14 ms·
Anatomy of a Moral Panic
- rdiddly 9y agoMinor additional point - if you're trying to create dangerous shrapnel, don't you pick something angular & sharp like crushed gravel, nails or even hex nuts, instead of nice round ball-bearings?
- ashark 9y agoBetter range/higher velocity with something more aerodynamic, maybe?
- maxerickson 9y agoIt's the energy that matters. A famous military anti-personnel mine, the claymore, uses spherical shrapnel. I guess that lines up with the other reply about the shrapnel being aerodynamic, something with less air resistance will have more range.
- korethr 9y agoQuite probably, and it'd probably be cheaper too; ball bearings are kinda precision things and the processes that make things like gravel or nails probably cost less. That said, if someone was really set on creating the opening scene of the movie Swordfish, they could make those ball bearings deadly if they got them going fast enough. A 3/8" ball bearing moving at a few hundred meters per second has enough energy to fuck up persons and property. I didn't pick those numbers completely at random -- 3/8" is about 9.5mm and common 9mm handgun rounds have velocities in the 300-400 m/s range. Edit: I want to call attention to other replies to this comment pointing out that ball bearings can be good shrapnel for other reasons I'd not considered. Today I learned a thing.
- agumonkey 9y agoThat's assuming a rational customer ;)
- s_m_t 9y agoThe chance of your nail hitting pointy side first is very low. A ball bearing, being spherical, will always deliver maximum energy to the smallest point possible.
- mmirate 9y agoTo use anything that's less symmetrical than a sphere as shrapnel, the munition must be designed to propel the shrapnel facing exactly one specific angle, because the shrapnel will have a bigger impact profile at any other angle. Ball bearings do not require such considerations.
- thaumaturgy 9y agoAnd now for the follow-up from Channel 4 and other media outlets: "hacker forum tries to find the best shrapnel for home-made explosives".
- influx 9y agoThat's literally the design of a Claymore mine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M18_Claymore_mine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M18_Claymore_mine
- eridius 9y agoIt looks like this is an unpublished post. It doesn't show up on the front page of idlewords.com, and isn't available as a "next" link from the previous story. maxerickson, how did you find this post?
- idlewords 9y agoHe subscribes to idlewords premium.
- maxerickson 9y agoTwitter.
- ocfnash 9y agoThis is a good piece but I have one nit: it is incorrect to say "thermite [...] will not detonate." I was shocked to discover this first hand some years ago: http://olivernash.org/2009/11/12/fun-with-thermite/index.html http://olivernash.org/2009/11/12/fun-with-thermite/index.htm... I can still recall the echoing boom of that (copper) thermite.
- idlewords 9y agoThank you for this correction. Do you know whether Al + Fe2O3 thermite as normally prepared (meaning, not ground up into nanoparticles) will detonate? I'll update the piece accordingly. Moreover, are you sure this was a detonation (shock wave) rather than a deflagration?
- jjoonathan 9y agoGiven that ocfnash's page never uses the term detonate, never discusses the difference between detonation and deflagration, and doesn't describe the experiments that would distinguish them, I'm pretty sure they were not in fact performed, and the (informal) explosion he witnessed was not a (formal) detonation. That's not to say it isn't worth a footnote to explain that "doesn't detonate" does not mean "won't go pop and propel burning material everywhere." Even a campfire can do that, but I could understand if someone heard "doesn't detonate" and drew the wrong conclusion.
- ocfnash 9y agoThanks for these helpful words of clarification! As I commented above, I was rather sloppily using the words "explosion", "detonation" to mean flash and boom. On the two occasions on which I witnessed this event, it was stunningly powerful but I now believe most likely just a deflagration.
- zzazzdsa 9y agoFrom a practical point of view, the only semi-common thermites that can actually explode are copper and silver. However, these thermites do not "detonate" as in the definition. They merely deflagrate extremely quickly, quickly enough to fool an observer but not in the true physical sense.
- brianjoseff 9y agoWho is making strides in fixing the underlying business model problems that are driving the increasing virulence and frequency of these moral panics, and undermining the integrity and function of journalism? Or at least providing alternatives that are equally profitable yet less pernicious. Because barring the entrance of one of these as-yet-unimagined alternatives, it seems we'll need to lean on regulation...but then we get into messiness of regulating free speech. There was Beacon Reader, the crowdfunding journalism platform, but they shut down. [1] Then there's Google's "Fact Check", but its reach is limited [2] [1] https://www.poynter.org/news/beacon-reader-journalism-crowdfunding-platform-closing-down https://www.poynter.org/news/beacon-reader-journalism-crowdf... [2] https://www.blog.google/products/search/fact-check-now-available-google-search-and-news-around-world/ https://www.blog.google/products/search/fact-check-now-avail...
- Analemma_ 9y ago> Who is making strides in fixing the underlying business model problems that are driving the increasing virulence and frequency of these moral panics, and undermining the integrity and function of journalism? Nobody, because the "underlying business model problem" is that, contra their stated preference, people don't want real journalism, or at least don't want it enough to pay for it. They want easily digestible fluff that validates the opinions they already have, and if they don't get that, they'll leave an angry pseudo-profound comment about "bias" and then go somewhere else where they can get more acceptable opinions. The internet is not lacking for such places. Facebook and Google are not blameless here, but while they are accelerating these trends by making the market more frictionless, at the end of the day they can't be blamed for the fact that people's revealed preference is for opinionated clickbait and not fact-checked serious journalism.
- dogruck 9y agoI've thought about this too. I agree with you. Another angle is that "real journalism" is fiction. Stronger than "people don't want it" is that it doesn't even exist. Suppose Zuck, Musk, Gates, Bezos, and Bloomberg pooled their cash, with matching funds from Uncle Sam, into a blind trust to fund "real journalism." What then?
- firasd 9y agoGood article. When I saw this I thought the UK press in general is really into panicking about the internet. Didn't they prompt the Youtube "Adpocalypse"? Not saying the concerns are irrelevant, but that the call-outs and subsequent remedies have to be well-considered.
- JauntyHatAngle 9y ago>When I saw this I thought the UK press in general is really into panicking about the internet. Didn't they prompt the Youtube "Adpocalypse"? No, that was primarily the Wall Street Journal that started that.
- ikeboy 9y agoIt does not take a lot of views for Amazon to link stuff together. I have a wholesaler dealing in closeouts (end of life products) that sends out emails with new inventory. I noticed once when looking at one item, that 2-3 entirely unrelated items showed up under "Customers who viewed this item also viewed", all that had been previously offered by the same wholesaler. I don't know how big their email list is, but it's probably in the double to low triple digits. So several dozen people, at best, viewed all of these items, and that was enough for Amazon to pick up and correlate them. A different time, I was advertising multiple entirely unrelated products with the same associates ID. One of them ended up, similarly, on the other item's page, presumably either due to the same people viewing both ads or them correlating by associate id.
- Gibbon1 9y agoI looked at pressure cookers on Amazon and for months was getting ads for full figured bras on other websites.
- vvanders 9y agoI used to do rocketry about 15-20 years ago, we had some pretty stringent requirements back then for the high power stuff(G+ impulse motors). I'm kinda surprised that the hobby hasn't been shut down completely given how hysterical some of the media can be about this stuff.
- Yossarian1 9y agoI'm pretty sure you can just buy black powder in the store for muskets. You don't even have to go through the trouble of buying all the ingredients off Amazon and mixing them.
- KGIII 9y agoIn most States that is true. NY has restrictions in it, and I think CA does. Federal law allows up to 50 pounds of the stuff, before you need a permit. You can buy it at your local outdoor/sporting goods stores.
- cl0ne 9y agoYeah, I used to do rocketry also and we had to get certification and FAA clearance to launch rockets with the high power motors.
- cisanti 9y agoWell written piece. I stopped reading news after Trump got into office and I have no shame about it. It feels great and I don't I miss out on anything. When people talk or ask me about politics I just say I don't know because I don't read. They make s surprised face and then continue talking and arguing about absolutely pointless topics and about the upcoming apocalypse. I just hope someone tells me an hour beforehand. I'd pay for a service that emails me only once s month and only about topics that matter. Just a brief overview. If I want details I can study history later.
- Cleisthenes 9y agoThat was your lesson from this? Stick your head in the ground and pretend politics is pointless? Ignorance of politics is a luxury afforded only to citizens of authoritarian regimes. You live in a democracy (assuming that discussion of Trump in politics means you live in the US). Politics is how society chooses to make and use government. People pretending they are morally superior or lead better lives through ignorance never cease to amaze me. This article talks about sensationalism in news. Sure, avoid it. Be skeptical of bold claims. But right now Trump and Republicans are talking about making gigantic changes to the nation's healthcare system. Regardless of where you sit on the fence, this absolutely matters. Pay attention. Find less sensational news. Pay for good journalism and also look for balanced analysis.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoPay for good journalism Where? He that is without sin among them, let him cash the first check. I’ve checked out too. The S/N ratio is way past what my filters can handle. I either need algorithmic filtering or noise attenuation. The fact is we’re all part of an intersubjective reality. It’s impossible for me to determine what is fake news and anyone who claims they can is fooling themselves or has primary sources.
- kermittd 9y agoOff topic but have you read Homo Deus?
- dwaltrip 9y agoIs there no robust way to hold publications accountable for carelessly peddling bullshit? I fear it will be incredibly difficult to improve the existing incentives.
- dom96 9y agoThis is a good question and I have given some thought on this. One quick idea would be to somehow shame publications for incorrect coverage, but doing so seems like an uphill battle. It will always be significantly easier to peddle bullshit than it is to disprove that bullshit.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoAlso, those publications almost by definition can outpublish you.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoSome gatekeeper like google would be needed to raise exposure by verifyability. The problem for a algorithm is to quanitfy truthfullness- it needs some feedback by the audience for that- and it needs to learn whos feedback is qualified. Doubt that even google could build such a curating search engine.
- chris_wot 9y agoThe UK has a press council.
- pmyteh 9y agoThe UK has had a succession of self-regulatory bodies which have conspicuously failed to prevent the worst criminal impulses of Fleet Street, let alone make an impact on merely poor reporting. It's also, interestingly, had some of the most outrageously claimant-friendly libel laws in the world, which hasn't made much of a difference either (though defaming somebody rich and bloody-minded can get pretty expensive).
- adrianratnapala 9y agoThe real story in this mess is not the threat that algorithms pose to Amazon shoppers, but the threat that algorithms pose to journalism. By forcing reporters to optimize every story for clicks, ... Because newspapers never did this kind of sloppy reporting before the interweb thingy.
- anigbrowl 9y agoI too was perplexed by that. Moral panics are the stock-in-trade of the sensationalist press, so blaming algorithms for speeding up what was already wrong with the media is kinda ridiculous. The basic problem is that there is a lot of money to be made by telling dramatic-sounding lies to people who want their worldview corroborated. News is a pretty competitive market, so it's not very surprising that the quality of news tends towards a lowest common denominator.
- edmccard 9y agoI think the point is not that some news outlets are doing sloppy reporting in exchange for eyeballs, but that all of them -- even those that used to be able to trade on their reputation for good reporting -- now have to chase the same eyeballs using the same tricks.
- avip 9y agoI see 2 claims: 1. The suggested materials are not for building bombs. 2. No one would be radicalized to build bombs by following shopping recommendations. Since uncharacteristically, he did not provide very good support to any of the above claims, I feel free to opt-in with my own made-up opinion: [1] is False. The materials ARE for building bombs. The "bearing balls" ARE what author says they are not (using an extremely unconvincing argument), and Mr idlewords is mistaken wrt how much data is used to build recommendations engines. [2] is True
- eridius 9y agoThe article did provide reasonable support for claim 1. Thousands or tens of thousands of people would have to buy the combination for it to be recommended, and aspiring terrorists don't usually purchase their terrorism supplies in a manner that makes it trivially easy to identify them (since Amazon knows who its customers are). The article also provided a far more plausible explanation for the recommendation than people building bombs.
- katastic 9y agoInteresting how >80% of the commenters are defending panics, or attacking the website or author itself instead of actually debating the findings.
- mikestew 9y agoWhat's to debate? There's a perfectly reasonable explanation for why product grouping was observed, and that explanation is far more plausible than imagining terrorists are ordering supplies from Amazon. Something something Occam. All we're left with is what you've observed. Or did I completely miss the point you're trying to make?
- nippples 9y ago> Interesting how >80% of the commenters are defending panics That's false.
- sixothree 9y agoWait, so will Amazon ship magnesium, iron oxide, and aluminum powder all in the same box? That sounds kinda scary to my layperson ears.
- Laforet 9y agoThe activation energy to get the magnesium ignited is rather high. There is little chance for them to spontaneously ignite unless the delivery truck is.gutted by a fire, and by then you have bigger problems than a kilogram of thermite.
- jfoutz 9y agoSounds like regexes. Now you have two problems.
- KGIII 9y agoAbout as likely as cooking ingredients somehow turning into a caked during shipping. Even an accident involving fire isn't likely to result in any additional risk. They get mixed in certain proportions and it takes some work to get them refined enough to be ready for ignition. Additionally, ignition requires a goodly amount of heat.
- zzazzdsa 9y agoMagnesium will only burn when heated to near its melting point of ~400 C, and thermite can only be set off at temperatures that would melt aluminum. Shipping them together is not an issue, unless the aluminum and iron oxide are freely dispersed in air.
- MarcScott 9y agoI used to "do" the thermite reaction when teaching secondary chemistry. It's actually a bugger to get the stuff to ignite. You have to stick a length of magnesium ribbon into the mixture, and I'd usually make a little well of magnesium powder that this would feed into. Then I'd use a Bunsen burner to ignite the ribbon, as often my lighter wasn't hot enough to ignite the ribbon unless I'd sandpapered the ribbon first to remove the oxide layer.
- Laforet 9y agoI might be wrong about this, but I think thermite is used more often as a simple welding method. Railroad workers doing track maintainence routinely use thermite to repair damaged sections. https://youtu.be/5uxsFglz2ig https://youtu.be/5uxsFglz2ig
- ekimekim 9y agoTrue, but I suspect they wouldn't be buying it on Amazon. The retail market means you need to look at hobbyist uses, not industrial.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoWhy would you buy that? Its just aluminium powder and iron-rust.
- mikestew 9y agoAs one who has not reloaded ammunition in a number of years, I’m going to guess that the only reason Amazon won’t sell you black powder (or gun powder) outright is due to shipping restrictions. Which means instead of buying the ingredients with a highly-trackable transaction from Amazon, your low-budget terrorist will have to resort to buying the powder pre-made, and anonymously in a cash transaction from the local gun dealer. Last I checked, they’ll sell you big cans of the stuff for cheap.
- zzazzdsa 9y agoAlternatively, the three components for gunpowder can be bought very cheaply and nigh-untraceably from hardware stores: potassium nitrate is stump remover, sulfur is used to reduce the pH of soils for gardening, and charcoal can be made from pyrolyzing wood in your backyard.
- Merad 9y agoBuying powder online isn't particularly difficult. It's classified as a hazardous material when shipping, so you have to pay a flat $25 (IIRC) per shipment. There's no shortage of online stores that will sell it to you all day by the 8 lb jug.
- pjc50 9y ago.. in the US, or the UK? I'm fairly sure you'd need an explosives license for more than the 100g ""personal experimentation"" limit, although I'm still trying to find a good canonical rules summary.
- mikestew 9y agoU. S., where there are enough people that reload ammunition that I made a pretty good bit of money back in the 90s selling software for that market. So, yeah, if you want to buy a couple pounds of the stuff, it’s not terribly difficult and no one is likely to think a thing of it (last I bought gun powder was probably ten years ago; take it as the dated information it is). EDIT: I also forgot that referring to smokeless gunpowder as just “gunpowder” is mostly a U. S. thing. But smokeless gunpowder is what I mean, in contrast to the stuff old school muzzle loaders use (black powder in the U. S.).
- gcb0 9y agothe talk missing here: accountability. reporters can screw up. like everyone else. heck in the IT security industry we have a mantra that you should not punish mistakes, because over time that makes people more prone to hide mistakes instead of disclosing. why isn't journalism the same? in the past they would publish erratas and mea culpas. now, they get the clicks, ad revenue, and on to the next "mistake".
- matt4077 9y ago"In the past"? I see multiple corrections per week, sometimes daily. They've started documenting even minor mistakes such as misspelled names. And mistakes that actually matter do have consequences, and not of the "don't punish" variety. See the recent firing of two CNN producers for publishing a story they later had to retract (something about some Trump associate's business dealings in Malta, I believe)
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> why isn't journalism the same? in the past they would publish erratas and mea culpas. They still do. But it doesn't matter (and I don't think it ever mattered) - if you lie on the first page, and next week put an errata on the second page in small print, that correction isn't doing anything. Most people will not read it anyway, and by the time it's printed, the damage to readers' cognition is already done.
- marter 9y agoDrivers scare me more than anything I see on the news.
- wolf550e 9y agoWasn't the "baseball test" an accepted norm in journalism? "A reporter should not be assigned to cover subject X unless he has as good an understanding of X as a baseball writer is expected to have of baseball."[1] Shouldn't media outlets be embarrassed into retracting stories written by people who know nothing about the subject? Shouldn't the reputation of the media outlet suffer? 1 - https://www.theatlantic.com/personal/archive/2007/08/the-baseball-test/54682/ https://www.theatlantic.com/personal/archive/2007/08/the-bas...
- kazinator 9y agoSo from this it follows, for instance, that a reporter assigned to cover baseball should have the same understanding as a writer writing about baseball: it is an assertion that there be a level standard of topic competence when reporters and writers are compared. But then under what condition should a writer not be assigned to write about baseball? (Unless he or she as knowledgeable about baseball as a baseball reporter?)
- dogruck 9y agoIt's an ilformed test. Can a writer truly understand baseball as well as a baseball player? But, isn't a baseball player bound to be heavily biased toward the consensus baseball view? Or, take finance. If a financial journalist truly understood finance, wouldn't they be running a hedge fund instead of scraping by pumping out articles?
- vonnik 9y agoIronically, the premise of this critique of journalism is as false as the Amazon story it cites. Algorithms and the Internet didn't ruin journalism, and this is not the end of the world. Journalism was corrupted by sensationalism as soon as it moved from subscriptions to ads, which in the US was in the 19th century. Remember when we discovered a colony of aliens on the moon? Yeah, that was the New York Sun way before we had electricity... Remember when Hearst started the Spanish-American war? No Internet then. Bad signals via the media is a very old problem. We should think about it, but we shouldn't think it's the Internet's fault.
- baxtr 9y agoFully agree. Reminds me of this: https://xkcd.com/1227/ https://xkcd.com/1227/
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoTo be fair, the snippets' chosen dates are from 1870s onward. Historians fuzzily date the start of the industrial revolution at around 1750. So that's about 100 years of industrialization and modernity. No wonder the art of conversation was considered dying by that point: it has been under assault from modernity for generations.
- schoen 9y agoAll of http://harmful.cat-v.org/journalism/gell-mann-amnesia-effect http://harmful.cat-v.org/journalism/gell-mann-amnesia-effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silly_season https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silly_season https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_journalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_journalism represent criticisms of the seriousness or competence of journalism, in various cases going back somewhere between decades and centuries. We should probably not think that there was ever a golden age in which all journalism was sober, cautious, and informed. But it also seems like the pressures facing journalism that Maciej points to are quite real. How can we get a better historical perspective on how well different kinds of journalism have worked over time? (I guess a similar problem confronts anyone who wants to criticize -- or try to redeem -- institutions that seem to be in decline.)
- Dove 9y agoIt boggles my mind that in such a connected age, getting accurate news should be such a hard problem. Never mind influencing the world - if I personally want to know what is really going on, I have no idea where to turn. Surely, surely, there must be a group out there that cares about accurate information and responsible research, to which I can subscribe? I am all for critical thinking, but having to become an expert in everything is wearying.
- vithlani 9y agoYou can turn to the Economist -- pretty much the only news organisation in the world that turns a profit with a major contribution coming from subscriptions and magazine sales.
- factsaresacred 9y ago> Missing in these reports is any sense of proportion or realism. Funnily enough I get the same sensation when reading Maciej's Twitter. Trump is going to go to war to approve his ratings, apparently. And it seems Twitter employees have an obligation to prevent Trump from using the 'Block' button. for some reason. Also, Peter Thiel (a pet hate/obsession) runs a company that 'powers ICE deportations' and needs to be ostracized for his beliefs. Some 'sense of proportion or realism' would be nice. That aside, great writing, as usual.
- pjc50 9y agoI don't really agree with the author's stance here. Especially since it was posted a couple of days after the inept bomb attempt on a tube train: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/09/20/parsons-green-two-men-arrested-bucket-bomb-terror-attack/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/09/20/parsons-green-two... Yes, it's a bit sensationalist, it's the news. Have you seen the UK news scene? This won't even be in the top 5 most misleading things said or printed in the news that day. Please also bear in mind the law on explosives precursors: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/supplying-explosives-precursors/supplying-explosives-precursors-and-poison https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/supplying-explosi...
- ufmace 9y agoIt's almost like we have a moral panic about moral panics...