8 ms·
You also have to look at the effect of UBI over generations. Children growing up with UBI may never see people close to them who do actual work. I once had a s
by maxxxxx 9y ago
You also have to look at the effect of UBI over generations. Children growing up with UBI may never see people close to them who do actual work. I once had a summer job at a welfare/employment agency. A lot of the people who received welfare in the second or third generation often had no idea how a job works. They were late all the time or just didn't show up for a week. The social worker had to explain to them how a job works.
I don't blame them. They just never had seen what people who have a job do. When I grew up everybody close to me was working so I could observe how a job works. And people who grow up around high-powered people like CEOs know how being a CEO works.
- nnfy 9y ago>A lot of the people who received welfare in the second or third generation often had no idea how a job works. They were late all the time or just didn't show up for a week. I dont understand. You have seen firsthand how entitlements ruin people, and you're arguing that UBI will be good for society? Edit: why the down votes? Are adults who do not understand the concept of a job not a problem? How else could so many of them live without this knowledge if they weren't being handed out the resources to enable them?
- Karrot_Kream 9y ago> You have seen firsthand how entitlements ruin people My grandfather received a very lucrative PhD offer at a very prestigious American university, but he didn't have the money to make the trip himself, and airplanes were much too expensive for him. So he found a ship in the harbor that was taking a passage to the US and volunteered to be a deck-hand. Now his grandkids, those in India and those abroad, drive cars, go to fancy bars and restaurants. I've never been a deck-hand in my life, and I have cousins who have never even seen a boat up close. It's easy for us to think that "entitlements ruin people" because it allows us to legitimatze our individual struggles, but it takes a leap beyond to comprehend whether our struggles should mean anything or are simply an artifact of the technology and logistics we have available to us.
- nnfy 9y ago>because it allows us to legitimatze our individual struggles Please. Have you ever lived in poverty? The people who climb out will tell you what other poor people are like. And I'm not just talking about poverty. Look at what former Soviets have done in NYC, especially Brighton beach. They live out of the projects but stereotypically drive BMWs. The average poor person is not your aspiring PHD father, its someone who wants a quick buck for the immediate future. UBI is textbook ivory tower politics. Poor people aren't just poor because they have no money, and by and large throwing more money at them won't solve anything. Now if you want to argue that the waste is worth it because of people like your father, thats plausible, but acting like UBI is the answer to poverty is absurd. Not to mention that you're essentially setting a demand floor which will "unnaturally" interfere with the economy. Another potential can of worms.
- Karrot_Kream 9y ago> Please. Have you ever lived in poverty? Yes, yes I have. I grew up in it. And most of my friends are struggling to make ends meet, working at restaurants, nail salons, and cafes. There's no glory in realizing that you can't make rent this month and you need to beg your landlord, or that after rent you have $50 leftover for a month's expenses. I've been there. > They live out of the projects but stereotypically drive BMWs. So you're using a stereotype to make your argument? Come on. > Not to mention that you're essentially setting a demand floor which will "unnaturally" interfere with the economy. Another potential can of worms. And you're arguing that supply is finite, which is the same fallacy that proponents of command economies often fall into.
- nnfy 9y agoI am not arguing that supply if finite, I am arguing that extraction of supply is finite and if you deincentivise millions of people from working while throwing money at them, you further reduce supply and exacerbate long term economic problems. >So you're using a stereotype to make your argument? Come on The argument could have been made without the stereotype, I agree. But it is an open secret in NYC that people, especially in Soviet neighborhoods, abuse the welfare system. I'll drop it though because I only have anecdata. If you lived in poverty, surely you at least caught glimpses of all the people who were not quite as noble as your friends? I do not deny that there are truly hard working poor who need a little extra to climb out. I merely argue that there is a much higher proportion of poor who dont care to learn or work than you are acknowledging, and those are the people who will ruin any UBI experiment.
- dang 9y agoYour comments are probably being downvoted (correctly) because they break the HN guidelines by posting ideological boilerplate and being uncharitable in interpreting others. We've had to ask you not to do these things before. Would you kindly re-read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and fix this? We'd greatly appreciate your help in raising discussion quality above that bar.
- thex10 9y agoHi, I’m someone who happened to both grow up on welfare AND watch zero people close to me work any sort of job ever. Your comment reads to me as an implicit argument against UBI. Is that your case? Allow to me comment from an insider perspective. - The welfare money didn’t cause the lack of work. They were not strongly related or if anything it’s the lack of work that drives the need to take up welfare. - It’s likely an extremely small minority of children in welfare-assisted families who see zero closely related adults working at all. - People who grow up without working role models do have a harder time learning the ropes on the work life, on that we agree. That doesn’t mean they’re doomed to fail completely. (Saying this as someone who had no idea how to do this right but eventually learned, went through grad school, now works in tech, outearns the median income in her city, etc). Also how do you explain the many underemployed/unemployed/deadbeat kids of successful high-status parents? The connection seems rather spurious to me. - Taking away the welfare money would do nothing to get someone employed. Instead it might endanger the family’s life. You realize that right?
- maxxxxx 9y agoI am not arguing against welfare or UBI. I am just saying the long-term effect may be different from what people are thinking. Especially at HN people seem to think all people on UBI will turn into artists or develop software all day. Maybe that will be the case but I have my doubts. "People who grow up without working role models do have a harder time learning the ropes on the work life, on that we agree. That doesn’t mean they’re doomed to fail completely. " People certainly can escape their upbringing but from my observation on average most people stay close to their social class. That doesn't mean that some won't do much better or much worse than their family.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- clarky07 9y agoThe basic problem with welfare as it currently exists, is that it actually provides disincentives to working. If you start working they take away similar amounts of welfare. You'd have to get a job that is way more than the welfare for it to make even a little sense. That disincentive goes away with UBI, which is the main reason I think it would work better. Under that system, every dollar you earn directly translates to a better standard of living.
- afpx 9y agoI don't completely disagree with you. I personally know two 2nd-generation 'trustfunders' who many would say don't do much. That is, they 'just' do leisure work. One plays poker part time, and he volunteers the rest of his time. The other promotes bands that she likes. But, are they really doing nothing of value? I think many people who meet them are sort of envious: seems like a nice life! I also know more than a few 1st-generation 'trustfunders'. Some are artists, some scientists, a couple work as university professors. They certainly are all doing useful work, right? Just look at HN as a case study. There are many people here (myself included) who could live off of their savings indefinitely. In fact, I've tried a few times. But, as others have pointed out, sitting around doing nothing is dreadfully boring. Once one removes the usual daily stressors (e.g. being able to pay for rent, food, kids, etc.), escapist behavior quickly grows dull. Believe me, when not required to manage stress, there is only so much Netflix one can watch and only so many video games one can play. I wouldn't worry about the vast majority of Humans doing nothing. People just do stuff. It just means changing perspective of what is valuable work. There are many types of work that are valuable to Humanity even if the market can't support them. Edit: just want to add that I would be concerned by younger adult males forming gangs. Their PFC's aren't completely formed, and they have raging hormones. In Christian western countries, it's a common saying that "idle hands are the devil's workshop". And, I find that true. So, young adult males, with nothing to do and risk-taking brains, tend to get into trouble.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pdfernhout 9y agoI wish technically-inclined people who could live off their savings would work on FOSS communication tools (e.g. FreedomBox, MatterMost, Matrix.org, Smallest Federated Wiki, or similar) to create viable alternatives to the centralized profit-driven communication and search systems created by venture capitalism. Or do whatever other worthwhile FOSS floats your boat like for educational simulations or whatever to be part of the gift economy. We desperately need alternatives -- and they are mostly not going to come from the surveillance capitalism culture (or its captive governance) which privatizes gains while socializing costs and risks (including costs and risks to privacy and democracy). And non-technically-inclined people with savings could help by promoting, documenting distributing, training, prettifying, and providing other support for such systems. And yes, I've put all my spare resources into that kind of FOSS technical work myself (although at the moment I'm once again working for pay to climb out of taking on debt to finish another FOSS project done with my wife -- this one called NarraFirma). Related by Alan Kay: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15261691 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15261691 "In the interview -- to say it again -- I'm not calling for the field to implement my vision -- but I am calling for the field to have a larger vision of civilization and how mass media and our tools contribute or detract from it. Thoreau had a good line. He said "We become the tools of our tools" -- meaning, be very careful when you design tools and put them out for use. (Our consumer based technology field is not being at all careful.)" See also "The Skills of Xanadu": Printed: https://archive.org/stream/galaxymagazine-1956-07/Galaxy_1956_07#page/n117/mode/2up https://archive.org/stream/galaxymagazine-1956-07/Galaxy_195... Audio: https://archive.org/details/pra-BB3830.08 https://archive.org/details/pra-BB3830.08 And yes -- a Basic Income would make that possible for everyone someday. But if you can live that way now, why not help create a more joyful and sustainable alternative right now? Isn't it plausible that our direction coming out of any Singularity may have a lot to do with our moral and technical infrastructure going into one? (Obviously, there are some paying jobs that align more closely with such ideals, but they tend to be few and far between, and if you have savings and take one, you displace someone else who might not have your options.) Also related by me on basic income: http://www.pdfernhout.net/basic-income-from-a-millionaires-perspective.html http://www.pdfernhout.net/basic-income-from-a-millionaires-p... http://www.pdfernhout.net/towards-a-post-scarcity-new-york-state-of-mind.html http://www.pdfernhout.net/towards-a-post-scarcity-new-york-s...