4 ms·
I think you overestimate how much the average person prepares for the future. Look at the number of people who have emergency funds. 62% of Americans have <$1k
by godelski 9y ago
I think you overestimate how much the average person prepares for the future. Look at the number of people who have emergency funds. 62% of Americans have <$1k and ~20% have no savings [1]. That number is too high to be explained away by necessary expenses. It is clear that people are just bad at saving. We can even look at the old game of "I'll give you a dollar today or five at the end of the week." Most people take the dollar today.
So with this time frame I believe initial ideas of "I'm going to put this to savings" will quickly disappear. Five years is a pretty long time, especially when considering at how bad humans are at preparing for the future.
What I think will be interesting is to see the different spending trends over time. I would imagine the first and last years are different than the middle three. But that's just a guess.
[1]
- hueving 9y agoThat's still not the same thing. Failing to save is partially because people think jobs are stable. That's unrelated to knowing you will need to get a job in 5 years after your extended basic income vacation.
- godelski 9y agoSaving $1k has nothing to do with your job being stable or not. That's a safety net for life. It is the basic emergency fund. Cars break down, people get sick, life happens. So to extend your premise, "Failing to save is partially because people think expenses are stable." Which is clearly poor planning. We know humans are bad about estimating risk. I'm not sure why this is such a controversial idea. What I'm saying is that if even those above the 50% income level are bad about saving a basic emergency fund, I don't expect those receiving this kind of grant to be any better at preparing emergencies. I do think they will be able to handle them better, but I do not expect them to plan better.
- aschampion 9y agoThe 60 percentile income is < $46k. That people have little emergency funds on incomes less than this is largely explained away by necessary expenses. 20% have no savings -- the 20 percentile income is $17k. Show me a net savings budget on $17k.
- godelski 9y agoThe median income is $57k/yr [1]. Or we can go to the second chart and get the following: 11.2% make under $15k. 20.8% make under $25k. 30.2% < 35k, 43.1% under 50k, 60.1% under 75k. The point isn't that the lower can't save, it is that people above the median income still don't save. These people should be able to save, but don't. [1] https://www.census.gov/data/tables/2017/demo/income-poverty/p60-259.html https://www.census.gov/data/tables/2017/demo/income-poverty/...