4 ms·
1) The total addressable market for a $1,000 breast pump might be outside of VC spectrum and more up small business financing or "Shark Tank" alley. 2) Women d
by prostoalex 9y ago
1) The total addressable market for a $1,000 breast pump might be outside of VC spectrum and more up small business financing or "Shark Tank" alley.
2) Women don't breastfeed their entire lives, so the units hit the used market pretty quickly, generating pricing pressure. Sales figures might look spectacular year 1, but what about year 5? VCs have access to market research data and executives at medical device companies who can probably provide them with better statistics.
3) Typical setup involves a hospital or a medical group buying a bunch of high-end pumps and renting them on a monthly basis (PSA for those who might need it: Kaiser Permanente will rent a breast pump to non-members).
4) Their main innovation seems to involve a different suction cup design that performed better for the target group they chose. How much a competitive moat is there? What's stopping Medela or a third-party parts supplier from building similar suction cups for a variety of breast pumps that's already out there?
- mc32 9y agoI think this has a similar potential as $1000 strollers. Most people will opt for something diff, but there'd defo be _some_ market for the devices.
- prostoalex 9y agoYep. Which is why Stocke AS history page boasts "3 generations of the Stokke family owned and operated the company", not "backed by prime Silicon Valley venture capital firms".
- lallysingh 9y agoA $500 pump is listed too. And people often have more than 1 kid. And this looks like a great baby shower gift. Or wedding present from pushy parents.
- prostoalex 9y agoAll valid points, but customer acquisition in that market is not zero. Amazon search results for electric breast pumps are 7 pages, many with 5-star reviews from verified purchasers.
- usaphp 9y ago> Women don't breastfeed their entire lives, so the units hit the used market pretty quickly, generating pricing pressure. Sales figures might look spectacular year 1, but what about year 5? I think people who purchase $1000 pumps are not the type who go shop on Craigslist’s for used breast pumps. Also number of first time mothers does not change year over year, so I don’t see a logic in your “1st year sales spike” point
- silencio 9y agoI have Kaiser and I am an exclusively pumping parent - the rental is through Apria and Kaiser covers it in full on an indefinite basis. The $1-2k+ Symphony as a free-to-$40-monthly rental, with a free (with ACA plans) basic-level pump, makes a $600+ pump a bit of a nonstarter to most people that plan to pump.