5 ms·
> any company storing SSN-type data owed some nominal amount (say, $10) to the owner of that data if it is compromised for any reason I think a company should
by criddell 9y ago
> any company storing SSN-type data owed some nominal amount (say, $10) to the owner of that data if it is compromised for any reason
I think a company should be able to avoid a fine if they disclose breaches immediately and are able to document that they followed best practices. From what I've read about the Equifax breach, they would definitely be found negligent.
- scrumper 9y agoWell no, because under jedbrown's scheme the insurance is there to pay the claim. Simple analogy: a homeowner still has to make a claim if their locked, alarmed house is ransacked while they're away. Insurance may subsequently deny the claim if it's shown that the homeowner failed to follow best practices, such as locking doors and windows. In other words, adherence to best practices is a condition of insurance.
- criddell 9y agoOk, I see it now and I agree. I think negligence or fraud on the part of the company should multiply the penalty and it probably release the insurer from being responsible.
- philipodonnell 9y agoThat documentation would already be available because they would have prepared it during the insurance underwriting process. And suddenly there would be a much more litigious and powerful entity on the side of protecting consumer data, the insurance company that underwrote the policy. They deny the claim and Equifax suddenly has a lot more problems.
- vec 9y agoNo, it needs to be strict liability. If an entity is as responsible as possible and still accidentally causes millions of dollars of damage, they've still caused millions of dollars of damage. Some things cannot be done safely, and if entities want to do them anyway they should be prepared to bear the consequences. It may be the case that once all the privacy related externalities are pushed back onto credit reporting agencies then their business model is no longer viable. I, for one, am fine with that outcome. If that's the case then credit reporting agencies were never a net good for society in the first place, and all the regulations are doing is exposing that truth.
- scrumper 9y agoNo, not in that case (your hypothetical responsible bureau): it's the criminals who have caused millions of dollars of damage. The insurance proposal creates the right blend of incentives to promote responsible behavior and punish - significantly - incompetence (i.e. denied coverage). To extend your thinking, consider air travel. Airlines act responsibly, even to the point of having government provide much of their security, yet occasionally terrorists manage to blow up aircraft. In that scenario, you'd have the airline be fully ('strictly') liable because of an external event they did everything to avoid. The harm is greater too - death is worse than ID theft. Truth is, nothing can be done safely. Not travel, not business. There is always a tradeoff between risk and benefit. Credit itself is an enabler for the economy. Credit bureaux facilitate comprehensible risk management, which allows for market forces to operate around interest rate setting reasonably effectively. Absent bureaux that same function needs to be performed, but it'll be done in a decentralized, ad hoc fashion by individual lenders which will impinge on their business models and ultimately drive up rates. So you don't like the bureaux; well, nobody does really. But what is an alternative which allows lenders to compare applicants on a like-for-like basis with some degree of confidence?
- rapind 9y agoWhen I fly, I'm aware that there are risks, and I choose to opt in when I buy a ticket. The risks are super obvious, and I'm the "customer". Not to mention airport security is pretty heavy handed and visible. Data gathering is usually not opt-in and it's also intentionally non-obvious who your information is shared with in most cases. I'm also rarely the customer, which means there's very little chance that my interests are being represented. Security or lack thereof is pretty hidden as well. I suspect we would find a way to fill the economic holes if every credit bureaux was phased out over the next 5 years. IMO, the entire vertical needs to be more transparent.
- scrumper 9y agoYou're entirely right on the first two points. But you do implicitly opt in by being a consumer of credit. I recognize that's a bit mealy-mouthed, since it's rather hard to exist in modern America without being on Equifax's radar, but nevertheless there is at least some illusory optionality. I completely agree with your final point about a need for greater transparency. But this is the situation we are in. I think the much more interesting discussion is about how those economic holes are filled, and it's why I posed that question in my note above. Of all the corners of the internet where you might expect such a solution to be proposed, HN is surely the best. What does post-bureau creditworthiness attestation look like? Presumably it's decentralized, to minimize aggregate harm to people in the event of a hack. Presumably it's de facto (and de jure) verifiable and correctable by each individual. It must also have some sort of graduated 'need to know' disclosure mechanism, with crude aggregate scores available to low-ranked creditors (cellphone companies, for example), and much more detailed information available to senior stuff like mortgage lenders. And why wouldn't it also have a facility, which didn't disclose creditworthiness data, for authenticating users to various services? But then why not go one step further. Why have this stuff in one place per consumer at all? Why not have lenders jus reach out over an API to every other lender to ask in effect "How good a debtor has scrumper, with SSN 01-234-5678, been for you? How long have you done business with her?" and get various answers back, all of which can be factored into some model which conforms minimally to a regulator-provided specification? The size or risk of the loan dictates the depth of that pan-industry query. Companies don't hold any more than they already hold, and there's no nexus for that data at all. And all the lender is allowed to keep is the model result, some sort of FICO equivalent, for a particular applicant.