The article false apart early because it is based on this premise: "There is no serious political theory according to which my pre-tax income is ‘mine’ in any m

The article false apart early because it is based on this premise: "There is no serious political theory according to which my pre-tax income is ‘mine’ in any morally significant sense." Stated in Paragraph 2. That's false, there's lots of solid arguments to suggest that your income belongs to you. To pretend that those arguments don't exist so that you can write a 3 page essay amounts to dishonesty.