5 ms·
Yes, this benefits Apple customers. I'm pleased. But it also attacks the revenue of the other 3 horsemen (Google, Facebook, Amazon). Which also pleases me. If
by specialist 9y ago
Yes, this benefits Apple customers. I'm pleased.
But it also attacks the revenue of the other 3 horsemen (Google, Facebook, Amazon). Which also pleases me.
If I was Apple, I'd mess with advertising, just because.
- caseysoftware 9y agoThat was my first (very pleased!) read on it at first but this snippet towards the end: > "When you visit a site, any cookies that are set can be used in a third-party context for twenty-four hours. During the first twenty-four hours the third-party cookies can be used to track the user, but afterward can only be used to login and not to track. This means that sites that you visit regularly are not significantly affected. The companies this will hit hardest are ad companies unconnected with any major publisher." Since the average internet user (aka not us) visits Facebook constantly and Google regularly, will this really have an impact at all?
- craftyguy 9y agoRight, no real effect for most users and ad publishers. Apple didn't really do much here.
- Xixi 9y agoI would think the average user visits Facebook through the Facebook app, not through Safari, so that should very much affect them. Google is a different story...
- apocalyptic0n3 9y agoNot on desktop, however. Safari for macOS is introducing the same functionality
- dpkonofa 9y agoRight, but isn't that the point that now they can't track you across sessions based on logins and things of that nature. If I use the app on my phone, they can't check my browser history against that and, on the Mac, they can keep my login information but they can't track me across sites. Seems like a win-win for users on both ends.
- kbenson 9y agoThe "unconnected with any major publisher." part is the major one. I would say this likely doesn't affect Google and Facebook much (it might affect Facebook greatly for me, since I use the site once every couple weeks). Who it does affect is shadier third party ad networks which have less well defined privacy policies. It also affects any fully legitimate and non-shady advertiser that doesn't have a web presence you want to visit regularly. So in that respect it punishes all the non-Google and non-Facebooks equally, which may or may not be a good thing. Google and Facebook may know too much about you, but I'm not really worried about them selling that data, which is some small relief. They are the ferryman at the river, and they charge to take advertisers to their audiences. They aren't in the business of selling boats.
- cgore 9y ago> Google and Facebook may know too much about you, but I'm not really worried about them selling that data, which is some small relief. Why aren't you worried about that? How about in 15 years when they've gone downhill and are looking for ways to make some quick cash?
- kbenson 9y agoLike I said, a small relief. To clarify, I'm not worried about them selling the data now, and I have hopes that there will be some headway made on the issue legislatively prior to them running into problems. It's not a good situation, but it's better than joe-schmoe-adtech right now offering to target me for $X, and outright sell all that info for Y x $X because they need to raise some cash fast. If we don't make headway on this issue legislatively and soon, I'm not sure it matters, as your profile information's privacy at all these sites has a shelf life in my eyes. Both sales and security breaches with exfiltration of data at random adtech companies will eventually lead to most this private profile data being publicly available anyway, so unless we put some strong limits on what can be collected, how it must be stored, notification of who is storing it, and the ability to review and remove items (and all of this at a minimum), I think it's a moot point who has it now, since everyone will eventually.
- exelius 9y agoApple knows this; in fact, I'd say it's their core business strategy. They did this before with the iTunes Music Store, and they will continue doing it as long as they exist. Apple focuses on the mass consumer as their sole and perpetual customer. This allows them to maintain laser focus on solving the problems of the end users rather than solving the problems of an advertiser and forcing the solution on end users. Apple's refusal to "innovate" on its business model has actually put them where they are today. Most other tech companies have other motives in making mobile devices: Amazon wants to sell you content, Facebook and Google want to show you ads, while Apple just wants to make the best damn phone out there and sell it at a very high price. If the market definition of "best damn phone out there" starts to include "protects your privacy", Apple doesn't have the conflicts of interest that Google or Facebook do. I'm sure everyone else will eventually follow suit, but Apple is the only one with the capability to take the lead on privacy.
- fhood 9y agoEven at risk of adding unnecessary comments, I feel compelled to tell you that this is the most insightful comment I have read all week.
- jeremy7600 9y agoMy response to this is: But they DON'T make the best damn phone out there. They DO sell it at a very high price. Samsung phones are light years ahead on features and being the best damn phone out there.
- butterfi 9y agoThis is somewhat subjective and misses the point that hardware isn't the only determining factor. If I was on the fence about which platform I wanted, the one with better privacy and a more secure app store is appealing.
- eumoria 9y agoI'd have to agree their hardware and software is lacking tremendously for tech users looking to use their phone exactly as they wish. This really isn't true for 99% of their userbase however. That being the case their ecosystem is very secure and their app store is slightly less of a dumpster fire than google play. Ultimately if you have the money for a premium phone and just need it to make phone calls, browse the web etc (the basics) then the iPhone really is the best option as it's more secure at the moment. The place where the iPhone doesn't sell to someone like me is the hand holding babysitting it does preventing you from manipulating the device as I wish. Again this is a non-issue to them. It can be frustrating to see someone overpaying for what you consider an inferior product but they're not using it like you are.
- notyourwork 9y agoCurious, how does this impact Amazon?
- criddell 9y agoI'm not 100% sure, but I think it's going to close the window available for them to retarget you with ads. I'm talking about the annoying practice of noticing that you searched for headphones on Amazon then you start seeing ads for headphones everywhere you surf.
- krausejj 9y agoRetargeting by brands/products who then sell via Amazon? (although if they're spending money on a sophisticated ad tactic i'd be surprised if they don't have their own site/store from which to sell)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ransom1538 9y agoOn mobile Apple removed IDFA (can be reset), UUID and mac address tracking. They are pushing hard to remove a way to tell if your mobile ads convert. On web apps, yes, removing third party tracking is also helps to remove any kind of accountability within your ad spends. This basically promotes dumb ad spends: you spend money without knowing if you get anyone to convert. This doesn't hurt google,facebook, et al, it actually helps them. Dumb money advertising is their bread and butter. (Pay per click / impression)