5 ms·
It's totally fine to think of taxation as theft, so long as you think of using public roads as trespassing.
by pavel_lishin 9y ago
It's totally fine to think of taxation as theft, so long as you think of using public roads as trespassing.
- patrickaljord 9y agoIt's only trespassing if you're not paying your taxes though.
- xmj 9y agoAre you saying poor people shouldn't use roads?
- krath94 9y agoDid they pay their "fair share"? See now you don't like that phrase...
- patrickaljord 9y agoPoor people who believe taxation is theft I guess if they want to be consistent with their belief. Although technically they could do some mental gymnastic and say roads are a product of theft and therefore it's ok to trespass.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoAre you saying poor people don't pay income tax?
- xmj 9y agoI hold title to the roads because I paid for them, whether voluntarily or at gunpoint makes no difference.
- telesilla 9y agoAgreed. Consider if theft if the total amount after deductions is more than is spent by the government on your ability to conduct business and earn a living. Start, for example, with your police whose existence I'd posit is a large reason you can fill a home with expensive goods and park a nice car in a driveway. Also: it's fairly easy to pay lower taxes with a good accountant. A cry to lower taxes is made by the elite to convince the middle class to vote for corporate-friendly interests.
- krath94 9y agoMost people that say Taxation is theft aren't literally calling for zero taxes though. It's just a saying, and definitely a hyperbole. There are definitely specific functions of the government that need tax funds. They should get the funds. But the amount we pay in taxes to the federal government is outrageous and most of us don't see a return on our "investment." The only people that 100% literally mean taxation is theft are anarchists.
- mannykannot 9y ago> Most people that say Taxation is theft aren't literally calling for zero taxes though. It's just a saying, and definitely a hyperbole. Then the best thing would be to just stop saying it, and discuss the substantive issues instead. The real issues of what functions need funding, by how much, and how, is a never-ending debate that isn't helped by trite aphorisms, even if, superficially, they seem to cut the Gordian knot.
- krapp 9y ago>The only people that 100% literally mean taxation is theft are anarchists. Because it is an anarchist argument which attempts to equate government to organized crime. Those hyperbolic anarchists are the ones using the term as intended.
- cvsh 9y agoAnd expect emergency services to reply "Fend for yourself!" when you call them
- throwaway2016a 9y agoFire should be paid for with property tax. Police and medical should be paid for by other taxes (probably also property tax but there are other solutions).[1] None of them should be paid for by income tax. I live in a state with no income tax that receives no federal funds (to the best of my knowledge) for fire and police yet I still have service... go figure... [1] Oddly enough as against taxes as I am, I don't think someone should have to pay a month+ income to get an ambulance ride to the hospital but that is a whole other can of worms unrelated to this article.
- krath94 9y agoWhen I say taxation is theft, I mean federal income taxes. I'd rather pay more to my state and local governments. I interact with those more local levels way more often and receive more benefits from them than from the federal government. States maintain their own roads.
- xmstr 9y agoAll states accept federal highway funds. Source: http://www.governing.com/topics/finance/gov-state-budgets-federal-funding-2015-2018-trump.html http://www.governing.com/topics/finance/gov-state-budgets-fe...
- throwaway2016a 9y agoThat is true but why the level of bureaucracy in the middle? Why not just give the states the money directly and bypass the federal government? Just because it is that way doesn't mean it should be. An obvious answer, though not satisfying, is that some states are too poor for that.
- krapp 9y agoThe rationale for calling taxation theft is the compulsory nature of taxation - which applies to states as well as the federal government. If taxation is theft, it doesn't cease to be theft when you like what the thieves spend your money on.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoAnd as long as you don't have any customers or employees, since taxation paid for their education, health care, security, et cetera.
- throwaway2016a 9y agoYour argument isn't valid because without taxation there would be no public roads to trespass on. At least not federally. And there are other solutions: - Tax property owners to pay for roads near their buildings - Toll roads - Private ways (actually very common in housing developments and usually work even better than public ones because the landlord / homeowners association is incentivized to keep them well taken care of to keep people from moving out) - Local income tax (something most libertarian's aren't against because living in a locale is a choice that is easier to change than, say, what country you are a citizen of) - etc An interesting mental trap people fall into is thinking that because currently something is paid for one way that taking away that source of income will mean it won't be paid for. The market has a way of working things out.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> Your argument isn't valid because without taxation there would be no public roads to trespass on. At least not federally. It's perfectly valid if I'm having the argument with someone who wants to pay zero taxes, but is fine using the roads currently in place. Now, if they're saving up to buy land in Montana and live off the grid - fine, they're trying to work their way out of a circumstance they didn't ask to be placed in. But if someone's an armchair libertarian who hypocritically feeds off the teat they claim to loathe, then I find their argument a bit harder to swallow.
- throwaway2016a 9y ago> It's perfectly valid if I'm having the argument with someone who wants to pay zero taxes, but is fine using the roads currently in place. I would find it hard to find that person even if I went to a gathering of Libertarians. Being anti-income tax is different than being anti-tax. Many Libertarian's are OK with (in one form or another): - Luxury sales and use tax (not on necessities like food and basic clothing) - Toll roads - Property tax - Local income tax With property tax being a little less common (although I am personally OK with it) because a lot of people will argue that if you have to pay taxes on it you don't really own it. Then again... I take that back... I WOULD be able to find that person at a gathering of libertarians but my personal experience is that he would be in the minority. Edit: to add to the lats sentence, perhaps a very loud vocal minority.