9 ms·
A 1979 War-Game That Takes 1,500 Hours to Complete
- greeneggs 9y agoWhere does the 1500 hours figure come from? According to Boardgamegeek, "Playing time with 10 players is listed at 1200 hours." At the top of the BGG page, play time is said to be 1000 hours. There is a thread in their forum asking if anyone has ever finished the game, and the answer seems to be no. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/4815/campaign-north-africa https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/4815/campaign-north-afri...
- afterburner 9y agoPlaying time predictions are usually on the low side. If the publisher is claiming 1200 and BGG is claiming 1000, then 1500 is probably a fair guess.
- hudibras 9y agoI would go so far as to say that playing time predictions are always on the low side.
- J_cst 9y agoYep we enjoy our pasta, a bit sad that we're always caged into this "pasta, pizza, mafia" storytelling :/ but probably it's our fault!
- jaggederest 9y agoI always thought it was kind of funny that Italy was famous for new-world and relatively recent concepts. Tomatoes definitively didn't exist in the old world before 1500ad and la Cosa Nostra only emerged in the 18th century, in the same vein as the Bow Street Runners in the UK. Of course pasta existed before tomatoes were available, as in things like Bolognese sauce, but it's still a strong association.
- thiagoharry 9y agoWell, Italy is also a new and recent country.
- J_cst 9y agoYep, only if you really believe that Italy's "birthday" is 1861... :) I humbly suggest that there's something more than that if you look closely!
- walterstucco 9y ago1870 is the real one, with the Capture of Rome when Rome was annexed to kingdom of Italy.
- J_cst 9y agoWhat people often refers to "Bolognese sauce" should be called "ragú" (tomato and minced meat).
- jaggederest 9y agoYeah, I'm not talking about the version that has any tomato in it. I'm talking about the stock-vegetable-and-beef-stew-on-pasta thing that predates it.
- tlb 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bow_Street_Runners https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bow_Street_Runners is a fine read
- nyolfen 9y agoi think the simple explanation is that these are elements introduced into american culture by italians
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Of course pasta existed before tomatoes were available Only a little over 300 years longer in Italy (where it did not originate.)
- firethief 9y agoWould this be less or more insane if transfered to a computer? It sounds like most of the tedium is computing and tabulating, but is that also most of the draw?
- digi_owl 9y agoThere is a reason why most early computer games were more or less straight translation of boardgames of this kind...
- WesleyLivesay 9y agoFar less. It does not seem any more complex than something like Gary Gigsby's War in the West and while it has a hill to climb if you want to learn how to play it, it is far from a 1500 hour game.
- Falkon1313 9y agoThere are absolutely computer wargames that can do this. Here's a Let's Play of War in the Pacific that was played at one day (real time) per day (game time) - for 1320 days. And as you can imagine, it can very easily take an hour or more per turn. https://lparchive.org/War-in-the-Pacific/ https://lparchive.org/War-in-the-Pacific/
- jakebasile 9y agoAnd here I thought the article would be about Monopoly.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dang 9y agoOk we put that in the title and added its year for good measure.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoPlease, no family play-through of Monopoly lasts for longer than three hours - that's the maximum amount of time before mom locks herself in the bathroom to chainsmoke, and dad begins to angrily saw apart random wood in the garage, leaving the children to form grudges that will last well into their 40s.
- sethrin 9y agoThe game's popularity is sort of ironic. It was designed to be unfair, in order to demonstrate the harmful power that monopolists accrue. That it results in the situations you describe could also be said to be by design.
- aidenn0 9y agoMonopoly usually goes pretty fast though; I've never had a game take longer than 2 hours. Are you auctioning off properties that the person who lands on declines to buy? Missing that rule tends to make the game take longer.
- drjesusphd 9y agoAlso silly house rules like putting $500 on free parking.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> they said ‘but we’re still playtesting it! We don’t know if it’s balanced or not. It’s gonna take seven years to play!’ And I said ‘you know what, if someone tells you it’s unbalanced, tell them ‘we think it’s your fault, play it again.’” I wonder if "have you tried turning it off and back on again" was in popular use for computers at this time.
- digi_owl 9y agoWell for home computers at least the way to get it to load a new program was to kill the power. The institutional ones probably had uptimes measured in months though. You didn't just reboot something that multiple people, including senior staff and tenured professors, may be using...
- zo7 9y agoIt sounds like this game was rushed, but it sounds like an interesting challenge: how do you design a game that takes a significant amount of time to play, while still ensuring that it would be balanced and engaging for all of the players throughout? There'd probably have to be some sort of computer simulation involved or some expedited way to play it, but how would you measure these things? Is it even possible?
- eternauta3k 9y agoRandomly sample game states, giving more weight to those that affect balance more strongly and/or occur more frequently.
- gwern 9y agoRandom sampling wouldn't work because it is the essence of cheese/game-breaking to go into rare or weird edge-cases and parts of state-space. Imagine a broken fighting game where you could win by simply executing 'upper block' the entire game; random sampling will be exponentially unlikely to sample a game with all upper-blocks. But if you used a mechanism like self-play reinforcement learning to explore the game state-space, your agents might autonomously discover game-breaking strategies on their own.
- hervan 9y agoI'd never expect anything lasting 1500 hours to be engaging (or fun) the whole time.
- mjaniczek 9y agoQuickCheck sense tingling!
- jerf 9y agoWell, a certain degenerate case of "balance" can be obtained with simple symmetry. It isn't quite the totality of what people mean by the concept because there are plenty of abstract games in which once one competitor has an advantage, they can inevitably press it home to a victory, and most humans would probably call that "unbalanced", even though in some sense it isn't. But still, a symmetric game certainly starts you off with a solid start in that direction. (Technically, perfect play in a non-randomized game determines the winner very rapidly, and even in randomized games there's a clear maximum probability path. However, perfect play is generally humanly-infeasible and may even be computationally infeasible; chess is a relatively simple game compared to most and we still don't know who wins or draws with perfect play.) Engaging 10 people for 1500 hours is probably effectively impossible, though. At that point you'd basically be selecting the people and building the game to match, if a solution even existed. (You may be thinking "Oh, but jerf, there are people who play 1500 hours of Team Fortress 2 and stuff", but my reply is that if you designed TF2 for this use case and picked 10 random people, even 10 random TF2 players, you'd have to be pretty lucky to get 1500 hours for all 10 of them. I'm sure there's well more than 10 people with that much time clocked but they're still the outliers, and you'd have a hard time naming them before the fact. Even with prior information about their addictiveness and tendency to stick with games.)
- SwellJoe 9y ago1,500 hours? That's nothing! These guys should give Civilization a go. (I say this only partially in jest. I've logged a few thousand hours playing the various Civs over the years. And, I'm not even a heavy player, compared to many.)
- sethrin 9y agoMy longer Civ games are usually 40 hours long. XCOM: The Long War is something like ten times longer. It's also brutally difficult. If you enjoyed Civ, I would strongly suggest checking it out. There's also a playthrough on YouTube by an Aussie who goes by 'beaglerush' which is both funny and full of good ways to not suck at the game.
- codingdave 9y agoIt does tell the tale of how gaming has changed over time -- 1500 hours was truly considered a lifetime of play a few decades ago. The article itself laid out what was considered reasonable - 3 hour sessions twice a month, with friends. Today, people can do 3 hour sessions twice a day. Alone.
- II2II 9y agoWould things have been different 40 years ago if solo gaming was practical? Getting half a dozen people together for 3 hour sessions is difficult to do once a week, never mind twice a day. Playing these board games alone would have been more of a research project than entertainment. I recall bringing a then-obsolete Mac SE into a private student lounge about 20 years ago. One of the games installed on it was Harpoon, which seems to be in the spirit of these old board games. Almost no one was interested in it. I had installed it because it was a novelty. One student played it ravenously. It leaves me wondering what computer gaming would be like if it focused upon detailed simulations rather than graphics and reflexes.
- codingdave 9y agoIf you think solo gaming wasn't practical 40 years ago, you weren't around 40 years ago. Those Atari 2600s rocked our world, man. But the change that really started to make people put games first in their lives was when it became social -- MUDs/MUSHes. When you could interact with other people through the game, that is when people started to play them all night and fail out of school because of them, etc.
- c3534l 9y agoI really want the rights to this so I can make it a videogame that only takes a few hundred hours to complete.
- catacombs 9y agoSomeone already beat you to it. It's called Hearts of Iron 4: http://store.steampowered.com/app/394360/Hearts_of_Iron_IV/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/394360/Hearts_of_Iron_IV/
- cyberferret 9y agoWow, and I thought our 8 hour games of Axis & Allies or Shogun were epic. I do remember one game of A&A which went for 3 days once. But a big factor of all those games was the banter and chatter that took place in between the play rounds - which easily took up >50% of 'game time'. Discussions about famous war heroes, tactics, politics, geography and purely made up stories to rationalise our game play was what made those sessions special, and stand out in my mind FAR more than the die rolls, cards or token that we had...
- jbattle 9y agoShogun was the best and the worst of those gamemaster games. I thought the flexibility of the rules (bidding for turn order, the ninja, experience for generals, etc) was way ahead of its time. But in our games, whichever player left the early game with the right side of the board was almost guaranteed to win.
- cyberferret 9y agoI always found that an odd number of players yielded best result with Shogun. With 4 players, it always became a 2 on 2 situation. With 3 or 5, there was far more interesting conflict and changing of fortune. I loved that every game was so different, but yes, the initial random deal of starting provinces could make or break the entire game. Also found that it made a huge difference if you went first in the first round, then last on every round afterwards. But even with all that, Shogun is still one of my favourite board war games ever. Still have my original set from >30 years ago, back when I think it was still a Milton Bradley game(?)
- panzagl 9y agoMy favorite story about Campaign for North Africa involves a, uh, 'innovative' solution to the POW problem. As the British roll back the Italians, management of POWs becomes a large problem, requiring the players to create POW camps in empty hexes and allocate units to guard them or else they can revolt (as mentioned in the article). Legend has it that one player was looking over the terrain and weather rules, and realized he could place the POW camps in hexes representing dry riverbeds. Come Springtime the hexes would flood, turning into regular river hexes, and freeing up valuable guard units for other duties...
- tptacek 9y agoSo basically Dwarf Fortress is tapping into something fundamental about simulation gaming.
- Falkon1313 9y agoI used to love epic monster board wargames in my teens. Advanced 3rd Reich was my favorite, and when played along with it's companion Empire of the Rising Sun could simulate all of WWII in about 80 hours or so - assuming you were completely familiar with about 2000 pages of rules and moving as fast as possible with little time for strategic thought. Realistically, it could run significantly longer. But still short enough that you could (and might want to) play it multiple times in a lifetime. (The current version, updated over the years, is called A World At War and lists a playtime of 48 hours.) Some of the very detailed air and naval tactical wargames back then could take an hour or so to simulate a few seconds or minutes of combat. I tried some of those and did not particularly enjoy them, but if a computer could help... My learning to program was significantly driven by making computer-aided-wargaming assistant software. But before long, PC wargames became more playable and I started turning to them instead. As an adult with work and family, I can't play the monsters or rivet-counters anymore. I have great memories of obsessing over them and all their details and possibilities. But even now that they're computerized, trying to fit all that information in my head, handle all the detail and micromanagement feels too much like work. Such games are works of art that provide a special place and time and some lasting memories for those who can get into them.
- bane 9y agoI have a friend, now retired, who's passion is these kinds of games. When he and his wife retired, they bought a house with a massive basement that he converted into a full-time wargaming room with space for 3 or 4 of these kinds of games setup all at once. Once or twice a week, he and a few other retired friends get together for a few hours and play the game. He has one game that's been going on about 3 years. His library of these games dates back to the early 70s and its really quite majestic. When you see the giant board laid out in its fullest, and the thousands of pieces each in their individual positions...you get the sense that these would be almost impossible games to really play adequately on a computer -- until maybe the hololens. The need to see the context of the entire battlefield is overwhelming that no amount of scrolling around a screen can really compensate for it. Another thing that's not clear for people from the outside is in many cases how scripted portions of the game are, and its really up to the players to spend a few hours following the script in between moves. This is supposed to simulate various historic battlefield conditions like new groups of units moving on and off the field as the real battle progressed, and the "play" happens within this framework. Very deep, very detailed, really fun in a way, and no way could I ever put the kind of time into it that it needs, even for "small" games.
- KGIII 9y agoSome trivia: TSR, original makers of Dungeons & Dragons, stood for Tactical Studies Rules. Rules for the study of tactics, specifically military tactics. They made wargames before they published D&D. Somewhere, I should still have a copy of Cavaliers and Roundheads. At least I believe it has survived all the moves.
- jaysonelliot 9y agoPlaying at the World by Jon Peterson is a fascinating and comprehensive history of the wargames that led to Dungeons & Dragons, and the early years of the roleplaying hobby. I highly recommend it for anyone that likes painstakingly researched details about the world of games.
- KGIII 9y ago
- classicsnoot 9y agoA few years back, some friends and I built a modification for Risk. From my (our) point of view the inherent conceit of Risk is that they more Ts you control, the more power you have, the easier campaigns become. Typical 19th century German thinking. The reality is that as you expand, costs go up not down. With great population comes great Tragedy. So our build included infrastructure and currency. We only tried it once. I have not spoken with one of the co-creators since those fateful three days (trans Arctic railroads, it turns out, are the stuff of ending friendships) but I kept a candle lit for the day when Hegemon would rise again. I have the rule book squirreled away on a HD somewhere. I'd love to give it another go. The core concept of the game was you go online, download the rule book for free, donate if you want, and use the pieces from other board games to play. If it caught on, we'd create an option to buy a custom made game (utilizing the Dymaxion Map and 3D printed pieces). Such are the dreams of youth.
- Pamar 9y agoEver considered using Kickstarter for a full edition?
- classicsnoot 9y agoConsidered and rejected for a few reasons: crowdfunding was a super negative experience for me on the one i was a part of. KS takes a pretty big chunk, one of the founders blew nearly 1/3 of our ask having to pay for all the stupid mother flipping TShirts and chotchkies for each different bracket of funding level, not to mention paying back all the bands and "artists" for their various contributions to the events that he ran to get the funding (the ultimate irony was that it was friends and family that contributed the most anyway, and that was in the final hours of the campaign). I know that these problems reside with our poor choice in founder(s), and it was for a film project, not a tangible product, but the whole affair left a bad taste and i would go with Indy Go Go if there was a next time. This may be conceited, but when it comes to film, i only want informed, intelligent investors and i want them to give a maximum so they have a stake, not a minimum so they have a badge of involvement. In my opinion, creators and producers need to be held accountable by investors. Getting 5,000 people to chip in $10 bucks feels like a bad thing in the long run for the world of indy film, but besides my previously articulated sentiments i don't know exactly why, i just have a negative gut reaction. Also, i want to be paid for something created, not rewarded for good marketing (which is probably why the Company keeps me chained up in the basement whenever investors are remotely close by ;) ).
- powera 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europa_Universalis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europa_Universalis is a slightly more approachable (and very slightly shorter) game along these lines.
- mcguire 9y agoBefore i clicked, i thought you might be referring to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Longest_Day_%28game%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Longest_Day_%28game%29