> Um, how about just reducing immigration a lot and giving it time? It's not that complicated. But not reducing immigration from most of Europe, right? And in

> Um, how about just reducing immigration a lot and giving it time? It's not that complicated. But not reducing immigration from most of Europe, right? And in turn should white Americans not be allowed to live abroad in most of the rest of the world? I should have refrained from saying "imbeciles", because that's not conducive to discussion and obviously there are some smart people like Thiel and yourself who end up advocating these ideas. It's hard to even begin a discussion about racial nationalism though, because I think it's pretty clear that the idea of race itself is scientifically shaky. I'd like to convince you though. But first, what exactly is it that you're advocating? And some questions I have... 1) Can you clarify your stance on immigration? 2) Can you give me a coherent definition of race? 3) What entitles one particular race (I'm assuming "white" people in this case) to predominate in America? 4) What if anything should happen to non-white people that are currently legal US citizens? 5) What should happen to Americans like myself who are married to non-white, non-US-citizens? Won't we end up in limbo with no place to go? I can assure you that I am not just looking for moral superiority -- I feel that my very wellbeing is threatened by the ideas that I hear espoused by racial nationalists. 6) Would you break apart the United States to give, for example, a black nationalist movement their own country? Seems only fair considering whites forcibly brought them to this country. And Native Americans? If so, what are the logistics of this and who gets what? 7) Do you feel that there is something fundamental connecting culture and "race"? What specific elements of the cultures of other races do you see as harmful? Are these differences fundamentally irreconcilable and why? Surely there are other white people (myself probably) who hold opinions that are equally divergent, so why not separate on that basis rather than purely on race? Again, I find myself halting while even typing out these questions because I have to keep referring back to this ill-defined idea of race. But, I guess the discussion has to start somewhere unless we plan on wiping each other out.