2 ms·
No worries, I don't take that as a personal remark at all. I agree with all of that. I agree (and I agreed when we discussed this before) that we have not achie
by dahart 9y ago
No worries, I don't take that as a personal remark at all. I agree with all of that. I agree (and I agreed when we discussed this before) that we have not achieved unconstrained realism yet.
I'm objecting to your claims that it's not possible. We can't check whether it's not possible. We can only verify that it has been done, after it's been done.
Nobody has done the experiment you've laid out. Not having examples that contradict you is not evidence that it can't be done. The criteria and claims you made are yours to defend.
I also counter that light transport, and specifically color multiplication, are not the problems getting in the way of realism.
It seems like you're intentionally discounting and ignoring progress in constrained realism. We have achieved some CG video that is indistinguishable from realty. Not hours of alligators in Thailand, or of people talking, but short videos of fruit bowls and architecture for sure. The dominos are falling, one by one.