2 ms·
Really? Sidewalks on every road is a big ask. There are a host of drainage issues that curbs/sidewalks create. It isnt as simple as laying down slabs of conc
by sandworm101 9y ago
Really? Sidewalks on every road is a big ask. There are a host of drainage issues that curbs/sidewalks create. It isnt as simple as laying down slabs of concrete. They need a base that is in some ways more demanding than that of the actual road.
- CydeWeys 9y agoI don't own a car. I barely know anyone who does. On the other hand, I do walk places every day. I can't even begin to describe to you how absurd I find it that you think sidewalks along every non-interstate road shouldn't be mandatory. When I was younger I lived in a much more suburban area than I do now, and when I stayed late for extracurricular activities in high school (two days a week) I had to take a different bus route home. The closest stop on that route was half a mile away from my house. That's not far at all, and I definitely don't mind walking, however, most of that walk was along a two-lane highway with no sidewalk that routinely had people cruising through at 45+ mph. The county has since thankfully put in some speed cameras to help enforce the 30 mph limit. Why didn't I deserve a sidewalk for my safety, exactly?
- TylerE 9y agoBecause it's expensive. Basic residential sidewalk is about $10 per sqft (and that's not counting the cost of land, which would be non-trivial). Typical sidewalks are 4ft wide. So your half mile walk home would cost $105,000, again NOT including cost of the land, planning, permitting, or anything else.
- CydeWeys 9y agoMeanwhile, a typical two-lane undivided road costs about $4 million per mile to construct. So you're not willing to add on a scant 2.6% to the cost of the road construction to also make it available for use by pedestrians? I'd much rather build 2.6% fewer roads and add sidewalks onto all of the existing ones. Keep in mind that far more than 2.6% of people don't even own cars, yet they do use sidewalks. The expense argument you're making does a much better job of justifying not building more roads than it does in justifying not building more sidewalks.
- TylerE 9y ago10% to the cost. That is for a half mile on one side of the road.
- CydeWeys 9y agoDo you have a source?
- TylerE 9y agohttps://www.homewyse.com/services/cost_to_install_concrete_sidewalk.html https://www.homewyse.com/services/cost_to_install_concrete_s...
- CydeWeys 9y agoThat doesn't say anything about the cost of sidewalk relative to the cost of building a road. And that's retail prices, specced out by square footage. When you're building sidewalks at the scale of entire cities it's definitely cheaper. You need to find a source that shows what the cost to the government is per mile of road versus mile of sidewalk. You can't compare retail prices of sidewalk that would be charged to homeowners to what the government is paying to build a road.
- s73ver_ 9y agoI fail to see how that's a bigger ask than putting the roads there in the first place.
- logfromblammo 9y agoIn my opinion, installing bicycle lanes and sidewalk is part of the job of building a new municipal street, in the same way that all modern limited-access highways need to have a breakdown lane on the shoulder and a crossover barrier in the median. If you can only afford to do it half-assed, maybe instead try harder on fewer linear miles of road.
- vkou 9y agoRoads themselves are a big ask. Sidewalks are a rounding error.