3 ms·
As long as the traffic limit is imposed by your device, or by content provider, this is not a network neutrality issue. However, if the filtering is done (even
by shkkmo 9y ago
As long as the traffic limit is imposed by your device, or by content provider, this is not a network neutrality issue.
However, if the filtering is done (even opt-in at your request) by the network, that is a network neutrality violation. Making that filter opt-out rather than opt-in is better, but both are still technically network neutrality violations
To come back to your analogy, this filtering is being done by your device. It is not being done by Apple directly so it is not directly analogous.
Indirectly analogizing to the intent behind Net Neutrality, there is a point to be made about giving established players more of an advantage. I am assuming that Apple is going to make this an opt-out option. That certainly lends weight to the concern that this can make Apple into a gatekeeper for advertisers / trackers. If this option were opt-in this would be much less of an issue (and have much less of an effect).
Other than opt-in vs. opt-out and market share, I don't see any fundamental difference between this and any other ad blocker or privacy protecting tool that maintains a white or black list.
- zlynx 9y agoIf net neutrality means the ISP cannot filter and shape at my request then I don't want it. You realize that reliable VoIP requires ISP side traffic shaping, right?
- shkkmo 9y agoI am unaware of any such requirement and can't find anything to back it up. As far as I can tell, the VoIP industry seems to widely support Net Neutrality so I would be surprised if this is a significant issue.
- zlynx 9y agoIf you don't have it then your voice conversations go to crap during heavy network use. It's very noticeable.