2 ms·
> Tulip mania was caused by the government changing futures contracts into options. The mania happened in these financial instruments, not actual tulip bulb pri
by justin66 9y ago
> Tulip mania was caused by the government changing futures contracts into options. The mania happened in these financial instruments, not actual tulip bulb prices.
This is obviously wrong: even accepting the premise of Thompson's paper, the popping of the bubble is blamed on what you've referred to but the mania (the inflated asset prices) existed for a very long time prior to that. In retrospect, the method of popping the bubble is really the least interesting part of that whole phenomenon (it's a given that those prices were going to crash) although I'm sure the people who experienced it did not feel that way.
- stretchwithme 9y agoIt doesn't seem to have gone on for very long to me: http://www.thebubblebubble.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Tulipomania.gif http://www.thebubblebubble.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Tu...
- justin66 9y agoStipulating for the moment that that chart is a chart, the phenomenon you sited as causing the tulip mania would have had to travel backward in time at least a year in order to do it. Perhaps we should agree that that is not reasonable. (I agree with your more important point that tulip mania and bitcoin are quite different)