4 ms·
Net neutrality is about ISPs. Apple is giving the end user control over how their own device behaves here. This is not a violation of net neutrality any more th
by mikeash 9y ago
Net neutrality is about ISPs. Apple is giving the end user control over how their own device behaves here. This is not a violation of net neutrality any more than me throwing away junk mail is a violation of the neutrality of the postal service.
- kodablah 9y ago> Apple is giving the end user control over how their own device behaves here. Are they? That's not really their approach to many things. It seems to me they are making decisions for users. I have nothing of note to say on this specific change, but we should be careful about where we want "neutrality" applied in our network go-betweens (be them ISPs, devices, whatever).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 9y agoIt’s an option you can turn off, so, yes, they are.
- kodablah 9y agoSurely we can acknowledge that control is not binary? There was no control that said "don't turn this on by default" or a control that lets me set the specific parameters of cookie sharing. The essence of neutrality concerns is the absence of control. Whether an ISP allows you to turn off the on-by-default traffic shaping or whether a device lets you turn off the on-by-default cookie restrictions is not the concern. It's whether these go-betweens make decisions for us, such as cookie sharing parameters, video downsampling, etc.
- mikeash 9y agoThe essence of neutrality concerns is the absence of control. Apple gives the user control over this, and many other aspects of the browsing experience. So... what's the problem here?
- xxxdarrenxxx 9y agoNo this is the postal company deciding for you which ads are not "worthy" enough, and not delivering them at all. This has nothing to do with net neutrality directly at all. The parallel it does share, is giving Apple a potential position of power to decide which data goes through and which don't. This is also the essence off the net neutrality debate. Their proposed "filter" could even very well be perfectly to my liking and in line with my personal standards for ads or how they are brought upon me. This is however about them providing a code, or at the very least a seed off their own for their machine learning algorithm to filter content. I like experiments, but I rather do not wish Apple or any singular entity for that matter to regulate my content. I do hold bias against Apple, because they have a certain position. They gave everyone phones, ecosystem for devs and patents and rights and indirect control to web frameworks through licences. Their might be conflict off interest. They have so much (acces to) people's data already through their devices and market influence, that I do not feel fully comfortable about them deciding that now the rest is not allowed to gain similar data.
- mikeash 9y agoApple is not analogous to the postal service. That would be Verizon or Comcast or AT&T or whoever. If they did this, it would be troubling.
- xxxdarrenxxx 9y agoIt is not literally analogous, but then you favor an argument about semantics over the actual argument at hand. People tend to default naturally to what requires the least effort to work; - This feature is default on their browser. - Other browsers are disliked or simply not used on IPhones for the big majority off users. - Their browser is realistically thus the main gate way used by people with Iphones to access the internet, aside from the social media apps. - At this early layer between people and the internet, Apple wants to place a machine learning algorithm, that decides which data is let through and which isn't. I am not sure about if I want them to have that position off power at all so closely to what is for many their main and potentially only access point to the internet.