3 ms·
Decimal itself is just a bizarre choice, most likely due to humans having literally ten digits. I think that's probably a myth and there's little reason to t
by wahern 9y ago
Decimal itself is just a bizarre choice, most likely due to
humans having literally ten digits.
I think that's probably a myth and there's little reason to think it's related to the number of fingers on our hands. People who count using body parts to keep track of multiples don't just use their fingers, but their knuckles, too, and sometimes other body parts. Lest you think that would naturally give rise to a power of 10, some extant systems only use the 12 knuckles of your four fingers--index, middle, ring, and pinky.
The 10 fingers explanation seems obvious only because of confirmation bias, representativeness bias, etc. Even a cursory survey of appendage-based counting systems makes the number 10 much less likely than we naturally think. Include all historic numeral systems and base 10 disappears into the mix altogether.
We get base-10 from the Hindus. Perhaps some ancient Hindu philosopher actually choose 10 because of our 10 fingers. But there's nothing obvious about it. As you amply point out, there's plenty of reasons to choose some other base, and plenty of civilizations did just that.
- jacobolus 9y agoWe get the strictly positional numeral system from the Indians. But base 10 was also used by people in various other places and some earlier (Greeks, Minoans, Egyptians, Romans, Semites, Chinese, ...) The source for most (all?) base ten systems was almost certainly finger counting, though I'm not sure how useful archaeological / linguistic evidence is about this in many cases.
- jandrese 9y agoIsn't knuckle counting and the like just a hack on top of finger counting, and finger counting would naturally lend itself to base 10 in humans. It would take some pretty extraordinary evidence to convince me that we use base 10 for a reason other than starting off with finger counting.