3 ms·
Why is anything against Telegram FUD but anything against Signal is clear sailing. I'm dubious about Signal, it has the same issues as most other encrypted com
by dijit 9y ago
Why is anything against Telegram FUD but anything against Signal is clear sailing.
I'm dubious about Signal, it has the same issues as most other encrypted communication channels (metadata leakage) but surely competition in this space is good.
Being "owned" by Facebook for me is a large red flag, as Facebook have an incentive to gobble up data- not saying the same is not true for telegram either- the only messenger I actually trust is iMessage but that's purely for reasons of: "Apple has no incentive at all to snoop".
It's not FUD to criticise Signal.
It's not FUD to question Telegrams crypto.
Holding Moxie and Durov to account for releasing servers that can actually be used would be a great help in being able to independently assess their claims. And even then, I might still err on the side of Durov purely for the fact that after doing what he did (telling the Russian government they couldn't do anything to Telegram) he fled the country, lost most of his fortune, his company. Etc.
- m3adow 9y agoCan you elaborate on the "owned by Facebook" part? I couldn't find any link between OpenWhisperSystems and Facebook apart from OWS helping WhatsApp integrating their Crypto.
- dijit 9y agoFacebook employs Moxie. I can't find public information about this interestingly but he's on the internal roster of employees.
- Vinnl 9y agoI can imagine that being some leftover from the days when he worked on WhatsApp integrating the Signal protocol, because he works for/leads Open Whisper Systems.
- evgen 9y agoOnce you are on the payroll as a contractor or FTE you are in the employee DB table and show up in the internal wiki as a current or former employee. Moxie was a consultant with the WhatsApp team to integrate the signal protocol (putting it into Messenger was done independently out of the London office without direct input from Moxie or his team IIRC) so he should show up if you do an employee search.
- lawnchair_larry 9y agoAre you sure that is an employee roster, or does it have contractors too? Moxie isn't even his real name, so it seems unlikely that it would be displayed this way if he were a real FTE.