9 ms·
>But it will increase usage. Not necessarily. When people really want something they will eventually find a way to get it anyway, it's not because you criminal
by ekianjo 9y ago
>But it will increase usage.
Not necessarily. When people really want something they will eventually find a way to get it anyway, it's not because you criminalize it that its usage drops. Just like IP infringement has not significantly dropped since they can put people in jail for it.
- everdev 9y agoWell, barriers to entry matter. If you're craving a drug and it's sold in a convenient store around the corner, you might purchase it more frequently than if you had to buy it from potentially dangerous people in a seedy part of town. That said, as with any bad habit I'm sure usage would still decrease over time for most individuals as they mature or if healthier alternatives are readily available.
- xahrepap 9y agoBut also, people who have addictions wouldn't be considered criminals so they wouldn't be so reluctant to get help.
- colejohnson66 9y agoBeing high is not illegal; Being in possession is
- joesb 9y agoBarrier to exit matters as well. When you buy it from dangerous people, you have to be in contact with dangerous people. It gives dangerous people leverage against you and people who care about you.
- alexasmyths 9y agoThere is no 'danger' from 'not buying stuff from your dealer' anymore.
- enord 9y agoI see you've never dealt with a dealer before.
- alexasmyths 9y agoI've known many a dealer in my lifetime, and a distant family member who spent some time incarcerated for 'high level' activity, who gives me long tales of how the business works as well. Dealers don't assault, endanger or attack random customers who just stop buying. That's totally absurd, and that someone would suggest it - indicates that they are getting their information from Netflix/Hollywood films or something, not reality. The vast majority of dealers are actually fairly normal people anyhow.
- enord 9y agoWell exuse me, I didn't know i was talking to a renneissance man. Addicts wheel and deal with each other, rack up debts to eachother, steal from one another. Some of them buy wholesale from larger distributors, usually with credit, to be repaid with interest or else. They rob, assault, rape and kill eachother over this stuff. I wish i was making this up. Doctors in emergency rooms usually have instructions to confiscate any illegal drugs they discover on OD-patients, but are faced with the very real dilemma of leaving the patient at their creditors mercy. This can cause real harm (as in "First do no harm") to the patient and their prospects of recovery or harm reduction.
- alexasmyths 9y agoIf you don't pay your dealer, that will cause pain, and possibly violence. But nobody is 'going after' someone who just decided to stop smoking something.
- enord 9y agoMaybe if that someone was just smoking pot and otherwise paid taxes. This particular group of drug users are not the central point of concern of the UN Special Assembly, even though its part of the wider problem. They are not dying in the streets and they are not socially marginalized. Allthough (anecdotally) i've known several fumb pot-smoking ducks who thought they could finance their proclivity through distribution and wound up several thousand dollars in debt to people who take names and chew bubble-gum.
- madshiva 9y agoThat can be anybody. Your old grandma, to this beautifull lady, or more common that guy in the corner, but not only "dangerous people" otherwise nobody will buy it.
- ianai 9y agoIf you tell people they can't skip in a certain lane on the sidewalk they will skip in that certain lane. There will always be people who just want to cross the line because the lines existence makes them curious or "rebellious". It's like a psychological balance for some people. Being told "no" really makes some people want something. The counter of this is why underage drinking is higher in the US than elsewhere. Society made it a taboo and that attracts people. In countries with lower age limits there's less underage drinking. The culture itself doesn't see it as such a big deal and there's no pent up against.
- ekianjo 9y ago> If you're craving a drug and it's sold in a convenient store around the corner But it goes with greater awareness of the risks as well, and once it's in the public, you can expect a lot more discussion about its usage rather than a too simple "it's bad" attitude.
- uoaei 9y ago>If you're craving a drug and it's sold in a convenient store around the corner Decriminalization means it's not illegal to possess, not that it's legal to sell. An important distinction in these sorts of discussions.
- kelnos 9y agoShouldn't it, though? Otherwise you still have the crime and violence associated with drug use. It's certainly better than having possession also criminalized, but is it good enough? I'm not so sure. I would suggest that maybe it's ok to continue to criminalize the sale of the more dangerous stuff, say of Schedule I drugs, but... well, marijuana is still on the Sched I list, so it's not like that list is particular scientifically rigorous.
- King-Aaron 9y agoI know this is an older article, but the Portuguese found that in practice, lifetime usage rates actually decreased following decriminalisation of most narcotics: http://content.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,1893946,00.html http://content.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,1893946,0...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- alexasmyths 9y ago"Not necessarily. When people really want something they will eventually find a way to get it anyway," No, not true at all. Supply and Demand. The 'cost' of doing drugs in society right now is pretty dam high. Social stigma, the possibility of going to jail, various professional licences lost. The 'free market price' of synthetic heroin and other drugs would be as cheap as sugar. Walk down to the local store and buy 1Kg of meth for $20. Jesus no. People are really un-pragmatic about this issue. I've had my exposure to it: a friend OD'd while in SF, another friend drug related suicide, and a third friend just fell in to a 'crack whole' for 20 years and now he lives full time in a clinic. Another - friend of a friend - has a 'weed' addiction (I know it's not common, but it exists) and he lives in a home as well. These people were ruined long before they ever passed away or went into a home. Selling crack or opioids in the corner store would instantly yield a massive public health crises. 'Legal' drugs - i.e. prescription drugs are already a major, major driver of the problem. Here in Canada - doctors are not required to give out the 'absolute minimum' of opioids after operations etc. You don't get 'a bottle' with 'refills' - you get like 3 pills. Why? Because there was a public healthcare crises developing even with legal substances. That's how strict they need to be, because that's what's on the line. If 'legal drugs' did not cause problems, then I suggest the massive amount of 'doctor shopping' and 'fake prescriptions' all over the US would not be resulting in serious problems, but they are. It's just one of those things - some people can handle their drugs - most people can't and fall down the slippery slide.
- RobertoG 9y agoNot saying that you are wrong, but I don't think you are right neither, it's a complicated issue. Addicts will pay, so, the price it's not a big influence in they taking drugs. It's a big influence in what kind of life they have. There are cases of rich functional addicts. Maybe, cheaper drugs would create more addicts, but we have the example of alcohol and weed in some places to examine. It's not so clear this is the case. Legal drugs doesn't mean, necessarily, socially accepted drugs. I think that makes a big difference.
- tomp 9y ago> The 'cost' of doing drugs in society right now is pretty dam high. Social stigma, the possibility of going to jail, various professional licences lost. Is it? I've never heard of anyone who wanted to try drugs and was unable to get them. Maybe it's different in the US, but in Europe, you can always find a supplier.
- Acalyptol 9y agoThe point being when you decriminalize it becomes accessible both to those who "really want" it and those who just would be curious to try it.