3 ms·
There's a whole class of drugs guaranteed to kill your child during pregnancy, and another where the interactions may seriously harm the child. Another where tw
by shakna 9y ago
There's a whole class of drugs guaranteed to kill your child during pregnancy, and another where the interactions may seriously harm the child. Another where two relatively harmless drugs, when interacting, can produce the previous results.
It isn't acceptable to just put the risk on the average, uneducated person, who is easily swayed by the way media portrays something. We have experts for a reason, which is to guide us in what choices are safest, or "best" in the current circumstances they face.
Here's a little example, which is fairly common:
Alice has borderline personality disorder. Most people don't notice, she just seems to be rather outgoing, and prone to depression and anger. Alice isn't sure she has it.
Bill, Alice's husband, convinces her to go to therapy, where the psychologist practices Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (as CBT is the only government-approved therapy), which has no affect.
Alice's psychiatrist puts her on quetiapine.
The amount is strongly controlled, because an overdose is very likely to be lethal, and one of it's known side-effects is suicidal ideation.
She gains 10kg in a month, and her mood is barely affected, but people feel more comfortable around her. The weight gain depresses her.
The psychiatrist moves her to lithium.
Alice finds she can live a normal life, and no one notices her being outrageous anymore.
Alice and Bill decide to have a child.
Here's the hard part of "best": lithium is class D for pregnancy.
It's probably the best medication for Alice though, who has demonstrated she is fully capable of being a normal and productive member of society.
The same problems will continue if Alice chooses to breastfeed, which is best for the baby, so long as they are careful around medications.
---
Neither Alice nor Bill are remotely qualified to determine what will, or will not, harm a child.
> We trust people to manage their own life
No, we don't.
We create laws, and regulations, to guide people into making safe choices.
Seatbelts are every bit as useful as a prescription.
- kobeya 9y agoSo have prescriptions and pharmacies. That's a separate argument from decriminalizion.
- vidarh 9y agoYes, but the argument made above made an argument about medicine that makes no sense if it was only talking about decriminalization.
- DanBC 9y agoWhich country are you talking about? This treatment plan for a person with borderlinePD is likely to cause harm. > where the psychologist practices Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (as CBT is the only government-approved therapy), which has no affect CBT is a short form therapy, normally about 8 weeks. Do not use brief psychological interventions of less than 3 months. https://www.nice.org.uk/donotdo/do-not-use-brief-psychological-interventions-of-less-than-3-months-duration-specifically-for-borderline-personality-disorder-or-for-the-individual-symptoms-of-the-disorder-outside-a-service-that-has https://www.nice.org.uk/donotdo/do-not-use-brief-psychologic... > Alice's psychiatrist puts her on quetiapine. Antipsychotic drugs should not be used for the medium- and long-term treatment of borderline personality disorder. https://www.nice.org.uk/donotdo/antipsychotic-drugs-should-not-be-used-for-the-medium-and-longterm-treatment-of-borderline-personality-disorder https://www.nice.org.uk/donotdo/antipsychotic-drugs-should-n... > The psychiatrist moves her to lithium. Drug treatment should not be used specifically for borderline personality disorder or for the individual symptoms or behaviour associated with the disorder (for example, repeated self-harm, marked emotional instability, risk-taking behaviour and transient psychotic symptoms). https://www.nice.org.uk/donotdo/drug-treatment-should-not-be-used-specifically-for-borderline-personality-disorder-or-for-the-individual-symptoms-or-behaviour-associated-with-the-disorder-for-example-repeated-selfharm-marked https://www.nice.org.uk/donotdo/drug-treatment-should-not-be... What Alice probably needs is a long form talking therapy. Have a look at Meeting the Challenge, Making a Difference for more information: http://www.crisiscareconcordat.org.uk/inspiration/meeting-the-challenge-making-a-difference/ http://www.crisiscareconcordat.org.uk/inspiration/meeting-th...
- vidarh 9y agoI don't know whether you or the person you're replying to is more correct, but it doesn't change their point: That these decisions are not something the average person should be making for themselves. If anything, your disagreement kind of makes the point even clearer. Maybe there might be an argument for people to be able to choose to obtain drugs like the ones mentioned by GP, but not without some kind of control-mechanism to at a bare minimum ensure they have been presented with the risks and have given some level of demonstration that they understand them. E.g. I quite like the mechanism now in place for online pharmacies in the UK, where you can buy prescription drugs like Viagra, or OTC but restricted products like Daktacort (combination anti-fungal and steroids), but need to convince a doctor (for the former) or pharmacist (for the latter) in writing that you've at least bothered to read what they've written about the drugs (since nothing stops you from just faking the symptoms, but you at least need to describe relevant symptoms free-form semi-coherently, or they'll do additional checks before selling to you). It has weaknesses, and certainly won't stop people from abusing abusable drugs, but it at least makes it possible to pick up on the most idiotic attempts at misusing drugs they don't even understand. Alternatively, I've used PushDoctor a couple of times - a UK service that connects you with an actual GP via video chat; the last time it took me 10 minutes from I scheduled an appointment until I'd uploaded pictures of a rash, had a conversation with the GP and had the prescription passed to a local pharmacy electronically; even if one were to consider taking away their "gatekeeper" role in terms of letting them deny treatments they don't think are necessary, I don't think it'd be unreasonable to still at least require a consultation like that for the most dangerous drugs to give an opportunity to at least inform.
- leksak 9y agoGood example