4 ms·
Does it make sense to include the lives saved annually for the life of the vehicle? or at least the mean time between failures of the cameras? Say the average
by TheSpiceIsLife 9y ago
Does it make sense to include the lives saved annually for the life of the vehicle? or at least the mean time between failures of the cameras?
Say the average reverse camera dies around 10 years after the vehicle is built. So maybe $14.30 per vehicle per year / $175 million per year to save 2100 lives over ten years. Or 150,000 accidental backing incidents over ten years (assuming ever one of those incidents can be prevent by a reversing camera, which is probably optimistic).
What about when the original owner sells the car secondhand and recuperates some of the original expense. What if we imagine new-car-buyers, when they sell their car secondhand, apply the value of the sale only to the safety features. Which isn't entirely unreasonable because when you sell a car the only thing you have left is the injuries and death it didn't cause.
Where am I going with this: the parent wrote about "amount of death we accept as a society just for the convenience of automobile", which is a popular trope but is false. We don't just accept it, we've done a lot to reduce road related death and injury, and we are, evidently, prepared to spend even more money and resources trying to reducing it.
- Aloha 9y agoOh yes, quite - and I'm not even questioning if reducing backing accidents isn't a noble goal, it is - I'm just questioning is this the most cost effective way of going about it is all. Improved tires, and mandatory seatbelts (as in included with the car) since the 50's have probably saved more lives than airbags however, as until recently airbags were only helpful for a very specific kind of collision.
- sokoloff 9y agoI think in steady state analysis (once backup cameras become ubiquitous across the in-service fleet), it's fair to analyze deaths in a year vs sales in a year, even if the deaths don't correspond 1:1 with model years.