4 ms·
"Those borrowers had made payments after being sued over loans that were legally uncollectable, either because the statute of limitations had passed or because
by greenyoda 9y ago
"Those borrowers had made payments after being sued over loans that were legally uncollectable, either because the statute of limitations had passed or because National Collegiate lacked the documentation needed to collect the debts in court."
This sounds a lot like what was happening during the financial crisis a decade ago. Lenders were selling mortgage loans to Wall Street to be bundled into collateralized debt obligations. After those CDOs got sold a few times, people lost track of who actually owned a particular loan. When borrowers defaulted, it was in many cases impossible to prove who was legally entitled to collect on the debt.
(A line in a spreadsheet that says John Doe owes you $500K is not very convincing evidence to a judge - you need to be able to provide a document with John Doe's signature on it.)
- roarktoohey 9y agoFlip side is paper documentation is poor UX.
- mirimir 9y agoYes, exactly the same problem. I don't get how lawyers could have signed off on bundling without documentation. I mean, databases can store BLOBs.
- tryingagainbro 9y agoCost vs benefit? The loss was acceptable enough maybe. Some of the loans are bought for 3 cents on a dollar...you get what you pay for
- mirimir 9y ago> ... bought for 3 cents on a dollar ... So some jerk is buying a $50K loan for $1.5K. But trying to collect $50K, plus fees and penalties. And ruining someone's credit in the process. That's insane.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 9y ago> After those CDOs got sold a few times, people lost track of who actually owned a particular loan. When borrowers defaulted, it was in many cases impossible to prove who was legally entitled to collect on the debt. Sounds fishy. The borrower was paying somebody at least up until he defaulted. Would not that entity be the one entitled to try to collect? Or were loans actually in default being sold around?
- derekp7 9y agoThey would be paying the loan originator (the bank where they got the loan from), who is still servicing the loan (in exchange for a fee from whoever they sold the loan to). But the original paperwork goes to the new owner of the debt.
- goialoq 9y agoNot quite, they'd be paying the servicer, whoever the loan holder contracted that to.
- ChuckMcM 9y agohttp://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/produce-the-note-defense-foreclosure.html http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/produce-the-note-defe... for some more detail. But it was, initially, a good strategy if you were being foreclosed to demand the person filing the motion could prove they held the note.
- KGIII 9y agoMy son got a letter insisting he owed money on his college loan. He never had a loan. I paid for his education without any loans. He asked for documentation and they stalled. I finally had my lawyer write a letter on his behalf and, sure enough, they had made an error and were deeply sorry for our inconvenience. Notably, they didn't offer to cover my time, his time, and the expense of the lawyer. I value my time more than I value money. I consider these things theft of my time.
- javajosh 9y agoDid you consider taking them to small claims court to recover your costs?
- johnvonneumann 9y agoThis, I don't consider myself a vindictive person, but financial vultures need to be punished.
- KGIII 9y agoNot really. The thought crossed my mind but I figured it'd just be more of my time being spent. I can make more money. My time is a finite commodity. I'd rather waste it on fun things.
- joering2 9y agoDidnt you think for a minute of your precious time that you had perfect opportunity to teach them a lesson and burn some of their money in the process? These scumbags dont exist because we dont have laws strictly prohibiting what they doing - they exist because only very tiny fraction of people they tried defraud will do something about it.
- KGIII 9y agoNope.
- 35bge57dtjku 9y ago