3 ms·
Are you referring to Champagne that can only be called from Champagne if it's from that area? Because it's different from the florist issue. The EU Protected De
by roel_v 16y ago
Are you referring to Champagne that can only be called from Champagne if it's from that area? Because it's different from the florist issue. The EU Protected Designation of Origin system was meant mostly to let local producers protect the local and artisan character of traditional products.
Florists probably argued the same thing that most professions that try to round the circle of the guild argue: the profession required special knowledge and for the sake of consumer protection we need to let only vetted people into the group. It's the same argument doctors use - yet I hardly ever meet anyone who questions the need for certification by a professional group or government of the medical profession (for the record I oppose such barriers to entry and advocate putting more responsibility with the consumer).
- sliverstorm 16y agoI was more specifically thinking of the requirements (depending on the country) for certain types of whiskey, beer, and IIRC some grain alcohols. I know the French do the same thing, but never delved into it because wines and cognac and brandy seem to be worlds more complicated.
- roel_v 16y agoYeah probably the same mechanism, it works and is administered on the EU level. It's used for many spirits, wines and agricultural products in the EU. An area close to where I'm from in Belgium even has a type of pie protected that way.
- hugh3 16y agoI appreciate your consistency, but you must admit that the consequences of hiring an incompetent doctor are much worse than the consequences of an incompetent florist.
- roel_v 16y agoYes I do. The question is where you draw the line. Once you admit that there are professions where certification / professional associations with legal rights to enforce entry to the profession / licensing etc. are needed or at least a less bad solution than the alternatives, the discussion will degenerate into everybody falling over each other to have their professions declared 'difficult' or 'a risk to public health'. Of course I choose the florist and the doctor because they're two ends on the spectrum, but where do you draw the line? Case in point: jacuzzi salesman. Doesn't sound like much of a problem, does it? Couple of years ago there was a show or trade fair of some sort around here where a jacuzzi salesman failed to disinfect the water in his sample jacuzzi. Salmonella developed in it, people walked by (thousands of them) and 10 or so died. Could this have been prevented with a licensing mechanism for jacuzzi salesmen? Probably. Is jacuzzi salesman a bigger health risk than florists? I don't know. Once a florist screws up and sells a flower with a fungus on it or whatever that they could've recognized, there will be calls for 'professional standards' and what not. Because of this slippery slope, I oppose all forms of registration. But yeah that probably means that there'll be some quacks who call themselves medical professionals. It'll be up to the patient to check if a hospital employs doctors who didn't go to medical school, or the mortality stats of a certain hospital. Let organizations like Consumer Reports find out who are trust-worthy and who aren't. I don't consider that a government job, let alone a job that we can reasonably expect the profession to self-regulate.