4 ms·
This looks like the start of a viable social network with very strong security. At one point I would have thought that's great, but now I find it vaguely alarm
by skybrian 9y ago
This looks like the start of a viable social network with very strong security.
At one point I would have thought that's great, but now I find it vaguely alarming. Maybe this is overly cynical, but I wonder what happens if it really starts to take off (say, growing towards Twitter scale). At what point does it become yet another social network that's degrading into a cesspool? And how do you get out of that state when everything is cryptographically locked down?
The lesson of Bitcoin seems to be that cryptographically irreversible actions combined with valuable digital assets (whether coins or, say, celebrity accounts) have a tendency to attract scammers and hackers, so you better be certain that your client machines can't be broken into and that you're immune to social engineering. And who is that certain?
I'll probably try it out, but I think undo buttons are really important. I'd be more comfortable if there were some trusted people who can roll back mistakes and fraud after they've been discovered and proven. (But, then again, how do we know they can be trusted?)
I guess this is all just FUD, but, hey, I'm feeling it.
- eridius 9y agoBut it's not a social network. There's no public posts, there's no leverage-your-friend-network aspect. Messaging platforms aren't social networks (e.g. Slack isn't a social network). File storage/sharing platforms aren't social networks. The only social aspect here is following other users and seeing who they followed/are following them, but that's just a trust thing, following someone doesn't e.g. expose you to posts made by them.
- jsjohnst 9y agoIf it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck. (PS, keybase has public, try --public flag on keybase chat send)
- eridius 9y agoHuh, I didn't know about --public. That's interesting. But that doesn't make it a social network. If Keybase had a mechanism to follow a bunch of people and automatically syndicate all of their public posts into a single stream that could be consumed by a desktop app, then this would be vaguely Twitter-like. But it appears that you have to manually query every individual user whose public posts you want to see, which doesn't scale to automatically following lots of users, which means this feature as-is isn't going to be used to clone Twitter.
- skybrian 9y agoIf you squint, a "team" looks a bit like a friends list. Couldn't everyone create their own? Depending on how big a team can be, how many teams you can join, and how easy it is to forward, this may just be a matter of UI and scale.