11 ms·
If Mozilla has any integrity, then I suspect Firefox might.
by yellowapple 9y ago
If Mozilla has any integrity, then I suspect Firefox might.
- bubblethink 9y agoWhat good is integrity if nobody uses Firefox ? That was the main reason they added EME support in the first place. Firefox staying relevant in the browser market is a better strategy in the long run than a hard line stance against DRM.
- dTal 9y agoWhat good is Firefox if it doesn't have integrity?
- kibwen 9y agoI can't tell if this is satire. Does anyone seriously believe that surrendering the war when you've lost one battle is an intelligent strategy? Mozilla contributes a whole lot to OSS, including providing a browser that can be trivially used without any black-box DRM-enforcement code hitting your system.
- dTal 9y agoI didn't mean to suggest I categorically disagreed with the decision, in this case. I simply note that you can't extend that logic indefinitely, or you lose the thing you're fighting for.
- thatzerodude 9y agoTrue that. Time to start using Firefox forks. Pale Moon, Iceweasel, GNU Icecat. Maybe go even further outside the box, use gngr: https://gngr.info/ https://gngr.info/
- yellowapple 9y agoExactly. The whole point of Firefox is to be the browser that actually protects its users. If I wanted DRM shoved down my throat, I'd be using Chrome.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoYou are free to run Firefox without the DRM module.
- wolfgke 9y ago> What good is integrity if nobody uses Firefox ? That was the main reason they added EME support in the first place. This was rather the point of Fall of Men ("Zeitpunkt des Sündenfalls") in Firefox' history to me. It was also the point in time where I stopped donating to them.
- sgift 9y agoAnd what's your solution (proposal) for the problem they faced?
- wolfgke 9y ago> And what's your solution (proposal) for the problem they faced? Make the zero-tolerance for DRM a unique selling point of Firefox.
- Sargos 9y agoI'm not sure "doesn't work with most major video sites" is an actual selling point.
- wolfgke 9y ago> I'm not sure "doesn't work with most major video sites" is an actual selling point. You just have to reframe it to something like: "protects you against websites that try to plant DRM-malware on your computer".
- emodendroket 9y ago"... And by the way you can't use the streaming services you pay for."
- kibwen 9y agoFirefox is, AFAIK, the only browser vendor that decouples the EME module from the browser, allowing the browser to be downloaded without any DRM support at all. See the various "EME-free" directories here: http://download.cdn.mozilla.net/pub/firefox/releases/55.0/ http://download.cdn.mozilla.net/pub/firefox/releases/55.0/
- HappyCynic 9y agoFireFox included closed-source DRM back in 2014. They've already picked their side.
- gcp 9y agoThe users picked by collectively not giving a fuck.
- AnssiH 9y agoFirefox has included support for EME DRM since 2015, despite it not being formally standardized. I don't see them dropping it even if the HTML standard Firefox follows drops them, unless other browser vendors drop EME too.
- riquito 9y agoMozilla ended up accepting EME in 2014, because otherwise it would have become "the browser where you cannot see videos" https://hacks.mozilla.org/2014/05/reconciling-mozillas-mission-and-w3c-eme/ https://hacks.mozilla.org/2014/05/reconciling-mozillas-missi... "We have come to the point where Mozilla not implementing the W3C EME specification means that Firefox users have to switch to other browsers to watch content restricted by DRM."
- wolfgke 9y ago> Mozilla ended up accepting EME in 2014, because otherwise it would have become "the browser where you cannot see videos" Rather: "the browser where you cannot see DRM-infected video" - which is an active protection of the user against malware.
- untog 9y ago...and which no-one will download. To be clear: if DRM is not implemented in browsers, Netflix and the like will just make native apps, which are far larger vectors of malware attack than the locked down EME standard is. I'm not saying this is a good thing, but "people should just not watch DRMed video" is not an actual answer to the problem at hand.
- wolfgke 9y agoSo you claim that Firefox (and other browsers) should implement malware or a malware interface into their browser so that users don't have a reason to download and install some other malware?
- untog 9y agoNo, I am saying that browser manufacturers should slightly increase their vulnerability surface area (and maybe not at all - I don't know the internals of EME) in order to provide a locked-down feature to users that they would only otherwise get by downloading a native app that has access to their local file system, amongst other valuable things. It's the same logic that leads to them to support JavaScript.
- azakai 9y agoMozilla opposed EME very strongly. But when it was clear that Google, Microsoft and Apple all supported it and were shipping it, Mozilla was forced to ship it as well (with a flag that makes it easy to disable for users that want to).
- wolfgke 9y ago> Mozilla was forced to ship it as well If anybody was forcing them, it were the media companies.
- kibwen 9y agoGoogle is also a media company. (Microsoft too, though Xbox isn't especially relevant here.) EDIT: Yes, and Apple, I completely forgot about iTunes.
- emodendroket 9y agoSurely we can count Apple among media companies as well.
- zizek23 9y agoMozilla is playing a double game of pretending to be on the users side while completely being in Google's pocket. For Google this ensures they cannot be accused of being a monopoly. And those working for Google attempting to divert attention to Hollywood are symptomatic of the reality distortion field and self deception of SV. Google is a spyware company engaged in mass surveillance and creepily following everyone on the planet for profit. There are no redeeming values here. SV is basically a gold rush with greed and money being the primary driver glossed over with dollops of pretension. The world just has to step up to take control and diminish the ideology that drives SV. So far be it open source, web services, standards or regulations there is no contribution. Why are there no alternatives to Firefox, Google, Facebook and others? You can't be completely dependent on these companies and then claim victimhood.
- ubernostrum 9y agoMozilla is not funded by Google anymore, and hasn't been for several years (the Google contract ended back when I was still working at Mozilla). If you're interested, I wrote up some notes/thoughts from my experience in one of the sessions about EME and whether to implement it: http://www.b-list.org/weblog/2013/oct/16/eme/ http://www.b-list.org/weblog/2013/oct/16/eme/
- zizek23 9y agoThat deal may be over but Mozilla still gets money from Google for search. Why is user advocacy so low key and half hearted, this being just one of them. What do they have to lose? They have consistently thrown in the towel while diluting the very things that users would choose them over Chrome for. There are many ways to exert influence in this world. Mozilla is in SV and is very much part of the culture and ecosystem. We need genuine alternatives and activism against entrenched interests.
- gcp 9y agoMozilla still gets money from Google for search. No.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]