4 ms·
Misleading title. While technically lawsuit names the requesters as defendants, what is implied - that they are under threat of civil or criminal penalties as r
by smsm42 9y ago
Misleading title. While technically lawsuit names the requesters as defendants, what is implied - that they are under threat of civil or criminal penalties as retaliation for requesting the info - is not what in fact happens. What in fact happens is that the agencies ask the court to keep the records unpublished. Which sucks, but it's not an action against the requesters - it's just an attempt to keep the records from being disclosed, and in no way threatens people personally.
It indeed sucks that you have to go to court, at your own expense, to defend your lawful right to see information that has to be public. But that has been the case for years, nonprofits like EFF or Judicial Watch has been doing this for years, supported by donations. There's nothing new in this.
- dclowd9901 9y agoI didn't know they had mechanisms like this to prevent divulging of public information, so this is definitely news to me. I don't think dismissing something you know to be true as "business as usual" helps. There's nothing misleading about the title: they are suing to prevent disclosure. Just because the immediate notion of lawsuit that comes to mind is associated with recuperation of damages doesn't make the title false.
- smsm42 9y ago> I didn't know they had mechanisms like this to prevent divulging of public information, so this is definitely news to me Well, the mechanism is simple - you send FOIA request, they decline it because national security, or some regulation, or policy, or it's too hard, or pick another of 10 thousand excuses they can find. Or they send you the documents with all text blacked out (that happened too). Next step, you have to sue, because while they can play any games they want with a regular citizen, with complete impunity, playing the same with a judge would be much more risky and only very well-connected people like top federal officials can get away with it. The rest would probably choose to comply. > I don't think dismissing something you know to be true as "business as usual" helps. I'm not dismissing it. I'm saying the title implied agencies retaliate against requestors by suing them, it is misleading - they are doing the same thing as before, clamming up and refusing to provide records. It is still important, but the title is misleading since it gives wrong impression about what's going on. > There's nothing misleading about the title: they are suing to prevent disclosure. But the title doesn't say that, and if somebody tells you somebody sued you, that's not the first thing you think of.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vilhelm_s 9y agoThe article strongly implies that this is a new development. What it talks about is government agencies who start a lawsuit instead of granting or denying a FOIA request. > State freedom-of-information laws generally allow requesters who believe they are wrongly denied records to file lawsuits seeking to force their release. If they succeed, government agencies can be ordered to pay their legal fees and court costs. Suing the requesters flips the script: Even if agencies are ultimately required to make the records public, they typically will not have to pay the other side’s legal bills.
- smsm42 9y agoOK, so that indeed is a new thing - they found a way to deny requests while not getting legal fees shifted on them if they lose eventually. This is indeed tricky and new. I just wish the article made it clearer that this is the reportable bit.
- Shivetya 9y agoyou should not have to pay the court costs to fight a system denying you access to public records. the agencies should be required by law to issue an exacting statement as to why the request is denied and reference a law based reason for that denial. As in, there should be an easily addressable list of reasons to deny a specific records request. going to court is outright intimidation
- smsm42 9y ago> you should not have to pay the court costs to fight a system denying you access to public records True, but that's what it always took if the agency you are asking is stonewalling (and they regularly do). As explained above, the new bit turns out they found a way to do it cheaper, so that they can avoid legal costs shifted to them (probably can be fixed by a law, but didn't happen yet).