4 ms·
Is it really necessary for the government to regulates? Why not have voluntary associations that people can join but have rules on business? If the organizatio
by kiba 16y ago
Is it really necessary for the government to regulates?
Why not have voluntary associations that people can join but have rules on business? If the organization have honest inspectors, their reputation will show. Businesses will pay for that kind of exclusive brands. Risk-averse customers will flock to it.
If you have an organization that everyone must join by law to practice certain field, then it could be a breeding ground for corruptions. The government is now intertwined with a professional organization, and then create an illusion of safety which none shouldn't exists.
Associations that has been around for years will have more trusts than new associations that pop up. The new associations will then prove that they're not kooks that been rejected by incumbent associations.
- carbocation 16y agoYou raise a valid point. I suspect that professional associations are neither superior nor inferior to government regulation. Perhaps it's best when both exist to the most useful extent necessary, and no more. (I guess that's a trivially true statement; sorry.) Government is susceptible to lobbying by interested parties (thinking about hoteliers vs Airbnb). Professional organizations are susceptible to antitrust (thinking about Wilk vs AMA) and perhaps to perpetuating the problem they are designed to solve.
- ohashi 16y agoGovernment often regulates when an industry doesn't regulate themselves. Sometimes you need the government to step in because the social cost isn't being borne by the industry.
- wisty 16y agoWell, the customers should be the ones who regulate industry. In some markets (medicine, food, financial advice, etc), it's very hard for customers to make informed decisions. In other markets, negative externalities are an issue. I think I can spot if a hotel room is clean or not. I doubt I could tell if the bedsheets had been properly sterilized, or if the shower was cleaned with bleach, but I can carry a sleeping bag and a pair of rubber slippers. Neighbors will complain about tourists partying till 3am every night, but that could be handled by the cops. They could raise some revenue by fining noise polluters, just like they fine people who break the speed limit.
- vermontdevil 16y agoNot always. Often government regulates on behalf of existing business in order to create barriers around said industry. This way the existing businesses continues to operate while newcomers are deterred. Look at cable tv, cosmology, etc.
- hugh3 16y agoCosmology? Is there a cosmologist's guild I don't know about?
- anamax 16y ago> Is there a cosmologist's guild I don't know about? Yes. Almost every "trade" has one. Every regulated one does. More to the point, every newly regulated trade had one that helped write the rules that they pushed through the relevant govt body.
- hugh3 16y agoAnd you're absolutely sure you're not getting cosmology confused with cosmetology?
- anamax 16y agoMy statement is true of both.
- wglb 16y agoSo what are the regulatory rules that apply to cosmologists?
- anamax 16y ago> So what are the regulatory rules that apply to cosmologists? No idea. However, we're discussing whether regulated trades have trade associations and whether those associations are involved in the regulations. No one implied that every trade was regulated, or even that every trade with a trade association was regulated.
- Confusion 16y agoWhy not have voluntary associations that people can join [..] their reputation will show This is an illusion. Are you going to check with what association your taxi driver is registered and have you done the necessary research upfront to judge the credentials of the association? If a taxi stops and it's from the 'wrong' association, but you know it's relatively cheap, are you going to send it away and wait for the next one? Especially services that an individual uses only very infrequently, such as a taxi, can get away with very poor performance. The businessman will tell everyone that the taxis in StateCapital suck, but a few months later, when he's there again for a one-off trip, he will have forgotten the name of the taxi service that rendered him such a bad service last time. However, commerce in StateCapital is harmed by all the gossipy remarks concerning one of their taxi services (which are remembered as concerning all taxi services in the city). Requiring taxi drivers to be licensed and checked on by the government could very well be a net advantage for all commerce in StateCapital.
- asmithmd1 16y agoDo you check to see if electrical appliances are UL listed? UL is private company that sets safety standards and tests products that manufacturers voluntarily submit for (and pay for) testing. Does a small mid-west town have the resources and and expertise to inspect the traveling carnival rides to insure they are set-up properly? Or does the carnival's insurance carrier handle that responsibility? There are private replacements for coercive regulation that are not theoretical but are actually working.
- Confusion 16y agoUL is private company that sets safety standards and tests products that manufacturers voluntarily submit for (and pay for) testing. Why do these manufacturers do that? Perhaps just as a lawsuit hedge: they can always claim to have been 'certified by the de facto testing standard', in which case it's the reasonable expectations laid down by the law that drive the interest in this 'independent' testing. I.e.: the government. Another explanation is that large brand A initially wanted to distinguish itself as 'the safest' and brand B just followed the lead so it didn't seem less safe. When they control a substantial part of the market, others will soon follow. After that, the actual contents behind the logo don't matter anymore. It's a perception-driven protection racket, the actual value of which cannot be determined by consumers. But it doesn't even matter how it comes about: after most of a market sports a certain logo or association, what's to stop that organisation from growing lax and pleasing their clients? There is hardly any room for competition in that market: who's going to start a UL competitor and why on earth would a brand be interested? Or, the more fundamental question: who tests the testers? How do you know the UL is not theoretical and actually working? Even the government suffers from corruption; I doubt such companies are any better.