3 ms·
i think the key here is the risk, not necessarily not practicing. its always good to boost you technique. its always good to know more rather than less. but, if
by the_cat_kittles 9y ago
i think the key here is the risk, not necessarily not practicing. its always good to boost you technique. its always good to know more rather than less. but, if you practice in such a way that you are trying to eliminate risk when performing, thats i think where you run into trouble. far be it from me to think i know more about this subject than rubenstein... but just my 2c. risk kind of seems like the empathic gateway with the audience, they can see that you are vulnerable, which makes the whole thing infinitely more interesting. its almost unfair that playing things perfectly makes them worse, because most people wont even know its hard or could have fallen apart.
- brooklyn_ashey 9y agodon't underestimate your own wisdom here. Rubenstein was just a guy who played piano a lot. You are right about vulnerability. But anyone at any technical level can reach for new stuff. Rubenstein was trying to romaticize something in an old fashioned, deep aubergine velvet sounding way. Of course he had his rep practiced to the point of row row row yer boat facility-- all musicians do who get paid to do it. The point is to have the courage to reach beyond what you have already mastered. Anyone can do this. He just says it in that old school arrogant classical master way-- like "i like to hold myself back from complete mastery so there is a little blood in it". My response to this is: oh Rubenstein! You nutty old master. It surely is ok to admit to everyone that you could not get to perfection if your life depended on it. None of us can, and it is totally cool to admit that. Back then, there was this "the Great Danton" mystique to the magical magical art of classical performership. It was the Harry Potter of then. Even his statements ate supposed to evoke the air of smoky mystery and genuis. Watch the Prestige for an explainer on this era of showmanship and life-altering commitment to this "performance". It is an anachronism. But just like in that movie-- people want to believe its magic. Dig?
- brooklyn_ashey 9y agobtw, pretty sure I know who you are, but won't out you. ;)
- the_cat_kittles 9y agoif you think im adrien holovaty you are wrong, and if you think im someone else im scared lol
- brooklyn_ashey 9y agodo you play violin? if so i do know
- the_cat_kittles 9y agonope :) ...but maybe well jam if your ever in seattle
- brooklyn_ashey 9y agook--- your id is secure then
- brooklyn_ashey 9y agoforgot to give you props and a chuckle.