5 ms·
If you feel strongly about this, you might want to read Cato regarding licensing for e.g. cosmetologists and taxi drivers. It is the same story -- pretexts abo
by patio11 16y ago
If you feel strongly about this, you might want to read Cato regarding licensing for e.g. cosmetologists and taxi drivers. It is the same story -- pretexts about the public safety justify anti-competition laws, whose effects are felt mostly by poor would-be entrepreneurs and the communities who they can't legally service.
- carbocation 16y agoThe taxi thing seems totally like a pretext, but cosmetologists engage in a lot of quasi-medical stuff that seems reasonable to regulate. Perhaps I'm mostly thinking of spas and their ilk, and honestly I'm probably mostly just thinking about the rise in community-acquired MRSA (which, to be fair, has not been shown to be driven by cosmetological practices at this point).
- houseabsolute 16y agoSometimes it might be better to wait and see if a problem arises rather than preemptively legislating it in a way that might do far more harm than the anticipated problem.
- carbocation 16y agoAbsolutely! Hence my strong agreement on taxis and my rambling uncertainty about cosmetologists.
- houseabsolute 16y agoI thought you felt that way, but I wanted to make it explicit for the readers because there was some ambiguity. :)
- carbocation 16y agoCheers; thank you for nudging me to express myself more clearly!
- gojomo 16y agoIndeed. And not only is it good to wait until problems occur, but it is also good even after a problem occurs to wait to see how businesses and their customers adjust, rather than assume that every new problem needs a regulatory solution. Once a problem occurs, and gets enough media coverage to drive regulation, it has also achieved enough awareness to become a point of marketing/competition/consumer-activism. That might be enough to control the risk, even without official state inspectors/licensors/bureaucrats. Especially in the modern era of costless sharing/archiving/finding of customer reviews and discussion.
- vermontdevil 16y agoThe state government is using this 'sanitary' issue as a pretext to intervene on behalf of the hotel industry that they have beholden themselves to.
- kiba 16y agoIs it really necessary for the government to regulates? Why not have voluntary associations that people can join but have rules on business? If the organization have honest inspectors, their reputation will show. Businesses will pay for that kind of exclusive brands. Risk-averse customers will flock to it. If you have an organization that everyone must join by law to practice certain field, then it could be a breeding ground for corruptions. The government is now intertwined with a professional organization, and then create an illusion of safety which none shouldn't exists. Associations that has been around for years will have more trusts than new associations that pop up. The new associations will then prove that they're not kooks that been rejected by incumbent associations.
- carbocation 16y agoYou raise a valid point. I suspect that professional associations are neither superior nor inferior to government regulation. Perhaps it's best when both exist to the most useful extent necessary, and no more. (I guess that's a trivially true statement; sorry.) Government is susceptible to lobbying by interested parties (thinking about hoteliers vs Airbnb). Professional organizations are susceptible to antitrust (thinking about Wilk vs AMA) and perhaps to perpetuating the problem they are designed to solve.
- ohashi 16y agoGovernment often regulates when an industry doesn't regulate themselves. Sometimes you need the government to step in because the social cost isn't being borne by the industry.
- wisty 16y agoWell, the customers should be the ones who regulate industry. In some markets (medicine, food, financial advice, etc), it's very hard for customers to make informed decisions. In other markets, negative externalities are an issue. I think I can spot if a hotel room is clean or not. I doubt I could tell if the bedsheets had been properly sterilized, or if the shower was cleaned with bleach, but I can carry a sleeping bag and a pair of rubber slippers. Neighbors will complain about tourists partying till 3am every night, but that could be handled by the cops. They could raise some revenue by fining noise polluters, just like they fine people who break the speed limit.
- tomjen3 16y agoOne could make an argument for both of those, but I have no idea how it came to be that _florists_ have to be licensed in Florida. Death to lobbyists.
- sliverstorm 16y agoPerhaps it was for the same reasons as why various countries have laws about what kind of alcohol can be exported under what name?
- roel_v 16y agoAre you referring to Champagne that can only be called from Champagne if it's from that area? Because it's different from the florist issue. The EU Protected Designation of Origin system was meant mostly to let local producers protect the local and artisan character of traditional products. Florists probably argued the same thing that most professions that try to round the circle of the guild argue: the profession required special knowledge and for the sake of consumer protection we need to let only vetted people into the group. It's the same argument doctors use - yet I hardly ever meet anyone who questions the need for certification by a professional group or government of the medical profession (for the record I oppose such barriers to entry and advocate putting more responsibility with the consumer).
- sliverstorm 16y agoI was more specifically thinking of the requirements (depending on the country) for certain types of whiskey, beer, and IIRC some grain alcohols. I know the French do the same thing, but never delved into it because wines and cognac and brandy seem to be worlds more complicated.
- roel_v 16y agoYeah probably the same mechanism, it works and is administered on the EU level. It's used for many spirits, wines and agricultural products in the EU. An area close to where I'm from in Belgium even has a type of pie protected that way.
- crystalis 16y agoInterior design has even taken up this torch! "Every decision an interior designer makes in one way or another affects the health, safety and welfare of the public. Those decisions include specifying furniture, fabrics and carpeting that comply with fire codes and space planning that provides proper means of egress. Additionally, interior designers deal with accessibility issues, ergonomics, lighting, acoustics and design solutions for those with special needs." His prognosis for the general situation doesn't look good: "My colleagues tell me that it would just seem silly to make a fuss over this; it is just not a serious topic. Yes we can't take seriously the idea of legally requiring a college degree to suggest where pillows go, but we also can't take seriously an economist who would focus on such a trivial and obvious point. [...] But if we cannot actually apply that knowledge effectively to obvious cases, what is the point exactly?" http://robinhanson.typepad.com/overcomingbias/2009/04/silly-consensus.html http://robinhanson.typepad.com/overcomingbias/2009/04/silly-...
- cabalamat 16y agoIndeed. Requiring a permit to do interior design is clearly a way of gouging the public, and societies need to have robust means to prevent it.
- jimbobimbo 16y agoI just recently had a conversation with a friend who does interior design professionally (not licensed though). At first my reaction was exactly - "that's stupid to require license for THAT". However, she made a great point - people confuse interior DECORATORS and interior DESIGNERS. You hire decorators to make certain taste decisions, but designer to design interior from ground up. Designer will make choice whether to put certain important things like, say, lights. I bet, you'd better have someone who understands how much lights your staircase must have.