6 ms·
I have wondered if the SEC could finesse this by saying "Ok, you can stick with your 'I didn't know' defense and we'll drop the insider trading case but we'll r
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
I have wondered if the SEC could finesse this by saying "Ok, you can stick with your 'I didn't know' defense and we'll drop the insider trading case but we'll require that the company separate you for cause and invalidate all post separation agreements." (aka the golden parachutes).
Since the benefits of such contracts often dwarfs the value they receive from trading it should help 'remind' them of what they did and didn't know. But they should not be allowed to have it both ways.
- leopoldo 9y agoInvalidate golden parachutes due to proven incompetence/negligence? I'll take that :) Though, I don't know if it's even gonna be an option on the table.
- smallnamespace 9y agoNever going to happen. Corporate boards are all stacked with C-level execs of other companies. These people went to the same business schools, socialize together, serve on boards together. It's a small world where everyone knows one another and I rub your back so you rub mine.
- HarryHirsch 9y agoA true meritocracy, in other words.
- vesinisa 9y ago... and earn 7 figures annually.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoIf you testify to the SEC that you didn't manage you division well enough to even know that basic security was being handled appropriately, as a shareholder, can I sue you for negligence? Cause it sounds like you're testifying that you're just not doing your job in any meaningful capacity, and I should be able to include that as a fact in a civil suit, since you swore in public record that it was the truth. Forcing them to testify that they didn't fulfill their duties to the shareholders in order to not be responsible personally for the breaches may introduce enough liability all on its own.
- ianai 9y agoYou can sue anyone for anything in our legal system. It's just a matter whether you have the time and funds and a good case, of course.
- SerLava 9y agoNobody ever asks if they can open a lawsuit against someone. They ask if an opened suit can possibly succeed. That is what "can I sue" means colloquially, one hundred percent of the time.
- colejohnson66 9y agoI wouldn’t say 100%; maybe 99.9%
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoI think so? Doing bad things and then not informing shareholders about it tends to turn "these guys should be prosecuted" into securities fraud cases.
- TCM 9y agoIts probably far easier to organize with your other shareholders to get that person fired. Suing is an option but you should probably try what I suggested in the mean time.
- greglindahl 9y agoNo need to organize your own lawsuit: https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2017/09/11/equifax-hit-least-23-class-action-lawsuits-over-massive-cyberbreach/653909001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2017/09/11/equifax-hit-...
- umanwizard 9y agoNothing forces the accused to testify about anything.
- ianai 9y agoThey need to go to prison and their company broken up.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI resonate with the sentiment but I expect taking away the golden parachutes of affected C level execs will go further to improving accountability than any amount of prison time will.
- Spivak 9y agoBut who would ever take a C-level position then? Since they're the face of the company they're fired ceremoniously as a PR move whenever the something bad happens.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoIn my experience a lot of people would take the job believing that they wouldn't allow something like that to happen on their watch. That said, you do have a point about the added pressure. Much like the '3 strikes' rule in California, the unintended consequence might be even more egregious and illegal behavior in order to avoid losing their contractual exit commitments.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoIf you kill their company, other companies will stop reporting breaches.
- gozur88 9y agoOr maybe they'll report in a more timely manner. They knew for the entire month of August a breach had occurred and they didn't report it. It shouldn't take more than a couple days. That's enough time to verify you had a problem and get a good picture of the extent. You might not have all the details nailed down, but you put out the information you know and say "We'll provide more details as they become available."
- scott00 9y agoNot exactly sure what you're driving at. If there's enough evidence that these guys knew despite their protestations to the contrary, it doesn't matter what they say. It's not like they need to confess to get convicted. And if there's not enough evidence, the SEC can't make companies fire its executives or revoke golden parachutes.
- int_19h 9y agoThe point is that if they claim that they didn't know better, and that is to be taken at face value, then they're plainly not competent to hold their jobs. So, if they testify that they knew - they're liable. If they testify that they didn't know, and SEC can prove otherwise - same as above + perjury. If they testify that they didn't know, and SEC cannot prove otherwise, then at least it is treated as them confirming their incompetence. So if they get, say, a bonus later, or a "golden parachute" for outstanding service on retirement, that is treated as evidence contradicting their claims.
- danjoc 9y agoNo. Jail + fine >= golden parachute.
- NTDF9 9y ago"Ok, you can stick with your 'I didn't know' defense and we'll drop the insider trading case but we'll require that the company separate you for cause and invalidate all post separation agreements." And a fine/penalty for not doing their job and putting so many lives at stake. They should literally be driven down to middle class mediocrity for their negligence. There has to be some example set for future transgressions.
- CWuestefeld 9y agoWhen did the government get the authority to tell a company who they can hire and under what conditions? Either there's enough evidence to convict those execs of crimes, or there isn't. If there's not sufficient evidence for that, then how can you suggest that the government should still have the authority to have them punished?
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThe US Government has always had that authority, the Government insists you only hire people who are allowed to work (by their rules) in the US, the Government insists you hire people without discrimination (regardless of how much you might want to), and the Government insists that when you hire someone you will will not exploit them in any number of ways. Further, the Government has given itself the authority to forfeit civil assets, whether or not they get a criminal conviction. Clearly it doesn't apply to non US governments but the government of the United States has all of the tools already at their disposal to unilaterally implement just this sort of policy. The policy question is a bit deeper than that, governing is ideally equal parts carrot and stick, and when there is clear evidence of a harm (and there is in this case) where it is impractical for the citizen to prosecute their own defense (could be debated either way) then the last line of defense for the citizen is the enforcement by their collectively empowered authority. That is perhaps the fundamental source of authority for any government.
- tclancy 9y agoYou're saying that like all companies are just widget manufacturers and who cares whether they succeed or fail? But some companies make their money based on a public trust and if you turn out to be abusing that, the government should come down on you with the full weight and measure of their power. We've spent so long in the middle and upper-classes of the First World kneeling at the altar of Shareholder Value we don't see any difference between Someguy's Ditch Digging Service and Arsenic Baby Votamins, Inc.
- jklein11 9y agoIf they fess up to insider trading do they get to keep their golden parachute? If not they wouldn't really have any more incentive to be cooperative.