12 ms·
Equifax Stock Sales Are the Focus of U.S. Criminal Probe
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoThese executives should volunteer to only accept from their sale of stock the value of that stock, 1 year from the date of their sale. The excess capital, if the stock has not recovered, should be given to non profit charities that support victims of identity fraud.
- jedberg 9y agoThe funny part here is that their defense seems to be, "no really we had no idea". Which may get them off the insider trading charge, but opens them up to one hell of a shareholder lawsuit.
- dingo_bat 9y agoAs it should be. That was the definition of insider trading.
- justinph 9y agoSomeone in Equifax was made aware of the breach on July 29, 2017. It defies common sense that the chief officers of the company did not learn of it until the same time as the general public, over a month later.
- bodz 9y agoI don't believe there's any claim that they didn't learn of it until the public announcement, only that they didn't know of it at the time of the stock sale which was on Aug 1st, only a few days after the breach was "discovered". Now, based on my experience, it's entirely possible that the July 29th "discovery" date only refers to the date on which some security analyst noticed abnormal behavior. That, combined with the possibility that Equifax doesn't have good security communication practices in place, it easily could have been a few days (or even weeks) before the security team looked into it enough to know the size of the breach and escalated it up to the C-suite.
- mfoy_ 9y agoI mean, on one hand, I wouldn't want this to go unnoticed and unpunished, but on the other, I'd rather that the feds be more focused on the actual breach part of things. Then again, was any part of the breach actually criminally negligent? Maybe this is the only real way that the DoJ even can go after Equifax...
- atonse 9y agoHopefully they can do BOTH.
- TheGRS 9y agoMost security standards are voluntary right? Based more on market pressure than regulation. It looks like the Fed is considering a set of regulations for large banking entities, which I assume Equifax would be a part of, but AFAIK the existing regulations aren't very robust and haven't been updated in recent years.
- bluejekyll 9y agoIs there anything the government has in regards to the storage of SSN? It could be regarded that the SSN is property of the Federal Government, i.e. the SSN Administration. Is there anything where they may have breached federal standards for storing federally owned data? Edit: for example, there is the fedramp set of compliance rules.
- tabeth 9y agoThe article itself doesn't make it clear how they will determine whether or not its insider trading or just a coincidence. Also, if there was a "bad vibe" at the company, but they didn't specifically know about the breach, would that be insider trading?
- fastball 9y agoAs with any insider trading case, they just need to prove access to the information. So either a witness needs to come forward and say "I told X to Y executive" or they need email/phone records which prove that such information was shared with these individuals. Unlike crimes like murder, insider trading is not predicated on intent, so proving intent is unnecessary.
- tabeth 9y agoInteresting. In that case, isn't all trading, given you work for an employer, "insider trading." If you see a bug opened on your company's GitHub and think it's crucial and sell all of your stock that's insider trading right?
- tfroseman 9y agoIANAL but I believe that the spirit of the law being that insider trading is when you use confidential/privileged information to decide your trades. In this case IF they knew about the breach and made trades before a public announcement then that is insider trading. As for github bug report, that seems like a legal gray area.
- matt4077 9y agoDid you choose GitHub because (most) repositories there are public? If that's the question, I'm pretty sure it wouldn't be insider trading, because by definition it wasn't inside knowledge. (Unless it required other, non-public data to know that the bug was important)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chollida1 9y agoI'm re minded of when baseball was pulled infront of congress and players were questioned about steroid use. There was one player Sammy Sosa who had for years conducted interviews in English who suddenly could not speak English when questioned by congress. This seems to mirror whats going on at Equifax now. The executives only way of staying out of jail is to claim that they suddenly have no idea what's going on not only in their company but in the case of the IT people, also in the very division they are supposed to be running..... Hmmm Time for Matt Levine to update his rules of insider trading to add rule 11, if caught insider trading after a a security breach don't try and claim that you as a C Level executive don't know whats going on in your own company.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI have wondered if the SEC could finesse this by saying "Ok, you can stick with your 'I didn't know' defense and we'll drop the insider trading case but we'll require that the company separate you for cause and invalidate all post separation agreements." (aka the golden parachutes). Since the benefits of such contracts often dwarfs the value they receive from trading it should help 'remind' them of what they did and didn't know. But they should not be allowed to have it both ways.
- leopoldo 9y agoInvalidate golden parachutes due to proven incompetence/negligence? I'll take that :) Though, I don't know if it's even gonna be an option on the table.
- smallnamespace 9y agoNever going to happen. Corporate boards are all stacked with C-level execs of other companies. These people went to the same business schools, socialize together, serve on boards together. It's a small world where everyone knows one another and I rub your back so you rub mine.
- HarryHirsch 9y ago
- S_A_P 9y agoAs obvious as these sales look like insider trading, I wonder if the execs are that ignorant and or greedy, or if this is truly a case of bad timing of large sales...
- mfoy_ 9y agoI wonder if, in an ironic twist, they try to play the ignorance card and use the breach itself as proof. "Of course we were ignorant of the breach, we're really just not on top of things, I mean, look at how we got into this situation, and how we handled it! Does that sound like competence to you? Of course not!"
- jedberg 9y agoThat would be a risky defense because while they may get off on the insider trading charge, they would open themselves up to a huge shareholder lawsuit.
- ransom1538 9y agoFederal officer: "Why did you sell the stock?" Equifax officer: "uh.." They will scrape through all their texts, emails, call logs. Someone will screw up somewhere. If they are dumb enough to provide a "SSN API" - I am sure their texts are a hilarious treasure trove. An easy slam dunk case.
- cddotdotslash 9y ago"I didn't want to tie up too much net worth in company stock and the stock had appreciated to a point I was willing to sell it." Maybe not too believable but to suggest they would have no answer at all is a bit naive.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jldugger 9y agoBut there's already 'planned sales' forms for this sort of thing and well, I hear these weren't.
- rdtsc 9y ago> Federal officer: "Why did you sell the stock?" > Equifax officer: "uh.." - "To buy a vacation home...". - "But why now?" - "Prices are going up so seemed right to jump in" The question can they reasonably refute that they didn't hear anything about the breach. If it has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt the lawyers might think they can convince a jury. They could say they were on vacation maybe and didn't receive any communication about. It is just that their cousin happens to be the college buddy of another exec but that might be tricky to prove.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 9y ago
- rdtsc 9y ago> looking into what executives knew Since it is a criminal probe the prosecutor would have to prove beyond reasonable doubt they knew? It would seem the executives who believed they could officially refute seeing the information would have done this. Some might have contacted their lawyer maybe and asked "ok so I overheard it in the hallway as I was leaving on vacation, didn't open my email or get any calls about it, what do you think, could I slide by and sell". In general what is the conviction rate for insider trading. It seems in general a hard thing to prove.
- mfringel 9y ago[IANAL] There's no trial yet, so it's about proving probable cause to go before a grand jury for an indictment.
- mythrwy 9y agoRight. Sadly I think they are very likely going to get away with it. They are almost certainly the kind of folks who planned this out and if there isn't any proof of knowledge, then there just isn't any. But it does seem inconceivable that they would have no knowledge of the event.
- ww520 9y agoIt's easy for the Fed to subpoena all emails, communications, and meetings of these people. It'll be easy to show the breach notice email sent to them, their replies, meeting agenda/attendees, and conference calls with their numbers. In these days of electronic work environment, there are so many digital footprint one left in the trail.
- rdtsc 9y agoI assume these are the sneaky execs who can officially claim they haven't opened that email. Individually each one thinks they probably have a chance o fooling the jury. I wonder how admissible the evidence that all 4 of them sold in the same time frame. Because individually (imagine there was only executive) each could argue that their case is just a random coincidence.
- tanderson92 9y agoNot addressed in the article: whether the SEC thinks the suspicious trading in Equifax options[1] is at all related to this investigation. People say "well, $1.8M isn't that much given how much stock they hold"; yes, but, if they were trading options as well then it becomes serious money: the profit on the suspicious options trade was $4.2M. [1]: https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/08/suspect-trading-in-equifax-options-before-breach-might-have-generated-millions-in-profit.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/08/suspect-trading-in-equifax-o...
- anigbrowl 9y agoI'm always perplexed by people's motivations for advancing that argument. The notion that the criminality of your actions depends on whether or not you're already wealthy (other facts not being in dispute) seems like the essence of corruption.
- sjbase 9y agoJust a friendly reminder that due process is a thing in the US. Let's allow some time for the texts, emails, testimony, etc. to come out. Everyone seems to have reached conclusions about this on very suspicious circumstances, but almost zero facts.
- bluetwo 9y agoTrue, but from what we do know, a full investigation is warranted.
- mikedouglas 9y agoDue process is a legal concept, and fundamentally, a restriction on the state (for very good reasons). I think it's fine for commenters on an internet board to use P(crime was committed|shady trading patterns) > 0.5.
- eanzenberg 9y agoDue process for punishment applied from public gov't bodies. However, people can and will reach conclusions based on the evidence laid before to make their judgements to whether be Equifax customers or not. I realize this may seem like mob-mentality or mob-rule but there's some nuance here. When you see such gross negligence do you wait until hearings and court judgements which can easily take years before voting with your wallet?
- glitcher 9y agoIndividual consumers did not choose to be Equifax customers, and as far as I know there is no way for me to "opt out" and effectively have all of my data removed from Equifax (including all future data).
- mabbo 9y ago> ... its president of U.S. information solutions, Joseph Loughran;... > ... discovered a security breach on July 29... > ... sold shares worth almost $1.8 million in early August... > ... didn’t know of the breach at the time You're the president of U.S. information solutions and you didn't know about the largest information breach in your company's history a week later? If that's true, that speaks more to the problems in this company than the actual breach itself.
- bodz 9y agoFYI the "President of US Information Solutions" at Equifax is a role that has nothing to do with their IT/security department. It's not the same thing as the CIO or head of IT, as many people are confusing him for. He's the head of a product line which is called "information solutions". The head of IT/CIO is a completely different person (who has since been fired/resigned).
- mabbo 9y agoAh, a very good point. I'll give him a little bit more benefit of the doubt if that's the case. The FBI might not, mind you.
- cmiles74 9y agoI'm not interested in giving the benefit of the doubt to a C-suite executive who cashes out about a week after the company suffers one of the most newsworthy data breaches in recent history. To my mind, they are in exactly the right position to know about this sort of thing. For sure, an investigation will be forthcoming and, in this country, one is innocent until proven guilty. But it seems, in my opinion, exceedingly likely that we'll find an email or text or some bit of ephemera notifying these people of the breach. If not, well, I will eat my hat.
- conductr 9y agoHave you worked at a BigCo or know what it's like to be in senior leadership? I would not be surprised in the least if this guy had no clue about the hack. These organizations are huge. People are actually very tight lipped when these things happen. You are/should be told not to speak about it even with your peers. I also wouldn't be surprised if he did know, but just wanted to emphasize these BigCo org charts tend to be insanely big and complicated. At the senior levels you may not talk to or see your boss for weeks; especially when some big shit like this is being uncovered. So totally possible he knew nothing.
- ww520 9y agoMartha Stewart insider traded with a far much less amount and went to jail afterward. These Equifax people need to go to jail.
- tanderson92 9y agoMartha Stewart did not go to jail for insider trading.
- ww520 9y agoI know it's about her lying to the Fed, and what are these people doing now with the Fed? Unless they taking the 5th, they are lying.
- mikeyouse 9y agoShe went to jail for lying to Federal investigators about the stock sale. It's impressively difficult to convict and jail people for insider trading.
- Top19 9y agoWhat’s even more disgusting is that behind the public’s back all of these guys brag about this sort of behavior. I was reading a book published in 2008 called “Zero Day Threat: The Shocking Truth of How Banks and Credit Bureaus Help Cyber Crooks Steal Your Money and Identity”. The main bad guy lobbyist of that book, Eric Ellman, who is now the head of the credit reporting lobbyist group (http://www.cdiaonline.org http://www.cdiaonline.org), PROUDLY DISPLAYS his portrayal in that book on his LinkedIn. http://linkedin.com/in/eric-j-ellman-0a33857 http://linkedin.com/in/eric-j-ellman-0a33857 He basically doxxed himself.
- Bucephalus355 9y agoThat website you linked says it’s goal is to “educate consumers”. How can anyone believe this bullshit anymore. That website was out of date by 1996. It looks so bad. They don’t care at all.
- guelo 9y agoIn the timeline of events that Equifax released [1] it says that they took the web app down on July 30 and contacted an external cybersecurity firm on August 2nd. The managers unloaded their stock from 7/31 to 8/2. It doesn't sound believable to me that the managers could be unaware of the hiring of an external security firm, or that the company had shut down one of their major web applications. [1] https://investor.equifax.com/news-and-events/news/2017/09-15-2017-224018832 https://investor.equifax.com/news-and-events/news/2017/09-15...
- bodz 9y agoNone of the managers had anything to do with or were in the chain of command of the security team, so it's entirely possible they had absolutely no idea about the breach until long after 8/2. The CFO is the one that is a little iffy, because the CFO might be involved in the hiring of the external firm. However, having worked for security consulting firms, it's also entirely possible that the CISO is given a blank check for this type of stuff without having to get CFO approval. I've worked in plenty of organizations doing cybersecurity work where the C-suite (including CIO, CFO, etc) was completely unaware we are there because they don't have to rubber stamp every single transaction. It's also a possibility that the 8/2 date on which they "contacted" the firm was just when discussions started between the two parties, and it might have been a few days before a contract was ironed out enough to involve the CFO or anyone else. There's a bunch of other possibilities/scenarios in which I think it's entirely believable that they didn't know. It's shady and worthy of investigation, yes, but I'm not willing to convict them just yet.
- tryingagainbro 9y agoOh, yeah that's the real crime. Give them 6 months in jail. (USA can chew gum and walk at the same time, but where is the probe for the breach...? 143 million people terrorized and most likely thousands will have their life turned upside down because of it.)
- modeless 9y agoPerhaps if these guys get nailed then companies will start to see the value of disclosing security breaches in a timely manner instead of sitting on them for months while they spin up the PR machine.
- bodz 9y agoHaving worked on the incident response teams for these types of breaches, the "PR machine" is only part of the reason why companies "sit" on the info. It also takes a long time to do investigations on the breach to know what was stolen, how much was stolen, and how to mitigate it. The FBI also gets involved in breaches like this, and sometimes they'll ask to put off announcing the breach while they do their investigation of it as well. It doesn't do anyone any good if you release a statement as soon as you notice abnormal behavior that just says "we might have been breached and our customers may be affected, but we don't know who is affected and we don't know how it affects them yet".
- cannonedhamster 9y agoNot to be pessimistic, but I'm surprised that anyone even being considered for insider trading, it's legal for Congress to do it, why shouldn't rich people be able to do it? It will probably end up the same way as the credit default swaps, rich people trying to flip houses, banks selling shady packages to the middle class, and the US taxpayer providing a bailout and poor people getting the blame. The idea of justice or consumer protection in the US is a joke.
- rhizome 9y agoIf "securities violations" is the only legal jeopardy Equifax executives are subject, we are truly screwed. The US needs a DPA, or at least its residents do. The government couldn't care less.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoIn the United States, insider trading is not a crime of a specific statute. Instead, it's charged as a breach of fiduciary obligation [1]. Whether the executives in question knew of the breach at the time they sold is irrelevant to whether the company, in allowing this sale to occur, misled the investors who bought those shares since the company, at the time of the sale, had awareness of the breach. [1] https://www.sec.gov/fast-answers/answersinsiderhtm.html https://www.sec.gov/fast-answers/answersinsiderhtm.html Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. This is not legal advice. Do not ever insider trade.
- 0xfeba 9y agoUnless you're a member of congress... https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130416/08344222725/congress-quickly-quietly-rolls-back-insider-trading-rules-itself.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130416/08344222725/congr...
- mtviewdave 9y agoEquifax's Q2 earning report came out after hours on Wednesday, July 26: https://investor.equifax.com/news-and-events/news/2017/06-28-2017 https://investor.equifax.com/news-and-events/news/2017/06-28... with an investor conference call on the morning of Thursday, July 27. Any public company I've worked at has had a trading window that opened a day or two after an earnings report came out, with most people who want to trade trading early in that window. Admittedly I've never been an executive and I don't know how the rules differ for execs, but the dates when these trades took place are when I would expect Equifax employees to execute options and sell stock. It also strikes me as possible that information about a security breach discovered on the weekend might not make its way up the company hierarchy for a few days, and that execs might not have been aware of it when they traded. I do think this should be investigated by the SEC, but I'm a little disappointed at the rush-to-judgement in this thread.
- ams6110 9y agoIn many companies, if they don't have a CTO, the IT division reports to the CFO. Is that the case here? If so, hard to believe he didn't know about the breach very soon after discovery.
- SilasX 9y agoRight. I also seem to recall the internet hive mind researching this when the story broke, and those same executives had been selling for months on a particular schedule and these trades were right in line with that schedule, and they still held significant stock in the company. Can't seem to find ATM though...
- markbnj 9y agoI can believe they kept this pretty quiet inside the company while they figured it out... but I have a really hard time believing the CFO was out of the loop.
- cdjk 9y agoI think the more interesting issue is the 2600 put options at $135 that were purchased on Aug 21: https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/08/suspect-trading-in-equifax-options-before-breach-might-have-generated-millions-in-profit.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/08/suspect-trading-in-equifax-o... I wonder if the 2600 number is significant or just a coincidence.
- vijayp 9y agoHow do these execs not have 10b5-1 plans set up?! Many companies require them for all senior managers. http://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/rule-10b5-1.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/rule-10b5-1.asp
- blueside 9y agoNot a popular opinion, but should insider trading be legal? It seems to create a false sense of security, that people inside the company aren't going to do bad things. Many people have made their fortunes on some degree of insider trading that they wouldn't have made otherwise. Wouldn't the markets be more efficient without this mirage?
- whatthesmack 9y ago> Not a popular opinion, but should insider trading be legal? Isn't this legal for members of the United States Congress? I can't recall the specifics, but seem to remember some special exemption for them from insider trading rules.
- 1mike12 9y agoWell congress itself seems to do abnormally well on their stock portfolio. They have some absurd return beating the indices by a wide margin. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/05/24/members-of-congress-get-a_n_866387.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/05/24/members-of-congress...
- FireBeyond 9y agoYes, members of Congress are not prohibited from making stock trades based on information they learn in their role as a Congressional rep. This includes not just routine and public hearings, but also closed and secret/classified hearings.
- matt4077 9y agoNo–legalising insider trading would destroy the market, because anybody not in a position to have insider knowledge would be at a severe disadvantage so as to make the expected return of investing negative. An analogy: It'd be like playing online chess for money, without any way to stop your opponent from using a computer to make their moves. Or like the Olympics where some people are allowed to use performance enhancing drugs. After a very short time, most everyone will have left the market. There's also no more reason to legalise insider trading than murder or burglary. The prevalence is very likely to be at an all-time low currently, because the statistical methods used to spot insider trading in market data have improved dramatically. Some quant funds also flag suspicious trades as a sort of by-product of their work and share that data with the authorities.
- otakucode 9y agoThey're very much more likely to face consequences from the stock sales than they are to face any sort of 'negligence' charges due to their security practices, sadly. If Toyota got acquitted in their 'unintended acceleration' criminal negligence case, no one can ever be penalized for it. Toyota was exceptionally egregious in their negligence, even worse than most companies are as part of their daily practices. Their developers didn't even have access to a bug tracker. So whatever Equifax was doing, the courts will just look at it and do what they always do, say 'huh... computers, huh? NOBODY knows how they work. Acquitted!'
- dforrestwilson 9y ago^This. Maybe because I don't work at a "pure" tech company, but a few coworkers have commented that they had to sign up for credit protection with sort of a shrug attitude. They don't realize how negligent Equifax was here or what the impact is going to be for the rest of their lives. Congress and the various regulatory bodies will take their pound of flesh. The CEO/Chairman will keep his job. Maybe MAYBE the President of USIS and/or the CFO go to jail for insider trading. On the surface the security folks don't have great credentials...I kind of wonder if the CEO chose his subordinates specifically to take the hit in a data breach situation like this.
- yebyen 9y ago> I kind of wonder if the CEO chose his subordinates specifically to take the hit in a data breach situation like this. ^ This! They sure have shuffled the CIO and CISO out of the conversation quickly. I'm sure you can be a perfectly competent CISO with two degrees in music composition and ten years experience, but they sure don't want us to hear about it if we haven't already. I've been through an acquisition before and promoted and put into the position of "potential fall guy" where my name went on official documents, and there wasn't a budget for more people or things we needed. If we lost medical records to hackers, I'd expect to answer some uncomfortable questions! But they are actively erasing information about these people from the internet, when lots of us want to have a closer look. What happened to failure as a learning experience? Retired effective immediately? Come on, those two people will never make that same mistake again!
- cr0sh 9y agoMaybe it's already been noted here, but I'm wondering about stock purchases. For instance, with the advanced knowledge in hand, did anyone with that information purchase a large amount of shares in, say, LifeLock or another such company?
- phaus 9y agoI don't know nearly as much about stock as most people on this site, so bear with me because I have a potentially dumb question. I agree that the timing of these sales looks really bad. However, I've heard that these guys are executives with an enormous amount of stock and the sales were for a small percentage of their overall stake. If they were intentionally breaking the law to avoid losses, wouldn't they sell all or most if it? Was most of their stock not vested and they just dumped what already vested? Or is the claim that it was a small percentage of their stock not true?
- 1mike12 9y agoIt's not as if there's an amount X you can sell less of where it's totally fine, but if you go over, you're in trouble. Nobody would be dumb enough to sell their entire position, but at the same time, if you did have insider knowledge, you wouldn't want to have all your position tank. So what do you do? You could go a little bit in the middle and claim ignorance. Trading based off of insider knowledge is illegal regardless of the amount of trades, but in practice obviously the government only chases after egregious cases.
- oconnor663 9y agoI think the idea of the question is, if you're talking about the difference between losing 50% of your value (doing nothing), and losing 49% of your value (making a small illegal trade), would it make sense to expose yourself to criminal liability for that 1%, even if that 1% represents a lot of money in absolute terms?
- yebyen 9y agoHere's a link to the video interview from CISO Susan Mauldin in 2016 that was erased from YouTube a few days ago, on September 10 after it was first reported: http://evilrouters.net/media/susan_mauldin_cazena_interview_201603.m4v http://evilrouters.net/media/susan_mauldin_cazena_interview_... The HN thread that found another copy: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15262026 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15262026 The first story that I saw breaking this interview, drawing attention to this story before it was wiped out by "user": https://hollywoodlanews.com/equifax-chief-security-officer/ https://hollywoodlanews.com/equifax-chief-security-officer/ I'm reposting this information, there's nothing earth shattering for me in the interview but I smell a coverup (I hope it doesn't sound controversial when I say this, it appears to be that material information has been wiped off the public record during an investigation, and that's a coverup! Not mincing words.) This has hardly been covered at all, so I'm going to mention it again. I figure the story probably isn't going away anytime soon. I think it's criminal (possibly quite literally) that this information is being suppressed by whoever has taken the original interviews down. It should be a case study, we should all watch it. I want to hear more from Susan Mauldin, but the appearance is they want her to disappear. I am interested in the stock sales too, but I would like it to be a thing, where we all can learn from what has happened and fix our issues to be better at this kind of thing. There are obviously technical and greedological issues that own some blame, but let's not be hasty and sweep the cultural issues under the rug. (There was a second interview from that day, which to my knowledge has not been recovered yet.) I'd like to be charitable and say that CISO Susan Mauldin did nothing wrong, but it's hard for me to make that argument seriously without more data and I don't hear anyone calling for her to testify in front of Congress yet. Maybe they'd like us to forget she was ever involved in the company, that just makes me want to know more and it should you too, if you've been following the story (but who could blame you for not knowing, just look what they're doing!)