9 ms·
It was at that awkward moment that Amazon decided that it would punish the New Republic. Our ad sales department received a note, informing us that Amazon w
by michaelt 9y ago
It was at that awkward moment that Amazon decided that it
would punish the New Republic. Our ad sales department
received a note, informing us that Amazon would be yanking
its advertising for its new political comedy, Alpha House.
The missive left nothing to the imagination. “In light of
the cover article about Amazon, Amazon has decided to
terminate the Alpha House campaign currently running on
the New Republic. Please confirm receipt of this email and
that the campaign has been terminated.” It was signed,
“Team Amazon.”
This is one of the reasons I really wish there was a decent, widely supported micropayment system for journalism.
So long as journalists' jobs depend on the ad money coming in, companies can use that leverage to get negative stories spiked. Amazon is one example in this article; HSBC with The Telegraph (and other newspapers) is another [1].
If we want to avoid this disease spreading, we really need some way to pay journalists that doesn't rely on corporate largess.
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/media/2015/feb/17/peter-oborne-telegraph-hsbc-coverage-fraud-readers https://www.theguardian.com/media/2015/feb/17/peter-oborne-t...
- willvarfar 9y agoPrivate Eye have an interesting model - they are deliberately not online. They do not try and bait and subscribe you. A lot of what they write is too focused on whitehall and fleet street to be terribly interesting to a wider public. I've often wished they'd expand to do serious journalism too.
- mst 9y agoPart of me keeps wishing there was a paid kindle edition of it or similar ... but then I remember that I mostly read the eye as a result of impulse purchases from railway news stands, and suspect that that's why there isn't. Always funny when you see part of an eye page clipped from a photo to post on twitter - the one time that having an image instead of text seems actually suitable ;)
- loceng 9y agoAs much as I understand a journalist's raison d'etre (reason of being), they hold a lot of power when they can publish to a widespread readership. This is great if everything is balanced and fair (this is of course all relative and must use reason), however I believe companies and people aren't given the opportunity to share their side of the story - or their counterargument. Usually you may see a quote of someone's response in to being questioned about something, or perhaps a company will say "no comment at this time" - neither of these are good IMHO. I feel pre-publishing, a person should be given the opportunity to respond - and at least part of that response be included in the publication - and always there should be a permanent link clearly highlighted to a third-party platform allowing the person's full response (or really all people and organizations mentioned in an article), which a link/response that can be added to/edited later (with version control to view the previous versions - leaving the purpose of editing to expand upon or clarify). Who pays for the wheels to get going on this kind of system? Is it safe to be government supported? This is an important system I believe we must implement as soon as possible. Getting it adopted is possible, it just takes effort which includes needing enough resources for a longer runway. It feels like it would be a similar type of service of importance as Wikipedia.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- morgancmartin 9y agoIt sounds as though something like the Ethereum network would be exactly what you're looking for. It's decentralized, meaning no one entity has the ability to remove it. And it is as democratic as you want it to be, meaning the user base can push for the requirement of fairness you suggest.
- mpclark 9y agoThe first part of what you have outlined is in fact part of 'proper' journalism here in the UK. A journalist is supposed to approach the subject of the story and get their point of view, partly for reasons of fairness and balance as you rightly point out, but mostly as a defence against defamation actions after it is published. You'll notice that the BBC always does this. However, it can very difficult to get any sort of comment out of any party that has acted less than admirably, and many see staying tight-lipped as a strategy that can make a bad story go away. Of course, it doesn't work like this. Additionally, some publishers have deep enough pockets that they are prepared to risk a defamation action if the story is strong enough, or they actively don't want to tip off the subject to upcoming coverage because they may put countermeasures in place (either legal or a pre-emptive "My drugs hell"-type confessional in a rival publication) The difficulty with quoting full responses anywhere is that, just for example, anyone ever asked for comment by one of our more popular UK papers would be well advised to work in something about their past support of the Nazis or indeed the tax arrangements of their proprietor. I'd expect many such responses to be defamatory in themselves, and thus unpublishable.
- inanutshellus 9y agoIMO micropayments would only be additive. (Ad-itive? ;D) In the "you fill the space you have" sense. XYZ news org would be giddily accepting micropayments w/ no ads but then there'd've been "the lean times" and instead of laying off 75% of their staff and having the C*'s take massive pay cuts, they'd add ads. And we'd be right where we are... only with micropayments.
- matt4077 9y agoIt's called a subscription. Micropayments don't work for journalism, because there's too much of a difference between the set of articles that people are likely to press the "pay 10cents" button on (or even read) and the set of articles that are necessary for civil society to function. That's why journalists were almost disgusted by buzzfeed's "big board", the screen showing current traffic numbers for all articles: it encourages the sort of cat content that drives traffic for the least amount of effort. As one example, there was the widely-shared frustration of one journalist on Twitter who had been investigating that Trump Jr. meeting with the russians for months, only to be scooped by Jr. making it public himself when he got wind of the investigation. It's not just that this journalist's work wouldn't be rewarded under a micropayment model. It also shows that some stories take an amount of work that I think people don't know about. Even if his article had become a hit, could it ever pull in as much money as the dozens of listicles you could pump out in those months of work? Editors at high-quality publishers still tend to want to do the right thing. Subscriptions give them a bit of cover to send someone on an assignment that they deem important. Once every articles' costs and revenue become explicit data points on a colourful chart, even those owners that are currently willing to look the other way as long as the overall numbers make some sense will find it hard to resist the temptation to point at the outliers and ask if it's really necessary to spend a six-digit sum on that investigation of bribery at the Backwater County (MI) Department of Public Health when it only got 10,000 microflatters of 5 cents each, all from residents of East Nowhere (MI), especially since advertisers stopped being interested in readers from East Nowhere once they all started spending their money on Heroin.
- athenot 9y agoYes. For that reason I have a subscription to one of the major papers. What I'd like is a federated system, where say 90% goes to the paper I'm subscribed to, but 10% goes into a pool of other participating papers, allowing me to view a few articles a month at other papers. 2 factors at play: I can't reasonably have multiple subscriptions and I don't have enough time to take advantage of content from more than 1 large paper. But I'd like a way to support good articles from other papers on a more occasional basis. Disclaimer: I haven't fully thought this through and I'm sure there are pitfalls in this approach… happy to hear about them!
- arjie 9y agoI think people will find any way to simultaneously not pay for news while lamenting the lack of good news. Things will just be forever "almost there" and "all we need is" but no one's going to do it. Micropayments aren't going to work. People will say "if only it were 10 cents instead of 20" or "if only it were 1 cent instead of 10" until it's "if only this used Bitcoin so they don't know who I am" and so on and so forth until the publisher refuses to bow to some onerous request at which point it'll be this big deal about how they don't really care about their users. I mean, the guy who solves this is going to be rich, but you only have to see about the complaints to Flattr, Patreon, etc. and you know no one else wants to touch this. The audience's Revealed Preferences are significantly different from their Stated Preferences.
- rb808 9y agoAgreed - also see the number of people that block ads to get the news for free. How hard is it to have ads on the page?
- Shikadi 9y agoIt would be fine if advertisements weren't intrusive and obnoxious. I don't want to start reading a page, then three sentences in have my whole screen jump, then a few more sentences have an overlay pop up, then have some inline text that looks like it's part of the article but is actually an ad, finally to accidently mouse over some text that pops up a video with sound. That's how I experience much of the internet without ad blocking, not to mention how much slower things load. I disable on sites I frequent that don't do that.
- joeblubaugh 9y agoI don't block ads to "get the news for free." I do it to marginally protect myself from an increasingly omnipresent surveillance apparatus that's tracking my entire path across the internet, across devices, as well as in the real world.
- ma2rten 9y agoSafari is going to prevent ad tracking by not allowing cross domain cookies. Does that mean you are would use Safari instead when the feature is released? https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/09/ad-industry-deeply-concerned-about-safaris-new-ad-tracking-restrictions/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/09/ad-industry-deep...
- criddell 9y ago> I really wish there was a decent, widely supported micropayment system for journalism. The audience for news isn't as big as I think lots of people wish it were. For the micropayment system to work, I bet the payments wouldn't be very micro.
- theseatoms 9y agoThen a lot of news can go away, which is fine. As ad-blocking becomes more popular, this'll happen anyway.
- hectorr1 9y agoYou're right - journalism has a broken and outdated business model. Amazon has a modern and effective one. To fix the problem, you need to fix this dynamic. I get a lot the crypto hate you see around here, there are some real problems in the space right now. But facilitating micropayments for online content is extremely low hanging fruit with the tech, especially if the US tax exemption for txs under $600 goes through and browser integration happens. Brave Browser / Basic Attention Token is one of the few groups in ICO-mania-land that is trying to solve a real problem, and they're focused on this one. It's led by Brendan Eich, former Mozilla CEO and original Netscape dev. Worth checking out if you are in publishing.
- guaka 9y agohttps://satoshipay.io/ https://satoshipay.io/ is another interesting project. (Disclaimer: I don't have any stake in the company but Meinhard is a friend of mine.)
- zionic 9y agoReading the grandparent comment I was thinking to myself that Brave is trying to fix just this. Seeing you beat me to this comment made me happy! It's super fast and very modern. Much faster than the live release of FF
- leppr 9y agoThere's no relationship with Firefox. A better comparison would be between Brave and a vanilla Chromium + uBlock.
- bovermyer 9y agoUnfortunately, Brave is incompatible with the current business model of journalism, and I don't know if journalism can survive a war on multiple fronts - that is, a war on its pocketbook from the consumer side, and a war on its integrity from the government side.
- Ajedi32 9y agoIt is? How so? As far as I can tell, sites don't need to change their business model at all; they can just start collecting payments from Brave in addition to their ad revenue from non-Brave users. > Once a user enables Brave Payments, the Brave browser automatically and anonymously keeps track of the publisher sites each user visits. The more times that a user visits a site, the larger the proportion of the user’s monthly contribution is “ear-marked” for that publisher. These funds grow as new micropayments are added. When contributions for a publisher exceed $100.00 USD, an email is sent to both the webmaster of the site and the registered domain owner from your WHOIS information. The email explains how to verify the ownership of your website with Brave Software. (See https://brave.com/publishers/ https://brave.com/publishers/) I really like this implementation, because it avoids the chicken-egg problem that other solutions like Google Contributor have by not requiring the publisher's cooperation in order to work properly. Visitors on Brave don't see ads, period. Publishers can choose to collect money from Brave users if they want, but that doesn't change the experience from the user's point of view.
- jasonsync 9y agoAt the most basic level "don't bite the hand that feeds you" seems like the main takeaway from this story. A long time ago I did an internship at a marketing firm that did work for Subway Sandwiches. As such, it was considered a fireable offence to bring any other branded "sub" into the office.
- tyingq 9y ago>As such, it was considered a fireable offence to bring any other branded "sub" into the office. Ugh. That's just so stupid. What if they do work for a bank, automobile manufacturer, clothing designer, etc? Are the employees obliged to then buy new clothes, cars, hide their branded debit cards in the cafeteria?
- jasonsync 9y agoHaha. In realistic terms they simply wanted to avoid that awkward moment. Although, if you work for GM, and exclusively drive a Toyota, would you feel pressured into switching at some point? Edit - to answer my own question I searched Google and found this: http://jalopnik.com/dear-car-companies-stop-punishing-employees-for-drivin-1746653093 http://jalopnik.com/dear-car-companies-stop-punishing-employ...
- Jonnax 9y agoI think that totally depends how high you are in the company and whether you're client facing. I doubt that the majority of people that work for Mercedes drive their cars.
- gbacon 9y agoYou’d be surprised on both counts. Union factory workers face significant pressure — as in slashed tires — from their peers not to drive foreign vehicles. Auto makers give sizable discounts to their employees.
- 9y ago
- rjtavares 9y ago> This is one of the reasons I really wish there was a decent, widely supported micropayment system for journalism. I was looking for that also, and have been happy with Blendle[1]. Pretty good selection, recommendations and "return" policy. [1] https://launch.blendle.com/ https://launch.blendle.com/
- bauerd 9y agohttps://flattr.com/ https://flattr.com/
- seppin 9y ago"Get early access" Why do sites do this? Flattr has been around for almost a decade.
- bauerd 9y agoI remember having signed up for Flattr ages ago so I tried it out. Turns out they seem to have scrapped their original product and I'm now on the waiting list for its successor ("Flattr beta"). I have no idea wtf they're doing. Edit: Also can't login w/ old credentials or recover my password. Duh
- blubb-fish 9y agowould it really make a difference? my guess is that expenses would be as always adjusted to the budget. and if the budget is u-payments + ads then the advertisers will still have power. what actually matters is the ideology of the journalists involved. do they have a mission or are they primarily interested in wealth and fame.
- sidlls 9y agoShouldn't they be compensated for their work, no matter how passionate they are for it?
- pp19dd 9y agoScale is a problem. To give you an example, as of a few years ago, you could buy copy of a typical mid-sized city newspaper for $2. The other $15 it took to produce that day's single copy (that's everything combined, editorial costs, and 30% print costs) came from advertising sources, of which something like 10% is digital, including subscriptions. And that's after years of massive layoffs and reductions in cost. This is a simplified view, but it should illustrate the scale of operations. The headlining stories that people would pay for are currently loss leaders in a sense, so turning them into sole breadwinners is dooming rest of the stories produced for that day (I'm not paying for a police blotter story, unless it features a stolen tomato). And under that model there's the feedback risk of majority stories becoming tailored to their patrons, becoming images of darling kittens and pet goats. Sideline to show I'm not just being my usual cynical self: for a brief time, AP tried to syndicate lolcats (yes, the i Can Has Cheezburger blog one) but then someone asked about the issue of image rights. Had this happened, it would have resulted in pretty much all of US newspapers ending up with kitten pictures in print, because readers would love it and it's no work at all to produce it. These cost breakdown numbers are changing and vary greatly from newspaper to newspaper, but I hope it illustrates a dark and complicated reality of news decline. I don't know what's the solution, but you can't dismiss brick and mortar news agencies and think they can either instantly convert to digital media and revenue, or that independent online-online agencies can come replace it. The non-syndicated stories you see in today's newspaper (go pick one up wherever you are) have been worked on for days, weeks, even months. And tomorrow's stories will have a similar breakdown of labor. Isn't it mind boggling? AP, AFP, Reuters will not concentrate in towns and fact check the local authorities and governance because they'd get stretched too thin, so newspapers mix and match local coverage with national as best they can. The kicker is that all that hard work spanning days, weeks, months gets used by local TV stations that very morning and (if the story is that unusual), by online-only agencies and aggregators, because they don't have all those boots on the ground. It's complicated. Reward for reading any of this rant, Dick Irwin's tomato blotter story: "Someone entered the rear yard of a house in the 5900 block of Johnson St. on Saturday morning and removed a tomato from a tomato plant. The tomato was valued at $3, police said."
- dalbasal 9y agoIDK if there’s a perfect (or even good) solution out there. There are and were many ways of funding publications, each with their own problems. Nothing consistently yields good work. A pattern-like donations system has biases of its own. Where big national dailies tend to have centrist-conservative leanings, donor supported journalism would tend to favour political wings and fringes as they play to their supporter silo. In both cases, there’s a big incentive to do opinion, talking heads, and less incentive to do first hand investigations.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoBloomberg has already established the market price of accurate independent journalism: https://qz.com/84961/this-is-how-much-a-bloomberg-terminal-costs/ https://qz.com/84961/this-is-how-much-a-bloomberg-terminal-c... ($24K per year per head) Not holding my breath on micropayments...
- wutbrodo 9y agoThis is quite obviously not generalizable. Bloomberg provides financial data, which is at a much more valuable point of the funnel in direct monetary terms to the purchaser. The sad fact is that real journalism doesn't provide that much value directly to the purchaser: much of the value of an informed citizen accrues as a positive externality to the rest of society. The latter by definition doesn't affect willingness-to-pay, however, so newspapers in general have had to rely on their customers' willingness to pay coming from a vague need to sound informed in front of their friends. This is obviously a lot less sensitive to the _quality_ of journalism, so you end up with a situation where there's no real channel for providing quality journalism to the average person.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoEven back in the day when they were still getting paid, the overall quality of mainstream media content was almost as bad as it is today. Even back then, they were still businesses. Their customers were still the advertisers, not the subscribers. If there was dirt to dig up on a politician, they'd probably cover it. If there was dirt to air on the local car dealership, grocery store, or real estate brokerage--silence! To be an actual public service, the agency relationship has to be right. It was never right for the mainstream media. Bloomberg terminals do have it right (I'm the customer, not the product), but expensive!
- yeukhon 9y agoBut here is a counter question: why would I pay a journalist in the first place? In other words, there must be an objective I am seeking and I somehow find this jouranlist or this group of jouranlist align with my objectives and beliefs. So how does a micropayment system can help promote free and honest journalism? I wouldn't pay journalist working for Breitbart (Steve Bannon's news outlet) because I don't agree with them.
- yebh 9y agoNo idea. Journalists to me perform the same function as search engine robots/crawlers. And probably have the same value as those robots do in the info economy. Google hasn't created a robot to do indepth scans of lets say all the Wikipedia tennis tournament pages even if they can afford to do so technically and financially. Why? Cause its results returned are good enough for the waste majority of ppl. If I ask who last years 4 US open semifinalists were Google isn't able to produce just the 4 names. I can rant about how dumb that is. And why more in depth scanning/parsing is required. But if Google can't find any great reason to upgrade its crawlers why should a news org do so. Maybe we are past the point where there is any great value.
- intended 9y agoBingo. This is the problem. If journalism is broken down into a market problem, (which will happen regularly on an American board for entrepreneurship) then the product will always be cat pics and scandal. Because thats what people want. As someone said above, revealed behaviors of news consumers are different from stated behaviors. If someone actually wanted objective information, they already pay for it - they go buy the wsj/bb for finance. If they want political analysis - they pay for those magazines. I don't think Journalism works in a free market model. The problem really boils down to 5-7 slots of short term attention span a human being has. For all the desire to want good news, people will still dump that attention on junk food for the brain. Since Good journalism is expensive, takes time to process, and may not be well received - its extremely time and attention intensive. In a world where we're blowing that resource regularly, good journalism dies. It has to be capable of going toe to toe with attention seeking feel good material. In a Market system - journalism end up being about hacking human attention. Otherwise not enough people reads it to support the paper. This is generally a solved problem - You pay the govt to make a single news agency - give it operating money, independence and stick an oversight group on top of it. And you call it the BBC, and spend the rest of your days trying to defund it, while a majority of groups call it biased in one direction or the other.
- eternalban 9y agoI seem to in a minority here scanning the comments, which are focused on "advertising". The OP is discussing "the power of Jeff Bezos". To illustrate, he has anecdotal evidence of an attorney bowing out due to concern for his daughter's upcoming book. He is talking about a network effect with scope far beyond the matter of a specific publication and its relationship with a key advertiser.
- mooreds 9y ago> This is one of the reasons I really wish there was a decent, widely supported micropayment system for journalism. Well, to be fair, there is a decent, widely supported payment system for journalism. It's called subscribing to your local newspaper (or the Times, or a magazine). And, depending on your income, this may be a micro payment. The NY Times costs something like 33 cents a day, for example. It does have the virtue of already existing.
- apsec112 9y ago"It's called subscribing to your local newspaper" This won't support, or get you access to, the overwhelming majority of articles, though. It's as if each musician required their own, independent monthly subscription. "The NY Times costs something like 33 cents a day, for example." Newspapers can, and will, quietly double their prices without telling you and then make it very hard for you to cancel. See my article on the Boston Globe, for example: https://rationalconspiracy.com/2016/04/24/dark-patterns-by-the-boston-globe/ https://rationalconspiracy.com/2016/04/24/dark-patterns-by-t....
- mooreds 9y ago> This won't support, or get you access to, the overwhelming majority of articles, though. It's as if each musician required their own, independent monthly subscription. Fair enough. Sounds like "Spotify, but for news" is what you're looking for. I see your point. > Newspapers can, and will, quietly double their prices without telling you And that's just plain old bad customer service.
- dilemma 9y agoIf there was a way to get access to all articles published that would create an even larger demand, and subjective value of, single-publisher subscriptions like the NYT. People, including you and me, don't want to have access to everything, they want choice access to the "best", chosen by a reputable entity.
- jordigh 9y agoThis is always why the pleading to make me sit through my alloted dose of ads for the good of capitalism always sounds so weird to me. You're trying to make me feel guilty about not wanting to allow my mind to be distracted and polluted by a third party that's trying to get me to buy something neither you nor I actually care about?
- ElijahLynn 9y agoAlso, WikiTribune is in the works and has potential. It won't be funded by advertisers at all.
- gozur88 9y agoI'm not a big fan of microtransactions unless everybody pretty much used the same service. Otherwise there's too much mental overhead. Also, I'd pay for a service that got me free access to a dozen original news providers (I don't want a dozen copies of the wire story) with different points of view, I'd pay for that. But that's not the landscape right now. One thing that might work is really lean organizations surviving on donations for original reporting. I know Michael Yon made that work in Iraq, and there were a bunch of people trying to do that (somewhat successfully, I believe) on youtube before the ad money dried up.
- devopsproject 9y agohttps://brave.com/publishers/ https://brave.com/publishers/ ?