8 ms·
So there's now a protocol for the browser to transparently share payment data with websites but we still can't get something to let the browser transparently lo
by StavrosK 9y ago
So there's now a protocol for the browser to transparently share payment data with websites but we still can't get something to let the browser transparently log us in to websites?
- swiley 9y agoThe w3c seems to be run by people who make money on the web, not people who use the web.
- throwaway284534 9y agoThe W3C is run by the same peers who frequent this and other tech forums. You can help by contributing to the organization, or you could hope for some internet points with snarky remarks. Which do you want to be remembered for?
- ben_jones 9y agoWhile he could've worded it better he did provide valid criticism. I'm sure he is not the only person here who has profiteering concerns for the various bodies who govern the internet.
- swiley 9y agoAlright "run" wasn't the right word, "heavily influenced by" is probably better. They just seem to continuously standardize things that are very user hostile and only serve content distributors.
- RandomInteger4 9y agoIf people want to make money of the content they produce and other people are happy to pay them, then what's the problem?
- detaro 9y ago> continuously standardize things that are very user hostile and only serve content distributors. Example Nr 1 you are going to quote is the DRM stuff (understandably, it's the most controversial for good reasons, both inside and outside W3C). What other very user hostile examples are there?
- swiley 9y agoWeb workers are pretty bad if you're looking for another one.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jancsika 9y agoFor certain decisions that seems like a false choice. For example, no amount of contribution would have stopped Netflix et al from pushing through EME as a web standard.
- colejohnson66 9y agoAs bad as DRM is, EME is a good step towards killing Flash. And because of that, Netflix needs a replacement, and the studios aren’t just going to remove DRM requirements because Netflix says they won’t support DRM. I’m almost certain that if Netflix tried to remove DRM, the studios would balk and pull their content.
- gsnedders 9y agoOr Netflix could take the route they took on iOS and just make native apps for everything. Or, perhaps more likely, browser vendors would continue to not kill Flash until 2020 (at the earliest) when Adobe ends support, and then browsers would drop support for the insecure plugin and then Netflix would go the native apps route.
- jancsika 9y agoThat goes against what throwaway284534 was implying. If everyone is a "peer" and an enormous number of those peers make a succinct, persuasive argument that EME is incompatible with W3C's mission statement of "Web for All" and "Web for Rich Interaction"[1], one would think that would make a difference in the direction the W3C takes. Instead I'm eating popcorn watching players with deep pockets choose tactics in their battle to control an industry. And that battle is what shapes this web API. So the claim of, "your peers are listening and they value your feedback," is about as convincing as a hold message from Comcast. [1] https://www.w3.org/Consortium/mission https://www.w3.org/Consortium/mission
- KyeRussell 9y agoIt's called pragmatism.
- orf 9y agoWhy not both?
- objclxt 9y ago> The w3c seems to be run by people who make money on the web, not people who use the web. Not really. Anyone can join the W3C, and anyone can participate in a working group / contribute to a standard. However, most people would agree that the balance of power effectively lies with the browser vendors. You can propose a standard all you like, but if you can't get a browser to adopt it then it's not going to get any traction. And although it's true that some browser vendors make their money off the web (Google) others very much don't (Apple).
- gsnedders 9y ago> However, most people would agree that the balance of power effectively lies with the browser vendors It lies with two groups: the implementers (as nothing can become a standard without implementations, though there's plenty of precedent for using obscure ones!) and the W3C Members (i.e., the paying organisations who pay to get a seat; not those who contribute on mailing lists/GitHub/whatever, not those who are officially on the working groups as "invited experts") who ultimately vote on the proposed standard (and there Google has as much say as the BBC and Boeing and the University of Edinburgh.
- dmitriid 9y ago> Anyone can join the W3C, and anyone can participate in a working group / contribute to a standard. Starting at ~10 000 USD per year, sure
- gsnedders 9y agoIt's worth noting that while it costs money to join the W3C, W3C membership isn't a requirement to participate in most (maybe even all now?) WGs where you can simply join the mailing list or subscribe to the GitHub repo and contribute.
- dmitriid 9y agoHowever, if you want anything done (especially your way), you'd better be paying A LOT. See recent EME snafu
- pfg 9y agoThe W3C is working on this in the Web Authentication (webauthn) working group.
- Rafert 9y agoLink for the curious and/or lazy https://www.w3.org/TR/webauthn/ https://www.w3.org/TR/webauthn/
- noway421 9y agoThis became a thing lately: https://developers.google.com/web/updates/2016/04/credential-management-api https://developers.google.com/web/updates/2016/04/credential...
- dbbk 9y agoAnd it's great! Also coming is the ability to share login credentials across domains.
- homakov 9y agoBuilt in pw manager with JS api. Nothing special. Doesn't fix anything.
- dbbk 9y agoIt's more than that, it syncs user login credentials across devices, and can auto-sign in users without them having to go through a login form. Example scenario: user signs up for a site on Chrome desktop. When they visit the site from their phone, they're automatically signed in, they don't even see a login screen.
- homakov 9y agoDoes it by default generate a password or there is STILL a way for user to set their own? If the latter, then it won't change anything. We must hide pw field entirely from the user.
- dbbk 9y agoI believe they autogenerate the password, but the long-term strategy is to make OAuth as seamless as possible so users are encouraged to login to everything with their Google/Facebook etc account.
- HugoDaniel 9y agochrome only
- chuckdries 9y agoIsn't kerberos supposed to do that?
- daenney 9y agoSupposed to, perhaps. But it's not going to happen. Kerberos is ridiculously complex (it's not named after Hades' three-headed dog for nothing) and hard to deploy. When used it is usually only done for company's own/internal apps. I don't think I've ever seen anything with Kerberos on the public internet. The description on Wikipedia for Cerberus/Kerberos is pretty apt when applied to the protocol too: > Cerberus was the offspring of the monsters Echidna and Typhon, and usually is described as having three heads, a serpent for a tail, and snakes protruding from parts of his body.
- Vinnl 9y agoThat's what Mozilla Persona (not the theming system) was meant to be, but apparently people didn't care enough for it for websites to implement it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Persona https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Persona
- vertex-four 9y agoMozilla Persona suffered from the problem that its developers abandoned it shortly after releasing it, rather than making any attempt to get it into browsers. The pop-up dialog wasn't how it was supposed to work, that was a fallback (and apparently a slightly confusing one) - there was supposed to be a little login widget in your address bar that you'd interact with, and it'd be fully integrated into your browser's UI.
- sitepodmatt 9y agoHmmm.. How would that work beyond Firefox if it wasnt a standard? Persona was a good nobel idea, but like many Mozilla endeavors without a commercial goal it was doomed to failure, a few devs and devops costs money (a lot in the US, let's say 3 devs - 2 devops, office space, benefits etc.. easily 1m). Slightly OT beyond Firefox has Mozilla done anything commercially successful? Mobile software failure (cant imagine Android FF pays for itsself), device failure, SSO failure. How much revenue % is accounted for beyond the Google search integration? Update: Just thought they made Rust and Servo that's pretty cool and my post sounds a little shitty, Rust seems awesome, but commercial avenue (back to reality) seems extremely limited here..
- vertex-four 9y ago> How would that work beyond Firefox if it wasn't a standard? Done properly, it hopefully would've been. (There was even some branding around the vague hope that it would eventually be a standard - "BrowserID"). As it stands... the Persona devs never even tried to create an extension for Firefox to show what they were trying to do (there's some early mockups that explain some of it), nor did they attempt to standardise it. The project was mismanaged to failure. > has Mozilla done anything commercially successful? Mozilla is primarily a non-profit organisation, "commercially successful" is not the goal. Mozilla Corp, the wholly owned tax-paying subsidiary, is simply a legal tool to make it less difficult to sell things like search integration, not to be a commercial success. The question is whether much of their work successfully furthers their goals as outlined in their mission statement and manifesto.[0] [0] https://www.mozilla.org/en-GB/mission/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-GB/mission/