6 ms·
A Sunnyvale, CA home that went for nearly $800K over the asking price
- ryanx435 9y agoGood to hear that at least one person in California recognizes that it's a supply/demand problem. Build more housing. Build more high density housing. Simple solution to a complex problem.
- irq11 9y agoReduce demand. Tax the tech industry to encourage it to relocate anywhere else in the 99.99% of America it doesn't currently occupy. Also, for good measure: eliminate the mortgage deduction, and tax short-term capital gains on property at 100% to eliminate rampant speculation. Simpler solution to a complex problem.
- tehlike 9y agoeliminating mortgage deduction could help with the prices, but overall, probably wouldn't affect how much each people end up effectively paying. I could pay 10K before the deduction, and effectively pay, say 8K, out of pocket. Remove deduction, i still pay 8K. Effectively nothing changes. Also, in the bay area, plenty of houses used to go for cash (to chinese). No amount of mortgage interest deduction cut could help with that. The demand & supply problem is somewhat due to prop 13, but still not entirely.
- tritium 9y agoQuick, someone build that carbon nanotube cable for the fabled space elevator we used to dream about out in middle-of-nowheresville, U.S.A. and watch a new boomtown draw off all of California's excess population in quest of The Next Big Thing® or whatever.
- dvt 9y agoThe bubble seems to be back. My parents bought their house in 2011 (my dad had the foresight to buy at the low point). The house has miraculously gone from $700k to $1.1m in less than a decade. I've come to terms with the fact that unless I win the startup lottery (or there's another 2007-2008 crash), I'll probably never be able to afford a house in California.
- swampthinker 9y agoDon't worry too much. The American economy generally runs on 69 month cycles (on mobile, sorry for no source). In about 6-7 years you will be able to buy a home again.
- tehlike 9y agoI am not entirely sure: https://www.paragon-re.com/trend/3-recessions-2-bubbles-and-a-baby https://www.paragon-re.com/trend/3-recessions-2-bubbles-and-...
- tehlike 9y agoI think we are past that cycle so far. It could burst anytime, but in the bay area the impact probably won't be that high.
- slantedview 9y agoSure you can, probably just not in one of the urban areas, particularly the bay area.
- gok 9y ago$700k to $1.1m in 10 years is about 4.6% annualized...that doesn’t seem that crazy.
- stouset 9y agoIt's actually pretty terrible when you throw in that they bought at the bottom of the market, and likely paid at least 3% monthly in financing costs.
- gok 9y agoWell it was actually the last top of the market; it bottomed out a year later. They probably could have gotten it for much less in 2008.
- dvt 9y ago
- rayiner 9y agoWhy do people put up with California? This is a 3 bedroom 2 bath house in a completely generic charmless suburb almost 40 miles away from the city. For $2.4 million. A similar house where I live (about 35 miles east of DC) would go for about $400,000, with a water view (also, fiber internet).
- maxerickson 9y agoIn a previous discussion of the sale, it came up that it is about a mile from the new Apple campus. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15238835 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15238835
- tptacek 9y agoIt's 40 miles from San Francisco, but just a fraction of that to San Jose, which is the larger of the two cities. People paying 2MM for a house in south bay likely work in south bay. The charmlessness, though, I agree with. People live in charmless apartments in Manhattan, too, but they live in Manhattan, which is an amazing place to be. South bay, though, is just bleak.
- dionidium 9y agoThere's something really bizarre about the claim that San Jose is "bigger" than San Francisco. Obviously, it's technically "true" in that San Jose officially consists of a land area 4x that of San Francisco, lapping up a lot of people as it stretches over those vast, nowhere suburbs. But this shows just how overrated "technically correct" can be when using the arbitrary political boundaries of different cities to make comparisons. Paradoxically, San Francisco is obviously the "bigger" of the two cities, even if it technically isn't.
- nuna 9y agoevery time someone writes about this they talk about the teachers, janitors and minimum wage people. Although they struggle they have some assistance (discounted day care or affordable housing). What no one talks about are middle class with dual income, that still can't afford a home, and don't qualify for anything at all. The dependent care spending account covers only about 2.5 months of my child's preschool cost. It's much much worse than it seems
- trcollinson 9y agoAnecdata time! I grew up in Southern California, first in the San Fernando Valley (Los Angeles County) then Ventura County and then Orange County. The housing market was amazing and crazy. My father started buying property in the late 1960's and finally left in 2006. He worked hard his entire career to afford to live there. Honestly, it wasn't much better in the late 70's and early 80's than it is now. Imagine buying a small rambler in Reseda for a bit more than $200,000 with a 19% mortgage. Remember also that you had to have 20% down. Then imagine a 3 bedroom two story in Thousand Oaks for a bit north of $300,000 with 17.5% interest rate. Or maybe a little Huntington Beach home that more then tripled in value and then dropped (in 2009) to 20% below the original purchase price within a 10 year timeframe. So yes it is wild, very expensive, and can (if you are intelligent and lucky) make you very wealthy. In about 2000 I had made a windfall profit off of Y2K consulting and met a beautiful woman from Pittsburgh who had 3 children and I decided to settle down. I could have moved them all to California and used my savings to get us a modest home. We decided to not do that and we have been very pleased with our decision. California is amazing and has a really interesting economy and job market. But I have as of yet never regretted leaving. I have always been employed. I have a very nice home with great schools and a beautiful area to live in. I make a substantial income and have no problem saving for retirement and investing. I also invest in property to this day and have done extremely well by almost all standards I have come across. You really don't have to deal with California if you don't want to. It's a great place. But there is no real reason to live there.
- justboxing 9y agoIt's not as much a bubble as it is a supply-demand situation. > The buyers, who work in tech, had been hunting for a home for a while — but kept getting out-bid, said Mini Kalkat, the Intero agent who represented them: “They lost two before they bid on this one, so we kind of knew what the numbers would be. It’s a crazy market, but there’s a way to maneuver the market.” Source: Mercurynews.com [posted in previous Discussion] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15238835 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15238835 Given that the house is close to Apple HQ and other tech companies there, and that these buyers kept getting out-bid 2 times before, they probably got tired of it, and had the money to put in a very high 1st bid that would almost guarantee that they'd win it, and they won it. San Francisco went through a very similar situation from 1998 to 2004 (the .com bubble and burst was in that period). If you lookup any house in the city for a 10 year period (from 1995 to 2005) you'll notice that the prices almost tripped for most house, condos, big or small, because .com millionaires were doing something similar to what's mentioned in this story back then, i.e. placing ridiculously high bids over asking so they could guaranteed get a place, and since they had the money, they didn't give a sh*t. Even though the .com bubble burst brought down prices from 2004 - 2008, they didn't fall nearly as much as they rose in the 10 year prior.