7 ms·
And I'm just going to self-promote a bit and say that the bet was registered via a project I worked on, the Long Now Foundation's project Long Bets: http://lon
by wpietri 9y ago
And I'm just going to self-promote a bit and say that the bet was registered via a project I worked on, the Long Now Foundation's project Long Bets:
http://longbets.org/ http://longbets.org/
We've been going since 2002: https://www.wired.com/2002/05/longbets/ https://www.wired.com/2002/05/longbets/
We are happy to host bets of long-term significance, and the minimum bet is only $200/side. I am glad to personally help shepherd people who are serious about bets to make sure you get through the process.
I would especially like to see HNers making bets about the things we argue a lot about. Bitcoin! VR! Uber! If you're tired of people posting waffle on some topic where you have a strong opinion, then challenge them to put money down.
- igravious 9y agoCool. Put your money where your mouth is.
- wpietri 9y agoI'm not sure why this is getting downvoted; that's exactly the point. We get people to stake money and reputation, which makes them very careful about making clear, specific claims. There is a whole lot of mouth around the future, but very few testable predictions. We could have tried creating an apparatus for rigorous predictions, but everybody understands a bet.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agothis utterly rules. like, i want to fly to your current location to give you a fist bump. in my utopian dream world, every political pundit has to put their thoughts on here.
- vowelless 9y agoEven if they get funded by special interest groups to spew the group's narrative, at least this will be a quantization of how correct or incorrect the pundits are.
- imcrs 9y agothis would separate the wheat from the chaff with regards to special interest groups.
- wpietri 9y agoNext you're in SF, definitely look me up. A couple years back the Long Now opened a cafe and bar, so we even have a good place to meet for the fist bump: https://theinterval.org/ https://theinterval.org/
- osrec 9y agoThat's a very cool project! Congratulations on keeping it going for so long!
- yhoiseth 9y agoOn https://longbets.org/register/ https://longbets.org/register/, it says that "Long Bets registration is temporarily disabled. Please check back soon." Why is registration temporarily disabled? Can I get an email notification when it's back up?
- wpietri 9y agoGood question! Somebody took over running the technical side of that some years back, so I haven't followed it closely. I'll ask. But if anybody has a bet they'd like to get registered, just email me and/or them.
- godzillabrennus 9y agoWhat email should they use?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- timb07 9y agoIf longbets.org was really serious about long-term bets, it wouldn't be restricting years to only 5 digits. Haven't they heard of the Y100K problem?
- 0xJRS 9y agoWhat is the Y100K problem. More importantly, who would they pay out at that point when both parties are dead
- KingMob 9y agoWhat if you want to bet they find a cure for death?
- wpietri 9y agoWe would totally accept that bet. The closest bet we have right now is bet 11: “At least one human alive in the year 2000 will still be alive in 2150.” http://longbets.org/11/ http://longbets.org/11/ The tricky part is coming up with a clear agreement about what "cure" and "death" mean here. But there's a lot of good discussion around e.g., the extropians, so I think a solid bet could be created.
- jandrese 9y agoDoes "Brain in a Jar" count? How about a Ghost in the Shell? More likely this is a bet on if Cyrogenics finally works out.
- wpietri 9y agoYou mean for that bet? Good question, and not one I'm likely to have to answer. But from the arguments, the spirit seems to be about traditional meat-brain-in-meat-body life. Or do you mean for your own? This is between you and the person you bet with. If you have a firm opinion, definitely find somebody on the opposite side and see if you can put together a bet.
- wyldfire 9y agoCrazy question: how can/does longbets interact with people's estates? Meaning -- what happens when one of the bettors is dead when the bet is settled?
- wpietri 9y agoNo, it's a great question. We take the money up front and deposit it in a long-term investment account. Each bettor picks a charity, and the initial bet plus half the gains go to the winner's selected charity. (The charity thing is to get around US gambling laws.) If if that charity doesn't exist anymore (which is plausible given our longest current bet settles in 2150) then we pick a charity that's close in spirit.
- knodi123 9y ago> We take the money up front and deposit it in a long-term investment account A minimal-fee S&P 500 index fund, I hope. I think Buffett just proved that anything else would be fiscally irresponsible.
- rvern 9y agoLong Bets is a good site to make a public statement but PredictionBook[1] or Metaculus[2] may be better to track predictions about things we argue about. Both sites calculate your Brier score, which is how you can know how well calibrated you are.[3] Since prediction tracking and aggregation sites use reputation instead of money, they scale to a higher number of predictions. As proof, there have been only 747 predictions and bets on Long Bets, while gwern alone has made[4] 2275 on PredictionBook. Furthermore, the Metaculus community prediction provides valuable forecast information,[5] much like prediction markets, while predictions on Long Bets don't count as Bayesian evidence of their own. [1]: https://predictionbook.com/ https://predictionbook.com/ [2]: https://www.metaculus.com/ https://www.metaculus.com/ [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brier_score https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brier_score [4]: https://www.gwern.net/Prediction-markets https://www.gwern.net/Prediction-markets [5]: https://www.metaculus.com/questions/track-record/ https://www.metaculus.com/questions/track-record/
- wpietri 9y agoSure. These things have different purposes. The Long Now's mission is to foster long-term thinking broadly. We don't care as much how well-calibrated a particular individual is. The point of Long Bets is to generate discussion, argumentation, and consideration. That's part of why we require each bettor to make a case for their side: we're less interested in who was right or wrong than how and why someone was right or wrong. I hope that people also use those sites. But I would love to generate some clear, dramatic bets about controversial topics here. The Buffett bet is a great example. People every day are putting money into one investment or another and have been for a long time, and there's no lack of data on results. But because of this bet a great number of people have thought about these specifics, as well as the many interesting related issues. I'd love to see that around more topics.