4 ms·
> So why aren’t there millions of publishers springing up Not millions, but there are a lot of tools [1]. Among them, quite some publishers that are relatively
by Vinnl 9y ago
> So why aren’t there millions of publishers springing up
Not millions, but there are a lot of tools [1]. Among them, quite some publishers that are relatively cheap, e.g. [2] [3] [4] to name a few.
So yes, publishing costs money and that's often overlooked, but the current rates by many of the big publishers _are_ excessively high. And yes, the reason they manage to keep them that way is due to the Impact Factor [5], or in other words: not quality. (IF is considered a proxy of quality, but it's not quality itself.)
Yes, gold OA has been making a lot of progress, but at what cost? It has resulted in the transfer of the extortionate practices that allows subscription costs to balloon, to publication costs. So rather than researchers at less-wealthy institutes (or not at institutes at all) being unable to access research, they're unable to publish their own. Is that better? Maybe, but in any case, not by a lot.
That said, thank you for your perspective - it's great to be able to get out of the echo chamber sometimes.
[1] https://101innovations.wordpress.com/2015/12/25/timeline-of-tools/ https://101innovations.wordpress.com/2015/12/25/timeline-of-...
[2] https://www.ubiquitypress.com/ https://www.ubiquitypress.com/
[3] https://www.veruscript.com/ https://www.veruscript.com/
[4] https://www.openlibhums.org/ https://www.openlibhums.org/
[5] https://medium.com/flockademic/the-ridiculous-number-that-can-make-or-break-academic-careers-704e00ae070a https://medium.com/flockademic/the-ridiculous-number-that-ca...
- dougmccune 9y agoYup, there are lots of startups and new players trying to change the way publishing works. I think the focus on tools is misplaced (and is often the tack that startups try to take) because it discounts the cultural factors at play in the industry. I'm incredibly interested to see if the Open Library of Humanities can really take off, because essentially that's the same subscription model, but flipped a bit (universities join as members). Anyway, I love that there are all these moves in the industry, but what I was saying before is just that nothing yet has shown that it can be successful (the only real change that I'd argue has proven success is OA publishing via author fees). To your point about OA just shifting the costs from subscription to publication costs, that's entirely true. But that feels like a more honest business model to me. You provide a service, someone finds value in that service and pays you for it. The pricing is transparent (as opposed to the current bundle pricing that's different from institution to institution). It just feels cleaner. But yes, it still costs money. And that's where I'm arguing that that's because it's a service that people value that costs money to operate. In my view moving to APCs instead of subscriptions better aligns everyone's incentives. The author is the customer (although even now in an APC world the author doesn't really pay, it's the funding agency).
- Vinnl 9y agoI'm most enthusiastic about OLH too, although I do believe that tools can _help_ there to have it take off. And I see where you're coming from with APCs, but that's not the model we're moving towards, I'm afraid. Rather, big publishers and governments are like appear to be going to the Big Deal route once again, meaning that APCs still don't align with the service being provided. There's always more to publish, and thus Big Deal APCs can again be somewhat arbitrarily raised, just like subscription costs were.