3 ms·
I'd say it's more of a colorful description than an analogy. Consider the classic dining philosophers problem for a crazier example. Who eats with both hands, u
by mikeash 9y ago
I'd say it's more of a colorful description than an analogy. Consider the classic dining philosophers problem for a crazier example. Who eats with both hands, using different forks, and sharing forks with your neighbor? And yet being able to visualize it like that helps a lot.
- hedora 9y agoThe dining philosophers have chopsticks in all the formulations I've seen. Wikipedia disagrees with me, FWIW.
- mikeash 9y agoInteresting, never heard that variant before.
- saghm 9y agoIn my OS class in college, my professor actually took the time in the lecture to criticize the textbook for describing it with forks and spaghetti rather than the less ludicrous rice and chopsticks. OTOH, when the computer science club at my school had an event where you could go to literally act out the problem with others, they used double-ended forks (I think two forks taped together) to mitigate germ spreading.
- comex 9y agoBut a pair of chopsticks is meant to be held in one hand, and picking up food with one chopstick per hand is clumsy at best (since the sticks are at opposing angles rather than near-parallel). How about knives and meat, where the non-dominant hand’s knife is used in place of a fork? That would definitely require having one utensil in each hand. Seems a bit crude-mannered for erudite philosophers, though...
- yorwba 9y agoThe point is that chopsticks are interchangeable resources, unlike forks and knives, and you usually need two of them to eat, unlike forks. The story makes sense for me if you assume that the dining philosophers aren't going to use one chopstick per hand, but they have to pick up one to the left and one to the right before they can put two in one hand.
- taneq 9y agoChopsticks makes more sense, certainly. Although still, who shares chopsticks (much less trades individual chopsticks with other diners)?! I doubt this dinner ever actually happened. :P
- adrianN 9y agoPhilosophers do, obviously.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- musage 9y agoIs this some kind of contest in missing the point?
- psyc 9y agoThis whole thread is.
- mikeash 9y agoWasn't this the whole reason DARPA created the internet in the first place?
- hedora 9y agoClearly, you've never worked with philosophers.
- musage 9y agoWhat makes a philosopher other than love of wisdom? And in your estimation are they missing the point of other philosophers, or of non-philosophers? If the latter, what's a non-philosopher?