5 ms·
Wow. An article about Cat Stevens with no mention of Salman Rushdie. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Oienjf0GK8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Oienjf0GK8
by mcguire 9y ago
Wow. An article about Cat Stevens with no mention of Salman Rushdie.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Oienjf0GK8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Oienjf0GK8
- boxerab 9y agoYes, I found that quite strange too. I would not consider him actually returned until he apologizes for his support for the death sentence on Rushdie.
- e40 9y agoThere is this http://www.newshub.co.nz/entertainment/yusuf-islam-get-over-my-salman-rushdie-comments-2015010910 http://www.newshub.co.nz/entertainment/yusuf-islam-get-over-... where he doesn't seem to want to apologize. I'm not buying it, either.
- coldtea 9y agoOr, you know, whether he has returned or not (and dismissed his old beliefs or got over them), is orthogonal to whether he has the courage (or even the will) to apologize. He can return, but don't feel comfortable to apologizing. He can return, but feel like that's all behind and no apology is necessary, or that that was done by a different person. And several other possible cases -- a lot of which don't leave out the possibility of having regretted it. Like we can regret something in private and internally, the same holds true for famous people, artists etc. They are not moral playthings that the public has some right to demand of them public repentance and submission outside their creative roles.
- camus2 9y ago> Or, you know, whether he has returned or not (and dismissed his old beliefs or got over them), is orthogonal to whether he has the courage (or even the will) to apologize. Or you know, maybe he doesn't feel the need to apologize because he still believe people should be killed for writing books, especially when these books have very little to do with Islam and when the people calling for murder didn't even read the damn book. I bet Yusuf didn't even read the Satanic verses either.
- eastWestMath 9y agoThe public certainly has the right to boycott an artist's work if they committed a morally reprehensible action without any sign of remorse. The public doesn't owe the artist anything.
- philtar 9y agoYou have the right to boycott his work just because he has a bad hair day. That's up to you. You do not have the right to demand public acts from him/her.
- sevensor 9y agoI don't think we should boycott his work, though. Certainly we don't owe him anything, but the music he made as Cat Stevens is beautiful and it would be sad for the world to lose it. We'd impoverish our culture if we cut out all the art made by disagreeable people.
- camus2 9y ago> I don't think we should boycott his work, though. Certainly we don't owe him anything, but the music he made as Cat Stevens is beautiful and it would be sad for the world to lose it. We'd impoverish our culture if we cut out all the art made by disagreeable people. Calling Yusuf "Cat Stevens" Islam "disagreeable" is a euphemism, he is a bigot and an religious extremist of the worse kind. He wants people to get killed for their ideas although I bet he didn't even read Rushdie.
- coldtea 9y ago>The public certainly has the right to boycott an artist's work if they committed a morally reprehensible action without any sign of remorse. It has the right, it's just stupid to exercise it. It's not as if we should only consume art made by good people. Or that whatever bad things an artists does in their personal life has much bearing to wether their art is any good (not to mention most good and bad things in one's life improve art: they instill it with life experience. Boy scouts seldom produce interesting work.). If you want to punish the artist for something they did, put them in jail. Or don't be friends with them. If they produce good art, and you don't listen to it because they are bad, you lose too. >The public doesn't owe the artist anything Well, if they listen to his works, then they owe him on that.
- dogruck 9y agoAgreed -- the article avoids every elephant in the room.
- abruzzi 9y agoI was the wrong age and wrong musical taste, so the first time I even heard of Cat Stevens was in relation to his support of the Khomeini fatwa against Rushdie. It appears he tried to walk it back somewhat, but the first statement is pretty clear and difficult to misinterpret: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cat_Stevens%27_comments_about_Salman_Rushdie https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cat_Stevens%27_comments_abou...
- BuckRogers 9y agoCat Stevens is my dad's age and I never did ask him if he was a fan of his music. He never mentioned CS while I was growing up. Doing a little research on this guy, now combined with your video is not favorable. He claimed that he wanted a secular speaker to die for disrespecting the prophet Muhammad. There's a 2015 interview where he remains unapologetic. I hope his comeback is a failure because publicly calling for someone's murder and sticking to it for 25 years is pathetic. I have many Muslim friends, many of whom were some of the best friends I've ever had in my life. They trust and respect me enough that they consider me one of them, so they were open with me. Given conversations with them I've had in the past, they weren't as dogmatic as Cat Stevens is. And they were born and raised in Saudi Arabia. Perhaps it's because they really know Islam (most of them are still believers) thus not as naive as a foreigner like Stevens.
- rev_bird 9y agoI can't tell what you're trying to say -- is it that you're against the commercial success of Stevens because of the fatwa? What does it matter that your dad has no opinion of him, or that you have Muslim friends?
- BuckRogers 9y agoIt's pretty self-explanatory. Reading comprehension is important because not everything you read is going to be a pithy simple point. To paraphrase. I'm saying I never knew who this guy was, checked into him without any bias and he's a terrible man. Even compared him to born and raised Muslim friends who are from the most extreme Islamic nation. I have tight friendships with them so they've spoken very openly to me in private, and it's Cat Stevens who makes Muslims look bad.
- cobbzilla 9y ago"Some remarks attributed to him seemed to be in line with some of the more distasteful prejudices of orthodox Islam." holy circumlocution batman! this is as close as the author will get, and in the passive voice no less. i did enjoy his tunes in Harold & Maude. but i think Rushdie is right, he's a different person.
- sremani 9y agoSalman Rushdie's take on Yusuf https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ThUgpNYr2Oo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ThUgpNYr2Oo
- duncan_bayne 9y agoIt's a pretty burning issue for them to have ignored.