14 ms·
Three Years in Identity Theft Hell
- maximumkek 9y agoWhat product can I buy to protect myself from this very scary identity theft threat?
- sillysaurus3 9y agoCounterintuitively, this is evidence that the Equifax breach isn't necessarily going to cause massive harm. If someone wanted to impersonate you, they could already. I remain hopeful that the full list of 140M SSNs will be posted in full. It's a rare opportunity: if that happens, the US will have no choice but to finally switch to a new system. One that doesn't rely on SSNs being private. That's the absurdity. It is easy to steal your identity because we have allowed it to be easy. It's going to be difficult to switch to a new system, but the pain will be worth it. Imagine if the author could finally have peace of mind because nobody could impersonate him. That is a fairytale, admittedly. It's always going to be possible to steal someone's identity if you're determined. But just look how trivial it is right now. Your driver's license plus the thief's photo is all they need. And it's possible to forge: they don't even need to swipe your physical one. Those are “the keys to the kingdom,” said Bo Holland, CEO of AllClear ID, an identity-monitoring service. “Once you have somebody's name, social, birth date, and address, you can go and open new accounts.” The SSN shouldn't be the critical key in that list. https://youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus https://youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus
- waqf 9y ago> the world The United States. I assure you that even though other countries have credit reporting, they do not use SSNs. > will have no choice but to finally switch to a new system. Really? I think they will just carry on unless and until the financial downside (losses from extending bad credit, or lawsuits from identity theft victims, or penalties from the federal government intervening directly) is shown to be really huge.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoFixed, thanks. What do you feel are some sensible systems used by the rest of the world? One that's hopefully hard enough to break but easy enough not to cause massive hassles.
- kmonsen 9y agoBetter checks by the banks, they need to take responsibility when opening accounts and not rely on the credit bureaus. This could mean slightly more expensive banking services.
- user5994461 9y agoTo confirm your identify: national ID card, passport or driver license. To confirm your income: Your yearly income tax sheet, a payslip or your contract of employment. There is really no reason whatsoever for credit check and background check agencies to exist. All they do is ask for these papers anyway.
- harryh 9y agoIt's worth noting that the perpetrator in the bloomberg article had a fake driver's license in the name of the victim. So ID cards aren't a complete solution either.
- noncoml 9y ago> Counterintuitively, this is evidence that the Equifax breach isn't necessarily going to cause massive harm. If someone wanted to impersonate you, they could already. This argument doesn't not follow logically. It's like saying you shouldn't lock your house because if somebody really wants to get in, they will do it.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoYes and no. At a certain point, if people keep breaking into our houses, it's a good idea to think about the locks we use.
- noncoml 9y agoThat's a different argument, than the one in the first line, to which I completely agree.
- matz1 9y agoIt does follow. Not locking your house is not going to cause massive harm. If somebody really wants to get in, they will do itm
- noncoml 9y agoI guess you leave your front door open every morning before leaving for work?
- matz1 9y agoWe are talking about leaving door unlocked, not leaving the door open. I lock the door every morning out of habit but I'm pretty sure its unlikely that something happen if I don't.
- noncoml 9y agoI don't know what you are trying to argue about, but somebody got hold of personal details, SSN and credit card details of 140 million people. The argument that it is ok, because anyway if somebody wanted it really hard they would find a way to get my personal details, is illogical.
- incompatible 9y agoHow would a more secure system work? Biometrics? Smart cards?
- sampo 9y ago> How would a more secure system work? Just look what many other countries do.
- incompatible 9y agoI'm not sure that any country has really solved it convincingly. Sure, they do better than the US and its secret SSNs, but that doesn't say much.
- incompatible 9y agoI mean, countries may have national identity cards with chips and perhaps biometrics that make them hard to forge, but a) I believe there's opposition in the US to identity cards b) do they help establish identity remotely, e.g., online?
- detaro 9y agoYou can activate German ID cards to work as RFID smartcards for online identification. Practically, there aren't all that many places to do it, and not many people do so. You also need a smartcard reader, but those were available reasonably cheap (no idea if a smartphone with NFC can do it or not) (You also can have a certificate on it, but they missed an opportunity and didn't make it default, you have to ask for and pay extra for that. Would have been a chance to widely roll out certificates of the standard necessary to legally replace signatures, instead of other crap that has been proposed as a replacement sigh)
- twiss 9y agoThe Netherlands has an OAuth system for online identity verification, called DigiD, for anything government-related (taxes, healthcare, etc.) Other than that, occasionally a service asks for a copy of your passport, although that's not really allowed.
- quuquuquu 9y ago>the US will have no choice [but to switch to a better, non-SSN based system] I absolutely hope this happens too... ... but I have a feeling all of the banks and agencies involved will find a way to plug their ears more and pretend nothing is wrong. They will look at how costly and complex it is to create a halfway decent identity system (even though it's really not hard, other countries do it just fine with digital and physical keys/tokens). And they will just continue to push the burden of ID theft onto consumers, rather than their businesses.
- rxhernandez 9y agoThis logic is so impressively bad I don't know where to begin. Okay how about this, I'm going to pretend I lack morals for a second. I would do this with the information: 1. Write a script to webscrape sites like LinkedIn to find out if a name/address/ssn key could be tied to people like doctors, engineers and whoever else might have sufficient disposable income. 2. I would take out loans in their name. If I have to be there in person, I would go from city to city and find people I could easily get dirt on, like people that might be here illegally. I would then cut them in for a piece of the loan and then move onto a random city in a 200 mile radius. 3. Move away after I get away with enough to live on for the rest of my life. 4. Hell I might just sell the rest of the information and scripts to other people who lack scruples.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoAnd you'd end up in prison pretty quickly. The point is, it'd be worth the pain. We'd come out of it with a better system.
- usaphp 9y agoThe flaw in your logic lays with the bank. You will need a bank account/visit branch/transfer loaned money somewhere where you can cash them. Banks have cameras + Irs will quickly find you and won't allow you disappear or use that money
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rxhernandez 9y agoThe flaw in your logic is that you fail to realize i have access to 143 million bank accounts and can transfer any number of ways I want to. You also overestimate the competence of smaller banks. Neglecting all of that you do realize that International wire transfers do exist right?
- usaphp 9y agoIt takes 1-3 business days for a US bank to transfer any amount and I am sure it will be even higher if the transaction is not matching a usual pattern of your victim. So 144 million bank accounts mean nothing with such long processing delays
- pmorici 9y agoStart issuing everyone a FIPS 201-2 PIV card instead of those flimsy paper cards the SSN's are currently printed on.
- snarf21 9y agoThe big problem is switch from SSN to what? Just another number that serves the same purpose? SSN is fine, what we need is the right for our credit to always be frozen and anyone who grants credit outside of our approval is liable for the loss. We also just need to bite the bullet and make chip and pin mandatory everywhere. We don't need to make identity theft impossible just reasonably hard. Other nations seem to have it figured out.
- narrator 9y agoAll they need is an ssn you can change if it gets stolen. To change it all that's needed is to go into a government office and do a biometric scan in person. That would be so ridiculously easy. Of course the government will never let a good crisis go to waste. Instead, we will all get chips under our skin that can't be removed that will be passively scanned by the authorities everywhere we go.
- pas 9y agoSSN is a primary key, not a shared secret. The entire problem is that people started using SSN as a shared secret, but it was classic password reuse. Use the same secret every fucking where. No. If you want to establish trust, use a random secret for each new trust relationship. If you want to establish identity ask the identity providers what kind of anti-forgery guarantees they provide. Oh, nothing, you say!? Then don't use that provider. Banks are trying to use easy to forge things to make sure they won't lose money. Sounds like stupidity. So they limit their stupidity (hence you can't just register for a credit card online, otherwise bored Russian teenagers would have already bankrupted them).
- narrator 9y agoWhat if, when you replaced your SSN, banks could use a system that would return "invalid SSN" on any new credit application. The existing accounts would be suspended unless you called them and updated your SSN. It would be about as much as a hassle as updating all of one's autopays when a credit card number gets stolen.
- eastWestMath 9y agoI think I've seen you defending Equifax on every post related to identity theft since the breach. Do you work there or something, why are you so invested in this?
- tryingagainbro 9y agoThe SSN shouldn't be the critical key in that list. So it would a "Credit ID," Passport Number, DL #, or something related. What's the difference, it will need to be stored next all your stuff, awaiting to be stolen. Now the banks eat the small % caused by fraud (cost of doing biz), your life is hell, but not theirs. Scan your iris before getting the new loan isn't going to happen either, too costly and slow. If they ever do that online, they'll find a way to recreate that based on your existing scan, stored at the future Experian.
- watwut 9y agoI haven't seen password I'd or national card I'd used as identification, ever. The way it works is that you bring it physically and they look into it. Or that you send photo of the id (yes that is easier to forge, then again harder then forging utility bill) - that is done only where it is impossible to do physical check and never with loans and such. Identity theft in Europe is extremely rare. It is possible to do something in your name, sure, but it does not happen nowhere near as often and damage is limited compared to ssn system.
- tryingagainbro 9y ago>> The way it works is that you bring it physically and they look into it. Not gonna happen, banks for now will rather swallow the relatively low loses due to fraud. In USA you sign a piece of paper (pre-approved loan), or login online and the loan money is deposited in your account within a few days. All automated. So far it works out for them, if fraud loses increase, the banks, not us, will choose the next method. And Congress will approve it within weeks.
- rocqua 9y agoThe issue is that fraud causes more loss than just for the bank. Whomever got impersonated is also fucked. At the moment, they have very little recourse to recoup their costs from the bank that got fooled.
- ProblemFactory 9y ago
- joshmn 9y agoHate to break it to you, but with very minimal browsing and $4 in bitcoin, anyone can buy any SSN of a US person born after 2003.
- nitrogen 9y agoanyone can buy any SSN of a US person born after 2003. Why only 14-year-olds and younger?
- tscs37 9y agoBecause the kids these days will enter their SSN and their parent's Credit Card into anything that looks like flappy bird to unlock the extra jump boost or something like that.
- joshmn 9y agoThat wouldn't explain my sister's.
- joshmn 9y agoI haven't the base, and there are conflicting sources about where the base came from (only two persons have it that I know of)
- Tomte 9y ago> if that happens, the US will have no choice but to finally switch to a new system. Impossible. A large part of the American people is obsessed with "the government is going to oppress us all". National IDs or anything similarly working are therefore a big no-go. If you could solve this problem, you could presumably also solve the gun debate to a large degree.
- criddell 9y agoThere's also a lot of people that object to a national ID number on religious grounds. These people vote and seem to be influential.
- glitcher 9y ago> “Once you have somebody's name, social, birth date, and address, you can go and open new accounts.” >The SSN shouldn't be the critical key in that list. Nothing in that list is secret.
- md_ 9y agoI recently had the brilliant idea that someone should create a site where we all enter our social security numbers and personal information (DOB, name, etc), with the promise that once the site collects, say, 100M verified records, all of them will be released. Seems like an opportunity to force the hand. I, like you, imagine such an action would induce systemic change. Maybe.
- stretchwithme 9y agoThe hassles and inconvenience this problem causes victims is sort of an unpriced externality of the credit industry. If those extending credit had to compensate the victims for their negligence, maybe they'd stop being so negligent. And it would help if individual making the faulty decision to extend credit lost all their commissions for the week. It should be a blight on their record, with more than 5 instances causing them to lose their jobs. And CEO of the worst offending company gets a hefty fine. Maybe that would focus the industry on solving this problem.
- sus_007 9y agoI submitted this like 2 days ago :D https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15247810 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15247810
- fencepost 9y agoSometimes things get attention and sometimes they don't. Also sometimes it's a slow news weekend and other times there's a ton happening. Don't ever stress about whether your submission gets traction.
- sus_007 9y agoNo worries man, m just sayin
- tomhoward 9y agoIt might be worth reading Dang's comment history discussing reposts: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=dang%20porous&sort=byPopularity&prefix&page=0&dateRange=all&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=dang%20porous&sort=byPopularit... It feels shitty when someone else gets the points for something you submitted earlier, but life isn't always fair, and as long as you keep submitting good content and making good comments, things even out in the end.
- quickthrower2 9y agoPlus karma ain't worth jack.
- needsilence 9y agoPaul Graham, is that you?
- myrandomcomment 9y agoOkay, blocked of time to freeze my credit on Monday.
- e40 9y agoYou can do it online now.
- FireBeyond 9y agoAs of Friday, all three credit services online freeze processes were "broken" due to demand (and/or other crappiness).
- e40 9y agoI completed all three yesterday. Late in the day, but it worked.
- matheweis 9y agoThe pin code they will give you to unlock it is the date/time stamp of when you locked it. And, if you happen to forget it, they will unlock it if you can cough up the very information supposedly compromised in the equifax leak anyway.
- throwaway613834 9y ago> And, if you happen to forget it, they will unlock it if you can cough up the very information supposedly compromised in the equifax leak anyway. Wait, what? Any more reading on this?
- interlocutor 9y agoHere's the link to "obtain your forgotten or misplaced PIN". https://www.experian.com/ncaconline/freezepin https://www.experian.com/ncaconline/freezepin And it says, "provide your e-mail address for faster delivery of your results."
- Exuma 9y agoSo how does one protect against this if freezing is useless because all that information was leaked anyway?
- ljoshua 9y agoFreezing doesn't protect the information, but it does protect your credit account from being added to. Once frozen, you are almost in a 2FA scenario where creditors are required to request any new accounts or credit hits, and the credit agency is required to then obtain your approval using the private information only you (should) know.
- Exuma 9y agoSo how should I protect myself other than monitoring my credit using creditkarma? What do people do who have millions of dollars, theres nothing else other than just pray?
- ubernostrum 9y agoYou freeze. It sucks that it's the only option, but it's the only option right now. The only way someone can open a new bank account, credit card or loan in your name under the freeze is if they A) have the credit-bureau-specific PIN to lift the freeze, or B) the account was somehow opened without doing any kind of credit check.
- patio11 9y agoFreezing doesn't protect the information, but it does protect your credit account from being added to. Going to take the liberty of adding to this because the imprecision might cause some people to develop a poor model of how financial institutions work: you don't have a "credit account." You have a few firms which have partial views of your "credit history", sourced by reports from some firms you've previously done business with before. What a freeze does is that those firms (CRAs) who could disclose your credit history to a bank will, instead, report to the bank "That file is frozen." How is this different from your mental model? Because credit decision is between a financial institution and a bank -- they don't have to ask anyone else's permission, including the CRA, to lend you money. They also don't have to "respect" a freeze on your file; it's purely advisory. It may deter _some_ banks from issuing you _some_ credit but it will likely not deter _all_ banks from issuing you _all_ credit products.
- Chathamization 9y ago> “We demand convenience over security,” Velasquez said. Banks send a constant stream of credit card offers through the mail and pay people to use credit cards (with rewards). Stores are always trying to get you to sign up for their credit cards and offering big discounts if you do, and car dealerships offer special deals - but only if you agree to finance your car. People might want more credit, but lets be honest - the financial industry is doing everything it can to shovel debt onto the American public. Imagine if a loan shark went door to door in a neighborhood paying residents $500 to take one of his loans. That seems almost cartoonishly evil, but that's more or less what the financial industry does. And it's not hard to see why - the average credit card has an annual interest rate of 15%. Even after you factor in things rewards and people who don't pay, you're still looking at a very nice rate of return. It's hard to see how identity theft isn't directly linked to financial institutions trying to make credit as easily available and as widespread as possible. Instead of viewing identity theft as a high price to pay for the convenience we want, it should be viewed as yet another terrible consequence of the financial industry's efforts to push as much debt onto Americans as they can.
- nvahalik 9y agoI had my "identity" stolen by someone who tried to open accounts at local banks after somehow managing to swipe a copy of my drivers license (from our mail box, as far as we know) and seemingly only was able to rent a Uhaul in my name (unbeknownst to me until I tried to rent one to move). The banks kicked him back and he tried forging checks from others (not me). I filed the reports with the police. And checked my credit. Nothing serious happened as he seems to have been pretty much thwarted by most places he went. But then he got caught when he was pulled over for having a brake light out. All in all I suffered no real harm from this guy. Seems like for the most part the system works...
- djsumdog 9y agoMy old flatmate was the victim of identity theft around 2010. After tons of paperwork, calling banks, closing accounts, working with the police .. he still lost about $3k that he didn't feel it was worth to try to recover. You just got lucky and caught it early.
- md_ 9y agoHow did he lose $3k? I've been curious about the real-world impacts of identity theft for quite some time. In the article linked, the author's only obvious losses were a) on the home mortgage (couldn't cosign; worse rate) and b) at the airport, with TSA (which I don't get; how did his credit rating have an impact on the secondary security screening?). It's unclear to me why I should care that much about identity theft, or what a thief can do. I'm not saying it wouldn't be a huge hassle to get calls from scammed creditors or be unable to obtain consumer credit, but I am fortunate enough not to need credit and I already have the credit cards and bank accounts I need. There is the whole IRS fraudulent return thing, which could be quite tedious to sort out and meantime would take real money. But that's about all I can think of unless you need consumer credit.
- needsilence 9y agoYou've never lived in a state where your car insurance premium depends on your credit score, have you. I think you understand perfectly well the problems identity theft can cause, but you're just being intentionally obtuse. > It's unclear to me... what a thief can do. Um... well... how about anything you can do with your identity, except it's someone else? Do you really not understand why that's a bad thing?
- rwallace 9y ago> There’s a logic to the maze you have to run to expose fraudulent financial accounts. In an economic system where U.S. consumers carry $12.73 trillion in household debt, you shouldn’t be able to just call up, say “it wasn't me,” and leave thousands of dollars in obligations by the wayside. Perhaps if it was easier to do that, there would be less of the predatory lending that created such a crippling burden of debt.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- unabridged 9y agoMy solution is make a site called credit.gov This would be the final say in any credit accounts, accounts not listed here are not legal debt (ie they cannot be collected or sued for) You can still use SSN for identification but authorization would require more. I imagine maybe a few different levels of security: 1. Password (or list of passwords) you can set/change in person at any post office. The company adding the credit account would need this password to register the debt. 2. Yubikey or other auth token you can register at the post office to create one time passwords for companies creating credit accounts. 3. Every new credit account requires physical confirmation at the post office. Then just setup really good cameras (maybe face scanner or biometric scanner) at every post office and make it like a 10 year felony to impersonate someone at the post office. The scammers will be out of the system very quickly.
- jakobegger 9y agoWhy is this only a problem in the US? I think that one of the reasons is that the US does not have a central government registry of all the people. In Austria, we have the „Melderegister“. Every person that stays in Austria is required to register the address of their current residence. Your name and address is always in this registry, from the day you are born until you die (foreigners residing in Austria are also required to register). Everything relies on this registry — voting rights, taxes, etc. I think that Banks can check this register to verify your address. So even if an identity thief is successful in applying for a credit card, that credit card would be mailed to the victims actual address, so the identity thief would have to intercept postal mail as well. So many problems that I read about in the US (using utiliy bills to proof you are a resident, registering to vote) just sound like a clumsy workaround to the fact that there is no „Melderegister“.
- aryehof 9y agoCountries like Australia do not have a central government registry of all people, unlike most countries, including those in Europe. Each State does have a register of all births and deaths. There is no national ID. It surprises many that one is free to carry NO identification. One can decide to not work (get a tax number), not drive (get a drivers license), not travel (get a passport), not get free healthcare (get a medicare card), not vote (evade census'). Unlike most countries, one doesn't need to register or let anyone know where you live, and there is no national service (conscription). It also has very little identity fraud.
- stefs 9y agowhy does the US not have a central registry? is it for historical/cultural reasons, i.e. the dislike of "(big) government" by certain groups? also, how would one get around the problem for homeless people or people without a permanent residency?
- hendry 9y agoI've been a victim of identity theft in Europe. Took many letters to several police departments in the UK and various states in Germany over the course of five years... I've not been stopped at EU airports for awhile but I am still not 100% sure if my name is on the Interpol blacklist still. The process of clearing your name is totally opaque. A helpful officer at London MET assured me to undertake the work to do it. The amount of times I've had to explain the very concept of "identity theft" to enforcement is just crazy. And sadly I don't think they fully understand it most of the time. I'm a little afraid to travel to eastern Europe, since this "advance fee" for a VW fraud in my name is particularly common there and I am tired of receiving threats. Sigh....
- jorgec 9y agoIn my country, its the bank that has the responsibility to ensure that they are talking with the right person. If not, then its the bank who will pay, not the customer. So, the banks here are pretty annoying, opening an account is a lengthily process.
- hughperkins 9y ago^^^ This. Why is this not in fact the case?
- 1024core 9y agoBecause banks think that if they inconvenience people, they'll lose customers. Convenience trumps security in the US.
- peteretep 9y ago> In an economic system where U.S. > consumers carry $12.73 trillion in > household debt, you shouldn’t be able > to just call up, say “it wasn't me,” > and leave thousands of dollars in > obligations by the wayside. Yes, you should, and the banks should be the ones left holding the bag. The author did nothing wrong, and was victimized by the banks' incompetence at adequate fraud checks.
- siliconc0w 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_ID_card https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_ID_card - everyone get's their own cryptographic certificate. I don't know why banks aren't pushing for a legit national ID, if anything it would make it easier to lend and eliminate a lot of expensive fraud.
- DiscoKing 9y agoI just realized, within the last year I went to the US and opened a bank account. I don't live in the US now, but I think I might be effected by the equifax hack now. Is it possible to check without waving legal rights?