3 ms·
Most non-technical people I know have trouble with "simple" undo-redo and copy-paste ; this would only make it harder for them.
by jcelerier 9y ago
Most non-technical people I know have trouble with "simple" undo-redo and copy-paste ; this would only make it harder for them.
- jfoutz 9y agoToys vs tools. I want paying my electric bill to by trivial. If I'm doing real work, I want all the power software can give me. I can forgive my retired grandmother for not getting copy and paste. A professional however, should constantly strive to improve their mastery of their tools.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoExactly. Toys vs. tools. Or, as AK put in the interview: "Well, a saying I made up at PARC was, “Simple things should be simple, complex things should be possible.” They’ve got simple things being simple and they have complex things being impossible, so that’s wrong."
- zmix 9y agoSo what? It shouldn't be too difficult to implement three states of userspace and have it be selected upon login: - Novice - Advanced - Expert 'Novice' gives you simple 'undo'. 'Advanced' gives you 'undo' with history. And 'Expert' gives you branching. For example... For file-managers this could be made so, that the novice gets something like the Finder or WindowsExplorer. Basically a file-browser, that handles its pane contents as a document. 'Advanced' gives you tabs, rearrangable layouts (dual-pane) and some more configuration. 'Expert' gives you fully configurable menus and toolbars, integrated with the hosts generic scripting host. Etc.
- coldtea 9y agoImplementing even one of those is hard, and costs tons of developer salaries, for what might ultimately fail anyway (like most software products/startups do). All 3?
- astrange 9y agoFinder does have tabs, and further automation is available through scripting (AppleScript and Terminal). Actually, both scripting and the commandline are effective ways of making you organize your program into nouns and verbs that can be extended by the user. But I don’t think rearranging the basic UI is that useful, because all your users are basically the same - we’re all human and not Lisp programmers.
- jeffdavis 9y agoIf everyone took the time to really learn and understand advanced undo/redo, I wonder how that would change our thinking? Might we find all kinds of new ways to apply it in the physical world? Maybe the reason people find it hard now is just the limit of natural languages as they exist today. We haven't made time travel, alternative realities, and hypotheticals a part of our ordinary speech (beyond trivial cases), but maybe we should?
- alankay 9y agoDon't you think that a good GUI and visualization of the situations and consequences would do the trick (i.e. think about what the GUI accomplished for interacting with computers at all). I fear that too many technical people have no feel for the plight of the users (and amazingly to me, for their own plight as users -- they are often willing to put up with execrable BS in their own programming environments).