4 ms·
To me, the question sort of misses why (I believe) people use Excel instead of something else. I think people use Excel for all the things that are missing from
by brudgers 9y ago
To me, the question sort of misses why (I believe) people use Excel instead of something else. I think people use Excel for all the things that are missing from other spreadsheets. Google gives away its spreadsheet and markets it to everyone with a Gmail account and makes it easy to use and people still pay for Excel because the cost of the missing features outweighs the price of the paid software.
Sure there are people who will express dissatisfaction with Excel. And many many use cases for which Google's product is good enough. But it is all the edge cases that Excel covers that makes it viable to standardize upon across a user base where some users have a significant level of expertise and that expertise is diverse.
To put it another way, free and available anywhere and easy collaboration are all great features. But they are not enough. Killer features will only become killer once a spreadsheet does pretty much everything Excel does (and in pretty much the way Excel does it so that muscle memory works).
- joehan 9y agoI don't work in tech industry but from my experience it's a lot simpler than that. Most of these day-to-day desk workers know nothing but excel because that's all they know from home and work.
- brudgers 9y agoI agree that most people just default to Excel. Mostly that's because there isn't really any competition and Excel is the default and even if there was competition, it would not matter because Excel has a low initial cost except when compared with free. More subtly, Excel has a low lifetime cost because there are many good learning resources (and also many bad ones) and those resources are widely available. Which makes me think that one of the killer features of Excel is all the technical headroom it provides for solving problems...by which I mean there is usually functionality and features that could make an ordinary job faster...particularly repetitive ordinary jobs of the sort most people wind up doing.
- tixocloud 9y agoAgreed. The thing about Excel isn't about the features. It's about the adoption across pretty every company in the world. It's in schools and it's used at work. When people become proficient in a tool, they are less willing to learn a whole new tool to accomplish basically the same thing Excel can. They will just ask the company to buy Excel. And it's cheaper to buy Excel than to pay for the employee to train on the new tool.