4 ms·
A modern phone actually makes a good attempt at replacing: Notepad Telephone Letter post Still camera Movie camera (not common in 1957) Security camera mo
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
A modern phone actually makes a good attempt at replacing:
Notepad
Telephone
Letter post
Still camera
Movie camera (not common in 1957)
Security camera monitor (needs external hardware, but still)
Audio recorder
Cinema
Library
Music collection
Games arcade
Map and navigation system
Magazine and newspaper stand
Store catalogues (concierge shopping, to some extent)
News and weather on TV
TV (partly...)
Job search
Travel guide
Restaurant and hotel finder
Flight booking and checkin tool
Business memo distribution system
Classroom toys and child entertainment
Textbook and trainer for older/adult students (limited, but hardly non-existent)
Quick notes for friends and family
Clearly there's quite a bit more value than just "information delivery."
Source data doesn't need to be absorbed. No one in 1957 seriously expected readers to memorise the written text of newspapers or magazines, and no one seriously expects Facebook or Twitter users to memorise entire feeds today.
So the actual volume of useful information consumed daily has increased by a huge amount, and it's presented in a far more accessible and interactive/participative form than it used to be.
The point is that mobile devices connected to an open public data network generate huge economic synergies. Processing speed and memory are far less relevant than automation of old applications and the development of whole classes of new applications. Both have literally been transformative.
As for liberal democracy and journalism - those are no more endangered now than they used to be. Technology is a social multiplier, and if the roots of a culture aren't sound media of all kinds will reflect that - but that's a political problem, not one caused by technology.
- dredmorbius 9y agoThank you for that list, all of which is precisely information delivery, or capture. Having lived in both eras, I'm rather familiar with the general set, and not entirely unsympathetic to some of the benefits. And costs. You might consider how else such needs, or in many cases, wants, were previously satisfied. Or accommodated, or in which activities worked around their lack. And how, often in initially subtle ways, the smaartphone's presence has changed the structures and institutions it interacts with. But as I've expanded on this elsewhere, the supposed economic analysis of DeLong is missing key insights. Data and computation, much as work, expand to fill available time. It's less how much computation can you buy and far more how much are you willing to spend. A curious aspect of computers is that the price points have remained remarkably resilient. In nominal currency, even. The original IBM PC cost $1,565. A current-generation Lenovo (successor to IBM), say, the P310SFF is priced at about half that, $710, plus $160 for the monitor, or a total of $870. It seems that for typical end-use the question is more of "how much computing can I buy for a given budget, than how much will X amount of computing power cost me. As for technology (and especially communications) not changing or disrupting democracy or society, I'd very much suggest you reassess that premise as it seems to me that every communications revolution, dating to speech itself, has had profound and often highly disruptive effects. Elizabeth Eisenstein captures some of that in The Printing Press as an Agent of Change. The role of cheap press, radio, audio tape, microphones and public address, photoreproduction, and cinema in the rise and spread of fascism is another hugely instructive episode. DeLong expresses awareness of none of this.