4 ms·
So, child porn is legal as long as both parties are involved? That doesn't work either. All you will wind up doing is having people magically always have only
by bsder 9y ago
So, child porn is legal as long as both parties are involved? That doesn't work either. All you will wind up doing is having people magically always have only two people involved. And "teen sexting" isn't even uniform: a 10-year-old sexting a 16-year-old is generally a problem while a 17-year-old sexting an 18-year-old likely isn't.
Your opponents in kiddie porn are two different sets of people: 1) the egregiously stupid, generally teenagers, who may or may not be malicious about it and 2) the horrifically competent and malicious who WILL find a way to exploit any loophole.
Group 2 is what makes child pornography laws so problematic. Anything you do to strengthen your ability to get Group 2 generally increases the collateral damage in Group 1.
This is exactly what "prosecutorial discretion" is supposed to be used for. Unfortunately, it seems that "prosecutorial discretion" is now mostly "scoring poltical points for election."
- mediocrejoker 9y agoWhich is better, to have a few horrifically competent go free or have a few innocent teenagers on the sex offender registry?
- glogla 9y agoIt seem that nowadays, people want to err on the side of needlessly ruining lives instead of risking the possibility of life unruined.
- jliptzin 9y agoTo have a few horrifically competent go free.
- bsder 9y agoThat's a really interesting question. I'm always on the side of "convicting innocents is wrong" because I consider it a pure civil liberty issue subject to abuse. However, you are going to have to defend against people doing a "damage amount" calculation. The malicious individuals are so vile and cause so much damage and exploitation while teenage sexting cases are generally sufficiently rare that the calculus probably doesn't come up in your favor. In addition, I have see firsthand from a bystander position that prosecutors are generally pretty good about teen sexting. I watched as a prosecutor patiently explained to an idiot mother that if he managed to convict the boy in the sexting case, he was also paving the way to convict her daughter of exactly the same thing. So, she could go along, and both of the involved parties would get some relatively innocuous conviction that would go away for both when they became 18, or she could make a big fuss and both of them would be sex offender registrees (the DA was clearly going to uncover evidence of statutory rape along the way--the boy and girl were obviously having sex with each other). The DA really didn't want the case to go very far. Of course, the DA involved didn't have to bow to religious nutcases to get elected. The relatives of the mother finally browbeat her into submission, but it was unclear which way it was going to go for quite a while and it could have gone very badly for all parties involved.
- lovich 9y agoAre adults actively seeking child pornography more common than teens experimenting? If that is true it would be a little disgusting/terrifying
- bsder 9y agoWhile lots of teens are sending pictures, the number of cases that actually get involved in the legal system tends to be low. Generally something stupid has to happen--posted to Facebook, being shared around at school, comes up in a divorce proceeding, found on phone while being searched, etc.--before a DA is going to bother getting involved.
- mirimir 9y agoOK, but that just makes it a horrible precedent that's arbitrarily enforced.
- bsder 9y agoYou are framing the problem wrongly. The FIRST problem is the existence of the "sex offender registry" AT ALL. If you get rid of the sex offender registry then the problems around the child pornography laws become far less acute.
- astral303 9y agoSex offender registry ruins lives far far far beyond what is morally "right." Google it.
- nv-vn 9y agoI wouldn't call anyone egregiously stupid for engaging in normal sexual activity. If the vast majority of teens doing so have gone unprosecuted, why should someone assume that something might happen to them for the same action? A risk/reward analysis will not make it seem like such a bad idea, so I can't see what part makes the teen particularly stupid here.
- astral303 9y agoReligious-based prohibitionism of premarital sex is a real problem in America. It's one of the frontiers of the culture war. So, please, donate to your local Planned Parenthood.
- Larrikin 9y agoWhy are you trying to imply that planned parenthood promotes sex between minors and a donation will encourage that?
- JamesBarney 9y agoBut you have a very easy way to differentiate group 2 from 1. Age...