4 ms·
From the article: “Did Freud get some things wrong?” says Lee Jaffe, the president-elect of the American Psychoanalytic Association. “Sure. But he also got man
by westoncb 9y ago
From the article:
“Did Freud get some things wrong?” says Lee Jaffe, the president-elect of the American Psychoanalytic Association. “Sure. But he also got many things right too.” Freud’s theories on unconscious mental processes, the importance of behavioral ambivalence and conflict, the origins of adult personality in childhood, mental representations as a moderator of social behavior, and stages of psychological development are all still relevant today. Freud also changed the public’s understanding of sex and desire, perhaps more than anyone else, by equating female desire with male desire. And, just by placing sexual desire and perversions into a “scientific” context, Freud freed sexuality from the largely religious context that focused on its moral degeneration or inherent criminality.
The ways in which he was wrong are much more nuanced than what you're suggesting.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- beagle3 9y agoFreud claimed that schizophrenia was a result of ambivalent mother care, and quite a few other things that he had no reason to claim (if it was science and not religion). He was wrong in many ways with no nuance whatsoever, but mostly, there isn't much in common between Freud and science. Which is basically what GP was saying. Freud deserves credit for taking psychology as a field of study mainstream - and the debit for founding it on religious principles which, unfortunately, still dominate quite a bit of it. His net contribution is usually assumed to be positive, but that's not an uncontested conclusion.