12 ms·
World's largest electric vehicle
- philipkglass 9y agoBecause the vehicle is electric, there is no need to “heat up” the brakes when descending. This is because the enormous electric engine acts as a generator and recharges the battery pack. That same energy is then used to help the vehicle travel back up the hill. Phys reports, “If all goes as planned, the electric dumper truck will even harvest more electricity while traveling downhill than it needs for the ascent. Instead of consuming fossil fuels, it would then feed surplus electricity into the grid.” Clever. It can do this because it travels uphill empty and comes downhill full.
- TheSoftwareGuy 9y agoHah. Never thought about harvesting the gravitational potential energy of garbage before.
- sushisource 9y agoWow. Thank you for pointing this out. The article does a terrible job and makes it seem like "Oh hey free perpetual motion"
- Z1nfandel 9y agoI thought the same, but then it made me wonder how many mines are built such that you are hauling ore down instead of up? I don't know enough about mines, and googling "most common mine design" isn't cutting it. Could anyone weigh in with more insight? The only big mines I've seen look to be pits, like the Bingham Copper Mine near SLC. I do remember reading something about ore trains in some Scandinavian country using regenerative braking to power nearby towns and its own trip back up.
- jandrese 9y agoUnless they are using this dump truck to fill in an old pit it doesn't seem like that should happen very often. The logistics of feeding the power back to the grid are also a bit wonky. Is it going to be dragging a cable behind it? Is there an inductive charge/discharge pad that it drives over? The article has no useful details on this, and the whole idea seems rather half baked.
- Fjolsvith 9y agoDoesn't an electric train have overhead power cables?
- grzm 9y agoDepends on the system. > An electric locomotive is a locomotive powered by electricity from overhead lines, a third rail or on-board energy storage such as a battery or fuel cell. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_locomotive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_locomotive
- razorunreal 9y agoWhy would feeding power back to the grid be any different from charging? When the battery gets full you'd plug in and mostly discharge it.
- aidos 9y agoI think that's a little unfair. I'm sure they've done the maths since they're building a massive electric truck. Maybe the article was overstating it a little but it certainly not technically impossible for it to store electricity and then release some of it once it's back up the top.
- hwillis 9y agoThink about it like this: mountains are places where deep mineral layers are pushed up into the surface, exposing them. It's where you find many of the dense, valuable ores without layers of dirt and non-valuable rock overtop. Mountains are actually great places to mine.
- ramy_d 9y agoexactly what I came here to find out. Thanks.
- jerf 9y agoThat's the first time in a while my "conservation of energy" mental alarm has false-positived. I could see "mere engineering" getting in the way of the dream but the energy checks out.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoI had the same intuition, but if anyone is out there wondering -- there's a hidden source of energy: all the energy that goes into arranging the trash at the top of the hill in the first place. So the energy that the truck is gaining is really the stored potential energy you got from the kinetic energy of bringing your food home from the store (or other similar things). I think the idea is really clever, to utilize that kind of latent stored energy to make your trip more efficient.
- hwillis 9y agoDump truck, not garbage truck. This one is transporting rock from a mine to a cement plant. It does not transport garbage. The mine is just on a mountain. Again, trash is not involved.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoDerp, reading comprehension. Same reasoning applies though, albeit other processes doing the lifting.
- hwillis 9y agotectonic drift, specifically.
- woodandsteel 9y agoI wonder if someone could come up with a more direct way of converting tectonic drift into electricity. The total amount of energy available would be stupendous, but there seems to be a problem with it being low-density from being spread over such a large area.
- schraitle 9y agoI wonder how much of a charge it needs to have at the beginning of the day in order to sustain itself via just the surplus from regen braking. The article mentions charging by 40kWh on a descent, which I take to mean that it's less than that to ascend.
- kazinator 9y agoRight, so it is basically a "middle man" which modifies the manner in which the cargo comes down the hill under gravity. An escalator that moves people down could conceivably work without any external power source other than the people.
- azernik 9y agoYup! Just less infrastructure investment and land use than the usual mining expedient of a giant conveyer belt.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThat had me pause as well. I'm still a bit dubious. Given potential energy is mass x grav x height, since the vehicle mass cancels top to bottom. You have load mass x grav * height of "extra" energy on the way down, which if you convert at 50% efficiency to charge would be a quantity of energy E which on the way up, if you have a 50% efficient power train would take the mass of the truck to the top of the hill. That suggests that the truck can carry 4x it's mass down hill. But in the phys.org article [1] it says it weighs 45 tons and can carry 65 tons. That is 44% additional mass. And because its linear 44% "additional" potential energy at the top. Which has to be converted twice (mechanical -> electrical, electrical -> mechanical). I'm not expecting them to meet their goal of producing excess energy. [1] weighing in at 45 tons when empty plus 65 tons of loading capacity -- https://phys.org/news/2017-09-e-dumper-world-largest-electric-vehicle.html https://phys.org/news/2017-09-e-dumper-world-largest-electri...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- brianwawok 9y agoSo how far is the trip down, 10 miles? The potential energy of moving 65 tons 10 miles down (think of pulling a rope with a 65 ton weight) is a freaking lot of energy.
- sp332 9y agoIt carries 45 tons + 65 tons downhill and then has to carry 45 tons back up. That's the hard part.
- brianwawok 9y agoWith 0 friction and 100% effeciency, the break even would be 45 tons of load? So this has 20 extra tons to make up for the various losses..
- hexane360 9y ago
- FussyZeus 9y ago> Clever. It can do this because it travels uphill empty and comes downhill full. Admitting up front I know very little about mining: Aren't most mines operating today of the strip variety? I.e. a big damn hole? My mental picture of the places most of these trucks operate is where they drive into the hole empty and come back out full, uphill. Am I wrong?
- hwillis 9y agoYes, according to wikipedia 85% of minerals and 98% of metal ore is produced by surface mining. Surface mining is above 300 m deep, and usually above 100 m. This includes mountaintop removal and highwall mining, which are still basically underground. Strip and pit mining are the other main types of surface mining. Even so this type of mining tends to happen in mountainous areas. Mountains are places where minerals are pushing up from deeper areas, and they're subject to more erosion, so you find a lot of valuable minerals. They are also colocated with seams, which are chock-full of minerals. Valleys and low spots are places where sediment accumulates and covers minerals, and are rarely worth mining. The altitude of a mine is usually much, much greater than the relatively negligible depth of the mine itself.
- FussyZeus 9y agoAh so it wouldn't be the mine itself that would be the uphill/downhill discussed, it's moreso the route from the mine to where the ore is processed. I got it now, thanks.
- rubenbe 9y agoIn a company created electricity metering, I heard a similar story of a train fetching logs in the mountains in Scandinavia. The train left the station in the valley empty and returned fully loaded with logs from the mountain. At first they didn't believe their own measurements, but it was effectively generating electricity.
- dwighttk 9y agoWill it produce enough electricity to offset the projects that move dirt uphill? What is the uphill/downhill ratio of dirt moved in the world?
- mmaunder 9y agoFinally. A perpetual motion machine. Never knew it would be a dump truck.
- bitmapbrother 9y agoA similar technology is used in Formula 1 to harvest energy during braking.
- randyrand 9y agoMost mining is the reverse. Travel downhill empty and uphill fill.
- woodandsteel 9y agoOk, but you are still sending the same weight of the truck up and down, so maybe this truck would save some money in that sort of case, too.
- robotresearcher 9y ago>> there is no need to “heat up” the brakes when descending I wonder why the journalist chose to use the scare quotes, as if the heating up was metaphorical.
- hydrogen18 9y agoProbably for "emphasis".
- robotresearcher 9y agoYeah, that seems to be a thing. But it has a "different effect" on me when I read it.
- hydrogen18 9y agoI "agree".
- kumarvvr 9y agoYeah no, since there is always some amount of loss, the energy gained back from moving downhill is always lesser than the energy spent going uphill.
- Baeocystin 9y agoNot if you add mass at the top of the hill.
- TwoBit 9y agoOK but what if it's hauling out of a pit?
- hwillis 9y agodepends if the pit is at the top of a hill or not. The hill is usually higher than the pit is deep (<100-300 m).
- matthew349hall 9y agoThis gave me pause as well but eventually made sense and I was like, "heck yeah that's awesome"
- samcheng 9y agoI'm surprised they didn't use one of the existing diesel-electric hybrid dump trucks as a base model. That seems like an easier conversion than converting a truck with a mechanical transmission. Here's an example diesel-electric hybrid dump truck: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebherr_T_282B https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebherr_T_282B
- mulmen 9y agoThat truck is an order of magnitude larger than the one in the article. I imagine that at some point hybrid electric power trains become a necessity but before that they are excessively complicated. Are there existing hybrid trucks of a similar size to the one in the article?
- hownottowrite 9y agoThe original article: https://www.empa.ch/web/s604/e-dumper https://www.empa.ch/web/s604/e-dumper
- ghostly_s 9y agoMods, can you change the link in the OP? For those who aren't familiar, Inhabitat is an extremely click-baity source and almost all their content is entirely credulous restatements of press releases or articles from other publications. As someone who follows sustainable architecture issues I categorically ignore anything they publish.
- dang 9y agoUrl changed to that from http://inhabitat.com/worlds-first-electric-dump-truck-stores-as-much-energy-as-8-tesla-model-s-cars/ http://inhabitat.com/worlds-first-electric-dump-truck-stores.... Thanks!
- ortusdux 9y agoThere are ore train cars that use regenerative braking on the way down the mountain, generating as much as 5x the power needed for the empty trip back up. Reportedly, they power the mining town at the top of the mountain. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regenerative_brake#Conversion_to_electric_energy:_the_motor_as_a_generator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regenerative_brake#Conversion_...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 0xFFFE 9y agoFor vehicle of that size to have a controlled descent using only the magnetic field (from the generator) as the braking force, it has to be one massive magnet, no? In which case, it is also adding to the overall weight of the vehicle.
- ars 9y agoIt needs the same size motor as the one used to drive it to the top. The forces are the same, just in the opposite direction.
- ericd 9y agoIt weighs a lot more coming down, since it's full.
- 0xFFFE 9y agoApologies if it sounds too dumb, but on the descent you have additional mass of your cargo that needs to be opposed by equal amount of braking force (magnetic or otherwise), on the ascent you have an unladen truck which needs lesser energy to move. So essentially the magnet has to be sized for the descent not for the ascent. Or am I completely missing something?
- ars 9y agoIt's not dumb at all. But this truck would need to be able to back up, make u-turns, etc, while fully loaded. So the motors must be strong enough to drive it uphill even when fully loaded, if only simply for the sake of positioning and maneuvers.
- sxates 9y agoI've heard people say that one reason why we shouldn't bother with electric cars is that they still generate a lot of carbon from their production supply chain. All the minerals and metals mined, the parts being shipped around, the energy in manufacturing, etc. But things like this demonstrate why that is the wrong way to look at it. We can, and absolutely should, electrify everything. The whole supply chain. The truck in the mine, the smelting factory, the assembly line, the warehouse, and the big rig that delivers it to you. There's no reason why every one of these couldn't run on renewable electricity. The only reason they don't is because until recently it was more expensive, but that is no longer true. The total lifecycle carbon impact of everything we make can go to nearly zero as all these points electrify and as our grid migrates over to renewables. That it can't happen all at once is no reason not to start.
- hwillis 9y ago>I've heard people say that one reason why we shouldn't bother with electric cars is that they still generate a lot of carbon from their production supply chain. All the minerals and metals mined, the parts being shipped around, the energy in manufacturing, etc. "A lot" = 15% more.[1] Approximately 1 ton of extra emissions, which it takes a daunting 4,900 miles to pay back- less than 5 months of the average American's driving. A great deal of this pollution comes from energy use- that report[1] says that if the grid was powered by 80% green energy then manufacturing a BEV would produce 25% less pollution than a normal car. [1]: http://www.ucsusa.org/sites/default/files/attach/2015/11/Cleaner-Cars-from-Cradle-to-Grave-exec-summary.pdf http://www.ucsusa.org/sites/default/files/attach/2015/11/Cle...
- sxates 9y agoRight, all things considered they're still less carbon intensive than and ICE car, especially with a few hundred thousand miles on the odometer. People seem to conveniently forget that an ICE car requires a lot of carbon to manufacture, and then creates even more with every mile driven. So even at the start the EV is ahead (or as your source says, within 5 months it's ahead).
- 9y ago
- elihu 9y ago> “Nickel manganese cobalt cells are also the choice of the German automobile industry when it comes to the next generation of electric cars,” Held said. Interesting claim. I'm not familiar with NMC batteries. Here's what wikipedia says: > Handheld electronics mostly use LIBs based on lithium cobalt oxide (LiCoO2), which offers high energy density, but presents safety risks, especially when damaged. Lithium iron phosphate (LiFePO4), lithium ion manganese oxide battery (LiMn2O4, Li2MnO3, or LMO) and lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxide (LiNiMnCoO2 or NMC) offer lower energy density, but longer lives and less likelihood of unfortunate events in real world use, (eg, fire, explosion, ...). Such batteries are widely used for electric tools, medical equipment, and other roles. NMC in particular is a leading contender for automotive applications. Lithium nickel cobalt aluminum oxide (LiNiCoAlO2 or NCA) and lithium titanate (Li4Ti 5O12 or LTO) are specialty designs aimed at particular niche roles. The newer lithium–sulfur batteries promise the highest performance-to-weight ratio. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-ion_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-ion_battery So, it's another kind of lithium-ion battery.
- hwillis 9y agoYeah. It's a subset of Li-ion. Tesla vehicles use NCA and their stationary storage products use NMC [1]. They are pretty similar but NCA is lighter and cheaper and NMC has better cycle life (and hence long-term value). It makes sense to use NMC for this application since weight is a non-issue. They're both significantly cheaper than LCO (the most common) and because of that NMC has become a lot more common than it was. They're also much better behaved (ie happy to put out high-power bursts, temperature-stable, and less likely to ignite), but last longer than other chemistries like FePO4 (which not well behaved but quite hard to ignite). [1]: http://fortune.com/2015/05/18/tesla-grid-batteries-chemistry/ http://fortune.com/2015/05/18/tesla-grid-batteries-chemistry...
- jonathanbull 9y agoMirror: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:JTEauvESZ4QJ:inhabitat.com/worlds-first-electric-dump-truck-stores-as-much-energy-as-8-tesla-model-s-cars/+&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=uk http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:JTEauvE...
- jordache 9y agoOnly 8x? Doesn't seem like that much? Maybe more aligned to the patterns in which the trucks are used.
- wongarsu 9y agoYou need enough charge to drive a short distance and do some maneuvering with a full truck, unload, get uphill with an empty truck, and get it loaded and drive a short distance fully loaded to the slope. From that point on you're back to charging the batteries from regenerative breaking while you're rolling downhill. That sounds very doable in the battery charge that allows a Tesla Model S to travel from LA to NY.
- wwarner 9y agoYa, this dump truck: 148 gal, compared to honda fit's 11 gal tank. That's like 13x. Tho the amount of energy on board only affects the range of the vehicle, so it's not that interesting. http://www.ritchiespecs.com/specification?category=Articulated%20Dump%20Truck&make=CATERPILLAR&model=740&modelid=91910 http://www.ritchiespecs.com/specification?category=Articulat...
- andrei_says_ 9y agoWhich makes me think: wouldn't it be nice if a Tesla or aforementioned dump truck could serve as a battery? An addition or alternative to a powerwall or whatever the tesla home battery's called?
- gyrgtyn 9y agoHigh tech green energy used to more efficiently strip mine/mountain top removal. Yay?
- hwillis 9y agoIn developed nations the use of raw materials is pretty much level- meaning that if it got cheaper there still wouldn't be that much of an increase in consumption. So the primary effect of something like this is to clean up mining that would happen anyway. In the grand scheme of things it's not that big a deal since the primary energy used to extract materials is an order of magnitude or two less than the energy used to process them. But still, the less oil we burn the better!
- agjacobson 9y agoI
- Abishek_Muthian 9y agoIt's good that they used existing truck base and focussed only on the fuel. But I couldn't see any data on actual efficiency/mileage, the whole article was focussed on how big the battery was on the big truck. "Its size and strength ensure it can transport materials from a mountain ridge to a valley 20 times per day." Is the only data on it's efficiency ?
- olivermarks 9y ago121 tons max loaded weight in original spec http://www.ritchiespecs.com/specification?type=con&category=Rock+Truck&make=Komatsu&model=HD605-7&modelid=93265 http://www.ritchiespecs.com/specification?type=con&category=... Be interested to know what range they anticipate from the 4.5 tons of batteries
- dom0 9y ago~infty / until the mechanical brakes are worn down after the battery is fully charged from driving.
- olivermarks 9y agoit seems to be a perpetual motion machine then? Just needs consumables such as brake pads repaired? The old UK milk floats had a range of 60-80 miles http://www.milkfloats.org.uk/faq.html http://www.milkfloats.org.uk/faq.html
- dom0 9y agoNo, perpetual motion means more energy from less. This moves mined rock downhill, so the work of moving it uphill was done by geological formation.
- wayanon 9y agoThank you to all those contributing insightful comments to this and other HN posts!, it’s why I visit daily.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- KGIII 9y agoI'm not sure the new/changed title is very good. Those giant earth movers, on tracks, that you see in mines are electric vehicles. They are just plugged in with giant cables. Well, some are. I presume some run on other power but I've not seen one.
- basicplus2 9y agoIgnoring one these in the electric version of course... http://www.hitachiconstruction.com/products/ex8000-6/ http://www.hitachiconstruction.com/products/ex8000-6/ https://youtu.be/VI57H89g3PA https://youtu.be/VI57H89g3PA
- hwillis 9y agoWell yeah. It doesn't really make sense to count it if it has to be plugged in.
- ctz 9y agoThis is not close to being the world's largest electric vehicle. Early submarines were electrically powered and more than twice the size (60ft vs ~30ft), eg. the Nautilus of 1886.
- keithpeter 9y agoAnd I thought of the humble metro trainset https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midland_Metro_rolling_stock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midland_Metro_rolling_stock 50-odd tonnes and I've witnessed zero to 80km/h in about 6 to 10 seconds or so. But, yes a nice big yellow machine running on batteries is an impressive milestone.
- dom0 9y ago1.3 m/s² is quite something, quite a bit more than a typical tram or S-Bahn (both ~1 m/s², which is still quite a pull...).
- keithpeter 9y agoThe drivers only do the high acceleration when the tram is mostly empty and no standing passengers I've noticed. For those in Birmingham UK: St Paul's to Jewellery Quarter is a longish bit of track just outside the city centre.
- pankajdoharey 9y agoThis is a classic example of stupid science reporting. For decades now the classic diesel engine locomotive used in trains and the electric trains themselves are the largest electric vehicles of any kind. The Komatsu heavy truck is anything but accurate example of "World's largest electric vehicle". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_locomotive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_locomotive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_locomotive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_locomotive And by the way all Diesel Submarines and Ships are also electric drive trains. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel%E2%80%93electric_transmission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel%E2%80%93electric_transm...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- konschubert 9y agoIt depends on how you define "electric vehicle". It is pretty clear that they mean "batttery driven, no engine attached". And in that context, their statement is correct.
- pankajdoharey 9y agoA vehicle (from Latin: vehiculum[1]) is a mobile machine that transports people or cargo. Typical vehicles include wagons, bicycles, motor vehicles (motorcycles, cars, trucks, buses), railed vehicles (trains, trams), watercraft (ships, boats), aircraft and spacecraft.[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle
- jlebrech 9y agoIsn't the ISS bigger?
- delecti 9y agoThe line can be blurred with space craft, but I'd argue that not having a destination makes the ISS more of a habitat than a vehicle, even though it's in constant motion.
- exabrial 9y agoThere was a copper mine in Arizona I went and toured about 5-7 years ago. The trucks were `diesel-over-electric` hybrids, but not fully electric. The shovel at the bottom of the pit was fully electric, with 4160volt 3-phase power lines delivering hundreds of amps. I believe the electricity was running a massive hydraulic pump on the shovel, making it also an interesting hybrid.
- pankajdoharey 9y agoSuch vehicles with Diesel-electric drive trains have existed since 1973. Like Terex_33-19_"Titan" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terex_33-19_%22Titan%22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terex_33-19_%22Titan%22