4 ms·
Biological plausibility is only silly if you assume that biology has NOT in ~4 billion years of evolution managed to explore the design space and arrive at good
by toss1 9y ago
Biological plausibility is only silly if you assume that biology has NOT in ~4 billion years of evolution managed to explore the design space and arrive at good general maxima/peak design for intelligent processes and are not merely stuck on the first local peak design encountered.
It assumes that outside of this biological design space lies both lower peaks and much higher unexplored peaks.
While it is likely that somewhere in the universe are higher peaks of design schemes for intelligence, it is also likely that those peaks are difficult to reach from here (4B+ years of evolution hasn't done it yet). It's also possible that the Fermi Paradox is showing is that there is no substantially better general design schema.
So, the more successful approach would probably be to seek designs for the first Automated General Intelligence in a design space that has already demonstrably succeeded, then perhaps use that AGI to search for other better design spaces.
- corey_moncure 9y ago1) One trouble with imitating biology is that stochastically driven processes tend to achieve maxima by exploiting environmental circumstances that are not intended or considered to be part of the design constraint. See for example the genetic-algorithm designed tone differentiator circuit on FPGA, which achieved extreme efficiency but the experimentors could not explain the circuit's behavior based on known theory, moreover, the circuit ceased to function correctly when tested outside of the lab it was 'grown' in. 2) Biology has to satisfy many constraints which are not hard limitations on artificial brains, such as: * Thermodynamics concerns, surface-area to volume ratio * A tightly controlled operating temperature of 97-99 F * Weight (wetware brains must float on CSF because they belong to moving animals) * Size
- jxy 9y agoPoint 1, we know. Just look at all kinds of the insects. Point 2, this reads as some advantages compared to our current computers.