3 ms·
It's true that we tax some sorts of "implicit income" but not others. Another example, which many people find very strange: taxing homeowners for their implici
by gnicholas 9y ago
It's true that we tax some sorts of "implicit income" but not others.
Another example, which many people find very strange: taxing homeowners for their implicit rental income:
Imagine Person A owns a house and lives in it. Person B owns one house, which he rents to someone else, and lives in a rented apartment. Person B has rental income and pays tax on it. Person A does not receive rental income (from himself) and therefore pays no equivalent tax (and also receives other tax preferences). In some ways, this appears to be inequitable. But to many people, it would be odd to tax a transaction that never explicitly happened (A only "paid himself rent" implicitly).
So a case can be made for taxing all sorts of things, some of which seem very odd to many/most people. Employer-provided parking will probably remain untaxed, just like employer-provided food often is.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoThe difference is that one is a business and the other isn't. A landlord can deduct depreciation on the building and operating expenses that the homeowner can't. And the homeowner pays income tax on the money used to buy the house.