8 ms·
Counterproductive effects of the commuter parking tax benefit
- sogen 9y agoI see tons of car ads... in SF of all places. Traffic is awful and sometimes it's way faster to just walk. The irony, most ads show a car in an empty highway.
- djrogers 9y ago>I see tons of car ads... in SF of all places. You realize that a small minority of the people seeing those ads actually live in SF, right? The TV stations showing those ads cover at least 9 counties, many of which have a higher population that the ~900k people living in San Francisco.
- iraphael 9y agoThey're probably referring to outdoors, posters, physical ads, physically located in SF.
- pweissbrod 9y agoBusinesses choose in their own self interest. If it takes me 40+ minutes longer to ride a subway than drive in (currently true) then it's both me and my employer's interest to reduce cost barriers and pay for the downtown parking. Tragedy of the commons with a touch of government inertia
- ropeladder 9y agoThe article is arguing against government subsidies, not business choices. Businesses are providing a benefit, parking, that is not taxed as income. If that benefit was taxed in the same way income was, it would be more expensive for both businesses and consumers and therefore businesses and consumers might make other choices about transit (or location). Further, I would argue that the time for your commute is to a large part determined by the available infrastructure (roads vs subway lines vs busses, for example), which is something the public has chosen to allocate funds for. There are certainly more and less efficient ways to move people around, and I'm not saying that cars are better or worse, just that the efficiency is partly a choice the public has made.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Brakenshire 9y agoThe issue also, why it take 40 minutes longer to take a subway than to ride in? That is not just the market, it's also often to do with zoning, separating residential and commercial, restricting height, and also things like requiring that all apartments have parking spaces. Similarly, policies prioritizing roads and parking in the city spread out the centre of the city, making it less pleasant to live in the centre rather than the suburb, and impractical for getting around on foot, or by public transport. A market might just as well be responding to government incentives, as much as driving the thing itself.
- JackFr 9y ago> Businesses choose in their own self interest. Thus if it's in their interest to lobby for a tax code with distortative effects, they will.
- Veratyr 9y ago> If it takes me 40+ minutes longer to ride a subway than drive in (currently true) then it's both me and my employer's interest to reduce cost barriers and pay for the downtown parking. Or it's in both your interests to decrease the time it takes to use public transport.
- brndnmtthws 9y agoAutomobiles are quite possibly one of the most harmful things in societies. Obesity, heart disease, diabetes, pollution, sprawl, time wasted going from A to B. My life improved dramatically when I decided to reject the automobile as a way of life. EDIT: I am of course referring to personal automobiles.
- valuearb 9y agoSince they've invented the automobile life expectancies and living standards have increased enormously worldwide, that is a real correlation.
- CalRobert 9y agoThe same could be said for nuclear bombs or silly putty.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- valuearb 9y agoNeither nuclear bombs or silly putty enabled the mass delivery of food and goods everywhere in the country, and for people to live outside of tiny apartments in congested cities in smaller towns and rural areas offering clean air, big yards, and more access to the outdoors. The fact that Americans have substantial increased their average living space and comforts is directly correlated with the spread of automobiles. The massive increase in food production is entirely caused by automation from the invention of farming equipment running off internal combustion engines.
- CalRobert 9y agoThis is a helpful, detailed, comment. Thanks. It contributes much more to the discussion than gp.
- brndnmtthws 9y ago
- valuearb 9y agoWe use the tax code to subsidize lots of stupid stuff and shouldn't do any of it if you want a fair, progressive tax system. Especially when running enormous deficits. Free parking should be reported as income, as should mass transit discounts/subsidies, such as healthcare subsidies, etc.
- CydeWeys 9y agoHow about subsidizing research/investment in renewable technologies to literally save the world?
- valuearb 9y agoWhy not institute a carbon cap and trading market, so internal combustion engines pay their external costs, and not subsidize anything? in that case renewable technology investment will be much more attractive without the costs of government picking ideas from only the best funded lobbyists (like Solyndra and the friends of Gore).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- to3m 9y agoThe UK does the same thing, too: https://www.gov.uk/expenses-and-benefits-parking-spaces/whats-exempt https://www.gov.uk/expenses-and-benefits-parking-spaces/what... I could never quite figure this out. It seems to be actually more hassle, in terms of paperwork and reporting, to pay for your employee to park a work vehicle during work hours while on a job made at your request (which is entirely a business expense) than it is to pay for them to have a reserved city centre parking space (which could easily have a significant personal benefit component). The other weird thing is: I don't even think the employee has to use it! Would their SO find such an arrangement useful? Well, there you go: they could use it instead! There really don't appear to be any restrictions on this stuff. It's extraordinary. On the flip side: this does mean, if you're negotiating a new job, maybe you could think about trying to get them to pay for a parking space for you, if that would be useful. Because it's entirely a business expense and so cheaper than raising the salary.
- frogpelt 9y agoThis is a simple concept. It's about liberty. People, Americans especially, want the liberty to come and go as they please, at the speeds they choose, by the path that they choose. I'm not sure every Bloomberg writer would understand that.
- lutorm 9y agoYet traffic means that you can, in practice, do none of these.
- minikites 9y agoA popular libertarian maxim is "Your rights end where my rights begin." This is usually ignored in discussions about unaccounted for externalities like pollution. Why do you have the right to pollute my (our) air with your automobile?
- rdiddly 9y agoSpoken like someone completely oblivious to the costs they're offloading onto everyone else. The liberty of people who want to breathe clean air, walk down streets that aren't noise- and fume-choked hellscapes, or who don't want to pay for your subsidies, the police & EMTs to show up & clean up your car wrecks - what of their liberty? It's a simple concept.
- danans 9y agoThat's fine, just pay for the societal costs you impose while exercising such a liberty. The article isn't is talking about taking away the liberty to drive, but rather not subsidizing it through tax loopholes. It's kind of a libertarian perspective, actually. EDIT: wording
- CalRobert 9y agoRelevant to some people here - https://www.arb.ca.gov/planning/tsaq/cashout/cashout.htm https://www.arb.ca.gov/planning/tsaq/cashout/cashout.htm Could net you a few hundred bucks a month if you don't use parking at work.
- afinlayson 9y agoAnd self driving cars, could make this worse. If your car has shocks for stop and go traffic as well as for bumps, you might not mind a 3 hour commute if you can instagram, and even do work from it. Meaning more people will live further away so they can get their half acre of land.
- payne92 9y agoBut self-driving cars never need to circle looking for a parking spot, and can head off to the dense "autopark" to hang out until you need a ride home. That will alleviate congestion.
- afinlayson 9y agoI would argue it just displaces it. Instead of you needing to walk to the parking lot and get jammed in after a high traffic event (Sports, or Concert), the auto parked cars will have issues getting out, and lining up in the street to pick everyone up.
- weberc2 9y agoHow is that worse than the same thing with human drivers? All of that parking lot space could be repurposed as loading space for humans, and more humans would probably be happy to use a cheaper ride-share service in which they can take the first available car instead of waiting for their personal vehicle to get through the line. (Note that ride-share isn't going to be "register with a particular car and wait for them to find you", but rather "get in the nearest available car"--automated taxis instead of automated Uber).
- jxcole 9y agoOr even better: it will drive off to pick up random people in an Uber/Lyft scenario, so your car makes you a small amount of money while you're working by itself.
- rb808 9y agoWould be cheaper to slowly drive around congested areas.
- jmull 9y agoCharacterizing employer-provided parking as a fringe benefit is a poor way to frame this debate. The benefit is to the employer, not the employee. Proposing to tax this as an employee benefit will likely sidetrack this and raise emotions due to the unfairness. That's too bad because there is a real problem and a tax may very well be the best way to solve it.
- marlokk 9y agoYes let's tax anything that bothers anyone. I'm sure this will lead to a bother-free utopia.
- x3n0ph3n3 9y agoAt my company, commuter parking perks only apply when driving to and parking at a transit station, then taking public transit to work. That seems like a net benefit for society vs driving the entire distance to work.
- mgreg 9y agoInteresting dive into the tax code. I wonder how the article would have read if the author researched the amount of subsidies that go into public transportation. Public transport subsidies are a very material portion of most city budgets as rider's fares typically pay for less than half the cost of running the bus/subway/light rail system. As an example San Francisco spends about $1 billion of its $9 billion city budget funding Muni - more than 10% of the entire city budget.
- rileymat2 9y agoI am not sure how it was calculated but the article did do that (but it seems like an underestimation): "True, there’s also a tax benefit for mass-transit commuters that costs the government about $1.3 billion a year. TransitCenter says that while it’s good as far as it goes, “it is overshadowed by the parking tax benefit’s much larger adverse impact.”"
- mgreg 9y agoYou're correct but this tidbit also exposes the article's limited scope. It's sweeping the cost of public transportation under the rug and then providing unsubstantiated opinion on the "adverse impact" of the thing the author doesn't like. To be clear I'm not arguing for or against parking or public transportation. But I do think we should be forming policies with more data and less opinion.
- turc1656 9y agoThat's not quite the same thing. What you quoted is referring to the IRS tax exemption for the first $255 per month spent on approved commuting costs (parking and mass transit). What mgreg refers to is the direct money that is used to fund/subsidize the cost of operating bus/train networks in urban areas. The cost of those tickets are less than they would be without the subsidies. These are two totally separate things.
- c3534l 9y agoSubsidies go into public transit, but for a reason. Even if you drive and never use public transportation you benefit from it by having freer movement in the roads. The whole point isn't that such a subsidy exists, it's asking whether it's a subsidy we actually want to be making. Additionally, it's not surprising that it makes up a large portion of city budgets, because city governments have the most narrow and local focus of any other in America. They're often not even on the level of county government, let alone state government.
- zaroth 9y agoThe IRS says companies must place a fair market value on free parking they provide, and must report as income any value of free parking in excess of $255/month. Compliance with this reg is likely minimal. It seems to me if I have to drive to a specific location to perform a job-task, the expense of getting there and parking there is a deductible business expense. This is true as long as you are not regularly commuting to a place of business. Once you start regularly commuting, the cost of the commute is no longer a deductible business expense. And if you are being given a place to park worth more than ~$10/day you're supposed to pay full load of taxes on that "income". So, if for example, you regularly work from home, you can deduct the cost of going into the office. That's a huge subsidy for working from home at least 50% of the time which this report totally ignores. To claim that not taxing as income the first $10/day in parking value provided as a fringe benefit is a $7b tax subsidy seems a bit of a stretch. The company also likely provides air conditioning in the office, do we tax that as income too? To say nothing of food catering, onsite gym, etc. I read the actual report linked in the article and IMO it comes off as somewhere between "progressive money-grab" to "bat-shit crazy." The reality is the IRS has a long-standing "don't ask don't tell" policy around all kinds of benefits that companies provide employees which are "technically gross income" but in practice are never actuallly counted as such. A common example is the value of frequent flier miles. Here's a paper on the subject: http://scholarship.law.duke.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3373&context=dlj http://scholarship.law.duke.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=... Referenced in that is another paper called "Defining Income" which seems to be the definitive paper on this topic? https://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=037082122068089013077101079007096005123025053058021063112099086101084008024073089028096120057028116036040111020086004101004028039017049060086094125099080064098106032012081095073085089118110123007010084117075092084116118121093030081112112079116117103&EXT=pdf https://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=0370821220680890...
- zaroth 9y agoThat last link is a gem -- here's a great quote from it; "Gross income is all accessions to wealth, clearly realized, over which the taxpayer has dominion unless excluded by statute, or by the IRS's never having attempted to tax them, or by the IRS's having announced an administratively created exclusion pursuant to no specific authority whatsoever." The paper explains the historical definition of income as meaning, "the realized product of labor or capital." That definition was challenged before the Supreme Court back in 1955 Glenshaw Glass when the IRS claimed punitive damages were taxable as income. Before Glenshaw, punitive damages were considered a windfall, and as neither a product of labor or capital, not income and therefore not taxable. Some specific examples of accessions to wealth, clearly realized, which are not taxed by the IRS for no reason other than administrative fiat are; child support payments, welfare payments such as TANF, and Medicaid. I supposed you could add "parking at the office" to that list. Another great example in that paper -- the cost of traveling to a job interview in another state. The reimbursement of that cost is clearly income under statute, but not taxed. Thankfully so! Are fish income when you catch them from the sea? Are minerals income when you pull them from the ground? Are Bitcoin income when you mine them? No, No, and YES!
- treehau5 9y ago> the government is subsidizing commuters to drive themselves to work instead of carpooling or taking mass transit or walking or biking or working from home. I would imagine in the majority of scenarios this is a false choice. There simply is no reasonable alternative. Our city planning was piss poor and thought it was a good idea to emulate Atlanta when it comes to road building (i.e. build them wherever the hell, with no rhyme or reason). Biking: not an option. Working from home? If I were to be so lucky. Second, not much thought was given to the economic impact of those commuters.
- emodendroket 9y agoWell, yes, that, and also, lots of people are going to drive to the train or bus station and park there, so we're not talking about two disjoint sets.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gnicholas 9y agoIt's true that we tax some sorts of "implicit income" but not others. Another example, which many people find very strange: taxing homeowners for their implicit rental income: Imagine Person A owns a house and lives in it. Person B owns one house, which he rents to someone else, and lives in a rented apartment. Person B has rental income and pays tax on it. Person A does not receive rental income (from himself) and therefore pays no equivalent tax (and also receives other tax preferences). In some ways, this appears to be inequitable. But to many people, it would be odd to tax a transaction that never explicitly happened (A only "paid himself rent" implicitly). So a case can be made for taxing all sorts of things, some of which seem very odd to many/most people. Employer-provided parking will probably remain untaxed, just like employer-provided food often is.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoThe difference is that one is a business and the other isn't. A landlord can deduct depreciation on the building and operating expenses that the homeowner can't. And the homeowner pays income tax on the money used to buy the house.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoIt's amazing the return on mass transit spending. The property values are massively increased in cities with mass transit, the economy is massively increased in cities where it's easy for employees to get to work, the environment has less smog going into it from cars, citizen mobility is increased which increases quality of life and their ability to spend the money they make at their jobs....and on and on. There's just endless returns on mass transit.