5 ms·
>Gaming is maybe the one mainstream application where local compute is important. There are a ton of things our smartphones and tablets do that rely on very hi
by simonh 9y ago
>Gaming is maybe the one mainstream application where local compute is important.
There are a ton of things our smartphones and tablets do that rely on very high levels of local computing power.
Biometric authentication such as face and fingerprint recognition is a heavily compute intensive application. It needs to be done locally in order to be secure. Face ID is just nuts.
Modern smartphone photography is heavily compute-intensive, from HDR to optical zoom to image editing and markup. Just look at what Apple is doing with portrait mode and lighting effects. I love using time-lapse and slow-motion video modes. What would instagram and snapchat be without locally applied filters?
Note taking, address book and time management. The notes apps on modern mobile devices are multi-media wonders with integrated text, image and handwriting recognition built-in. Calendar management, alarms and notifications all rely on local processing even if they do make use of cloud services. Without local smarts those services would lose a huge chunk of their utility.
Document and media management. I read eBooks and listen to podcasts. My ebook reader has dynamic font selection, text size adjustment and will even read my books to me. Managing media on the device is essential as contemporary networks are still nowhere near good enough to stream everything all the time. My podcast app has sound modulation and processing options built in to tailor the sound to my tastes and needs, including speed up, voice level adjustment and dead-air 'vocal pause' elimination in real-time, all on-device and adjustable at my fingertips. That's serious sound studio level stuff in my pocket.
Playing digital video files. Even ones downloaded or streamed. So what if we've had it since the 90s. It's still proper computation, especially with advanced modern codecs. VOIP and video calling even between continents have also become everyday and absolutely rely on powerful local number crunching.
These things have become so everyday that we hardly notice most of them, but without serious on-device processing power, some of which would have been beyond $10k workstations just 15 years ago, none of this would be possible.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoYou are kinda missing OP's point. It is true that today's phones are several order of magnitudes more powerful that those of 50 years ago, but OP's point is that we are kinda still in the paradigm where a lot of the computing we rely on happens on remote servers. So, while the computing power of the 80s is very well accessible to us, our needs have grown far beyond that and are only serviceable using remote servers. Take Google Search itself for example.
- simonh 9y agoIm not missing any point. >...this is a valid argument today. While today's equivalent of terminals (phones, tablets, and even PCs) have a significant amount of local computing ability, for the most part they really are just used as fancy terminals. The argument that we don't need or use local computing power is not valid. The nuance you are imagining isn't there. Of course networked services are incredibly valuable. But most of them would be useless without local client software and there are plenty of things we use mobile devices for now where online services are just a convenient adjunct to powerful local applications. 'For the most part' almost every time I use my phone I unlock it using locally running fingerprint recognition software and interact with a high performance animated graphical user interface, regardless of what else I do with it. You can't wish these things away as irrelevant just because you've got used to them.
- jamespo 9y agoToday's GUI is yesterday's terminal
- KGIII 9y agoI am still sort of baffled by this trend. In my pocket, I have a device with capabilities of a supercomputer from not that many years ago. So do many other people. Yet, with all this, we're slowly reverting to the days of the dumb terminal. The concept of data ownership is all but dead. Even trivial things, like word processors, are being moved to the cloud and more things are requiring connectivity.
- simonh 9y agoBut then a huge chunk of the smarts in e.g. Google Docs is in the JavaScript you're executing locally. Just because you download the code at runtime doesn't change the fact your device is doing a ton of local computation to make that application work. A lot of web apps like that are actually local JavaScript apps with a relatively dumb web storage backend. Then again I mainly use google docs using the native app on my iPad.
- Theodores 9y agoYears ago when I had a VAX to work with, the terminal was happy with user name and password. Your supercomputer phone might have classy iris scanning stuff but it is merely unlocking the terminal. Okay there is no remote authentication to it but it is the same conceptually. Everything else apart from things like the clock are client server.
- com2kid 9y ago> My podcast app has sound modulation and processing options built in to tailor the sound to my tastes and needs, including speed up, voice level adjustment and dead-air 'vocal pause' elimination in real-time, all on-device and adjustable at my fingertips. Everything short of the vocal pause stuff an old Sansa will do for you, running a tiny embedded C based runtime. > These things have become so everyday that we hardly notice most of them, but without serious on-device processing power, some of which would have been beyond $10k workstations just 15 years ago, none of this would be possible. The modern photo and video stuff is super cool and uses a ton of processing power. Likewise for high quality video streaming, decompressing is hard work, though often offloaded to HW these days. Everything else my desktop of 15 years ago handled just fine, with 256MB of RAM. Heck my smartphone in 2006 with 64MB of RAM did most of this stuff. The one thing that has remained constant across a decade of smart phone development is the Pandora app getting forced closed all the time.
- DigitalJack 9y ago"Everything else my desktop of 15 years ago handled just fine, with 256MB of RAM." I hear this sort argument a lot. But I never hear of anyone doing it, that is working on a 15 yr old computer for a while. I imagine with Linux it might not be too bad.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoIt's because software accrues bloat on all layers of the stack, so that even as functionality stays the same, performance requirements increase pretty much in lockstep with hardware power. And since each piece of software tends to have its own format, and/or is tied to its own cloud, it's harder and harder to exchange data between old and new programs. So people keep upgrading. If you look at places where there isn't much pressure, you'll see plenty of old hardware and software doing just fine. For example, many shops I frequent are run on DOS-era programs, which are 100% totally fine for the job, and probably even better than modern replacements (less clicking, more typing = more efficient to use).
- groovy2shoes 9y ago
- andai 9y agoWhat podcast app do you use?
- mmirate 9y ago> It needs to be done locally in order to be secure You know that. I know that. Technical personnel generally know that. "The suits", however, will find some way to profit from collecting biometric data, at which point "appealing to security" will cease to be relevant (to them).
- Amygaz 9y agoWhile waiting for a better network in every part of globe, we do need local power like you described. But, none of your examples couldn't be implemented remotely, and be more powerful if implemented remotely. We have all the tech to have faster and better bandwidth, it's just a financial implementation problem (i.e. 'some dudes need to have their bank accounts happy' kind of problem).