4 ms·
> "We don't have a gas gauge. It would be really nice if we did," Molly Bittner, a systems engineer at JPL who has worked on Cassini for the past four years, te
by dmix 9y ago
> "We don't have a gas gauge. It would be really nice if we did," Molly Bittner, a systems engineer at JPL who has worked on Cassini for the past four years, tells NPR. Instead, mission controllers had to estimate the amount of fuel used by each maneuver. And there had been lots of maneuvers since 2004.
Does anyone know why they couldn't have a way to measure the amount of fuel left? This seems like a relatively easy engineering problem from a non-expert perspective.
- clarkmoody 9y agoIf you know the thrust of the engine, then you can calculate the mass of the spacecraft based on how the orbit changes given a certain engine burn. I assume the dry mass of the craft is known to high certainty, so (almost) everything else is propellant.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 9y agoThe conventional method is a float valve, which obviously doesn't work in space. Putting a sensor in the tank also involves drilling a hole, which compromises its strength. I think the simple answer is that they didn't need it, so they left it out and relied on highly accurate predictions of fuel usage.
- dmix 9y agoTrue, they probably didn't need to solve the problem of directly measuring fuel in low gravity, given the thousands of other problems they needed to solve. Apparently this is a common problem with satellites as well: > “Traditional gauging methods tend to have wider error bands as the tank empties" > Measuring how much fuel remains in an operating spacecraft has been a matter of educated guesswork. It is calculated either by book-keeping – estimating the fuel used on every thruster burn – or using a pressure sensor to estimate from headspace gas pressure how much liquid fuel is left. Unfortunately, book-keeping can be as much as 10% too high or too low, while the gas method consistently overestimates fuel reserves. https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn11254-new-spacecraft-fuel-gauge-may-reduce-space-junk/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn11254-new-spacecraft-...
- bashinator 9y agoThere's not actually gas, or a tank. Most space probes like this are powered by radioactive decay of a plutonium core.
- greglindahl 9y agoCassini is far too old to have ion thrusters -- and even ion thrusters use reaction mass. There is a plutonium RTG that generates electricity. That's used for heaters and powering the science instruments and communications gear.
- jakebasile 9y agoThat's used to generate electricity. The spacecraft still use propellant when they need to generate thrust.
- branchan 9y agoOrbital maneuvers are so precise that when they say 'estimate', they are probably still talking about a small margin of error.