5 ms·
Just for the record, Goodman's problem was solved by David Deutsch who profoundly observed that languages are theories. The grue/bleen theory has embedded with
by lisper 9y ago
Just for the record, Goodman's problem was solved by David Deutsch who profoundly observed that languages are theories. The grue/bleen theory has embedded within it the unmotivated (and false, though that's a detail) hypothesis that there is something special about some particular date which has been picked out of a hat and embedded into the theory in order to make Goodman's pedantic point. It is this arbitrariness and lack of motivation that invalidates the grue/bleen theory (which is actually a whole family of theories parameterized by the magic date) from a scientific point of view.
There are examples of words that have times embedded in them that are actually reflective of natural phenomena and hence constitute valid theories, like "main-sequence" (with regard to stars).
- wickawic 9y agoI like that response, but to me it raises the question as to what incorrect theories might be embedded into our daily (or even scientific) language.
- JadeNB 9y ago> There are examples of words that have times embedded in them that are actually reflective of natural phenomena and hence constitute valid theories, like "main-sequence" (with regard to stars). Of course one shouldn't expect the philosophy of science to hold to the same rigour as science itself, but this seems just to be shifting the goalposts. Of course, you and I know that the definition of 'grue' is arbitrary and unmotivated, because it is made to be so; but how can one define when a hypothesis in a seriously propounded scientific hypothesis is arbitrary and unmotivated? If the test for whether a theory is a good description of natural phenomena is whether it is a good description of natural phenomena (to take your exact words, whether it is "actually reflective of natural phenomena"), then it seems that we have substituted a tautology for a paradox to no particular gain in understanding.
- lisper 9y agoNo, because language itself can be empirically and even mathematically grounded. The fact that I can say to a shop-keeper, "Please give me an apple" and with odds much greater than chance end up in a particular state that I call "having an apple" is evidence that the word "apple" really does correspond to something meaningful in the physical world. Here's a more detailed explanation: http://blog.rongarret.info/2015/03/why-some-assumptions-are-better-than.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2015/03/why-some-assumptions-are-...
- mannykannot 9y agoOccam's razor addresses that question, I believe - if there is a time-independent alternative that just as good an explanation and is simpler overall, it is taken to indicate that the posited time-dependence is spurious.
- theoh 9y agoDeutsch is a physicist. Unless you can provide evidence of prominent philosophers applauding his contribution, it seems a bit glib to say he solved the problem posed by Goodman. It's their conversation, they get to decide what's admissable or satisfying as an answer.
- philsnow 9y ago> Deutsch is a physicist. so was Einstein. physics, philosophy, math, and a lot of other fields reward being able to find simplicity / symmetries. it's probably best to not discount people or their theories just because of a label attached to them.
- theoh 9y agoActually, I was trying to get at the fact that disciplines do operate like conversations: you can make an unsolicited contribution from outside to a philosophical discussion, but it's unlikely to be well received. The HN crowd probably has no difficulty seeing how this would be the case with e.g. (a recent example discussed here) "trisectors". Well, philosophy has its cranky outsiders too, up to and including Hawking (arrogantly?) declaring philosophy obsolete.
- lisper 9y agoLOL. Physics and philosophy used to be synonyms. The reason we distinguish them today is that in 1687 Isaac Newton got the bright idea that truth could be distinguished from falsehood by looking at how the world actually behaves. Those who subscribed to that idea are today called "physicists" and those who chose to reject it and continue to engage in intellectual circle-jerks untethered from reality are called "philosophers." There's a reason that "experimental philosopher" is an oxymoron. The whole idea of a "prominent philosopher" having anything meaningful to say about the world is laughable, not because philosophers can't come up with good ideas, but because "prominence" in the philosophy world is not gained by coming up with good ideas, but rather by coming up with ridiculous ideas like grue and bleen which seem deep if you ignore reality, but crumble immediately if you don't.
- mannykannot 9y ago
- scooble 9y agoI would be more inclined to view that as a solution if it didn't seem like a restatement of an objection anticipated by Goodman in the original paper. The time-sensitive nature of 'grue' and 'bleen' arises because we take 'green' and 'blue' as basic, and define 'grue' and 'bleen' in relation to them. If we took 'grue' and 'bleen' to be basic, then our definitions of 'green' and 'blue' would be the ones with the additional time parameter. The idea of language as a hypothesis sounds a bit fishy in general. Not least because hypotheses generally need to be expressed in a language. Which language should we use to test other languages? I am also not sure whether it makes sense to take about languages as being false. And presumably, since it appears that English and Japanese constitute different hypotheses about colour, which one is the false hypothesis, and what constitutes good evidence against it?